K Final DTManalysis. Sorry for the lateness since work and soreness from the gym and all.
@Milk/Thomith Page 2-3 Stuffs.
It took a few rereads but looking at Milk's POV: The vote and the RQS statement are independent things. It took me a few re-reads but there seems to be some blending of both RQS arguments with the votes assuming you take Milk's side. I can agree on a theory standpoint how
how RQS is not scummy but makes Milk view their play differently. These cues are best used for meta - alignment link analysis.
I'm ok for the stance that RQS is fluffy (hence my original post this game) which leads to fruitless advances. I'm ok with Milk's reasoning with player trend analysis. But otherwise I find these pages more about mafia theory and less about actual interactions. It doesn't seem to be a strong argument for this early case.
However I dislike Thomith's followup to his Milk vote. Particularly the "cautious" reasoning of Mormon. I was fine with him following a person's case if he felt that it's a good one. I'm not fine when Thomith's Mormon analysis because to me when I read between the lines it doesn't seem like a person should be convinced by a cautious person's vote. If a person has a good case I would be more suspect of the lack of voting (i.e Mormon) because this could be an early bus attack link (i.e Mormon-bork) or something fishy like that. Seeing how Thomith admitted that there should be doubt in Mormon's character I see this more of someone latching on to a case in a lazy manner, which is scummy in my eyes.
@Mormon
This post is scummy to me. Mainly because caution at this stage of the game shouldn't be an issue with exception to L-1 quick votes. Which it in self is informative. For a game of this caliber I expect town to be more competent to avoid quick hammers. Thus if a quick hammer occured on an early day 1 wagon, we actually narrow down the pool for scum targets (or should be able to) since only scum would push a wagon so fast.
Like wise if we do run up a powerrole, the need to claim isn't present for this stage of the game. That person won't be lynched because I expect town to recognize the context of the wagon (i.e. early day 1).
Finally if we do have town that sheep wagons like so, we have more serious problems then outing PRs since our day play would be severely compromised due to player style in game rather then any other repercussions of losing PRs. In other words scum would play to be the leaders of this kind of crowd since that's far stronger then lynching PRs.
So this comment pings on my scumdar for the above reasons. Caution at this stage really isn't necessary for competent town. Reaction tells garnered by this phase will set up a solid foundation for future reads and the later phases.
@URoE
Town read for the following reasons:
a. Actually using my question as a basis for pressure attacks on Humble. I was looking to see how people would handle it and to me this is kind of a unique way to attack someone (i.e scum hunt).
b. Gut reads/vibes from defending Aragua on Page 2.
@Techno
a. Twitchy? I'm impressed that you could see my physical body writhing awkwardly from some text on an internet forum. (/bad joke) That aside I'm confused to why the scum read in particular. Details please.
b. Aside from that I noticed a scummy activity.
You failed to follow up on Roflcopter
. Between your Post 63
here to
Roflcopter's post of questions on page 4 here and your
response here later that day I noticed you
failed to follow up on your very own scum case
. Townies care about their own cases. Townies don't forget when someone fails to answer the question. This is scummy since you didn't follow up on your own case.
THIS REEKS OF DISTANCING. CALLING IT NOW, EARLY TECHNO AND ROFLCOPTER linkage to be scum buddies since reading between the lines this looks like distancing between the parties.
@Sensfan
Seacore beat me to the punch but I don't see how significant does not equate to an alignment read. I don't get it. It's like you're framing for the bussing argument but there's no punch line. Also town reads when you admitted that there isn't a lot to make alignment calls? CONTRADICTION GALORE.
Tl DR:
Scum = Sensfan
Scum Partners = Roflcopter/Techno
Must look into = Mormon
Town reads = self explanatory if you've read.
Trio I pick to lynch, the first 3. Done and done. Time for some sleep.
