Open 435: Great Idea Mafia (Day 4)

[Axxle]

VOTE: Vote: CDB

Hopefully he's as easy to read as scum here as in IRL.

[Axxle]

I'm only gonna be voting for people who weren't at Scummer of Love for the foreseeable future. <3

Buddying up with half of us already?

[Axxle]

Sure. You said, "let me look at your previous games." then the next post, literally 5 minutes later, you unvote.

Kondi, can you explain this? Why are the posts so close together? For now:
VOTE: Kondi

[Axxle]

I'm also failing to see why zoraster is voting for evilpacman instead of kondi? his reasons make kondi seem more scum and evilpacman missing subtle things like posting time.

[Axxle]

zoraster, why did you unvote pacman?

[Axxle]

Also:

@mod: My vote should be on kondi

[Axxle]

I'm not sure I like the izak lynch. His interaction with GAR seems like town frustrated with antitown town. And his reaction to the dayvig seemed town as well.

VOTE: yellowbounder

I see very little content in this guy's posts.




I don't really like hydras in general. Part of me feels like it's unbalanced because it's giving one of the teams a voteless player (confirmed to one other player) that can still think for one of the teams. I think that claiming at least one head might help with meta, but other than that I think it'd probably be fine if they didn't.

[Axxle]

I disagree with post 258

[Axxle]

If I claimed a PR, would everyone love me, too?

You're already getting plenty of love yb.

[Axxle]

Maybe he's an SK, and just trying to bamboozle us? He's not being very helpful to the town.

Interested in reactions.
VOTE: evilpacman
L-1.

Yellowbounder: What reactions did you get from this? What did it tell you of people's alignments?

[Axxle]

also intend to hammer izak. McStab commenting very little on that is telling.

[Axxle]

read me as a doctor (which i am)

There were four kills yesterday. You are terrible at your job, heh.

[Axxle]

why micky s?

[Axxle]

Quilford

- 277 and then 305 are disturbingly parodic i-am-buddies-with-yellowbounder posts. 305 seems a really dumb one for a player like Quilford to make if it is what it looks like but 277 is more convincing. If there's a third mafia buddy, it's probably Quilford.

VOTE: Quilford

[Axxle]

Izak, why did you target Mcstab? The only reference you have to him is this:

I do not think you're scum. I have seen both town and scum behave in this way, so I'm not judging you on this argument, at least not yet. More to the point, since almost all your posts have been arguing with me so far,

what's so scummy about McStab

, or your other scumreads?

[Axxle]

Oh and UNVOTE: Quilford

[Axxle]

So this is either MYLO or LYLO or even Lynch correctly and lose? What do you guys think of a No Lynch?

[Axxle]

Cop

Katsuki and petapan aren't mafia...

[Axxle]

Can't read katsuki for shit. Peta was the last one left on the yb wagon.

[Axxle]

Mr. X, who do you think is scum?

[Axxle]

I just don't see Mr. X bringing CDB into Lylo when both me and JD were CDB's prob-town reads.

[Axxle]

I think I'll be voting CDB.

It feels like he's been molding me and JD the entire game for lylo.

But first: CDB, you followed izak to a NK, what took you so long to vote for him?

[Axxle]

Hmm... That was a good answer cdb. But I really think that No Lynch is the thing to do here.

If we no lynch:
2m, 1w, 1t: Doesn't matter
1m, 2w, 1t: Doesn't matter
2m, 2t: Impossible situation
1m, 1w, 2t: We lose if we lynch here.
1m, 3t: Better chance of narrowing it down, especially with power roles. However we'd lose if it's mafia dayvig, only one of the 5 remaining mafia roles.

Talked myself into it:

VOTE: No Lynch

[Axxle]

... that fails to explain the night kills. There's at least 1 mafia left.

[Axxle]

... that fails to explain the night kills. There's at least 1 mafia left.

So we should no lynch and hope they kill each other, according to your theory.

[Axxle]

Cdb, should we coordinate our actions or just use them independently?

[Axxle]

Er, well, I mean, it was completely obvious that I had to be scum there. Elton had me with my pants down.

I was pretty sure you were scum after I died, since I really doubt Mister X would want to 1v1 you instead of me.

[Axxle]

He couldn't have left you alive if he were scum. Your investigation would have screwed him as much as it would me.

It would have just been my word against his, much like it was your word against his.

[Axxle]

Hmm... true. Hard to say what I wouldn't done in that situation.

[Axxle]

Hmm... true. Hard to say what I wouldn't done in that situation.

*wouldv'e

[Axxle]

I LIKE LOVERS K SHUT UP

"All the world loves a lover"