Mini 1379 - Game Over!

[Axxle]

AP hid behind UN, he breadcrumbs that time and time and time again, just read his iso. Tell me where he hints hiding behind anyone else at all?

@Trollie, I pretty much don't see a scenario where I don't vig UN (barring his lynch I guess).

[MattP]

Day 3

Axxle ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

BBmolla ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

CooLDoG ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

havingfitz ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

Kimor ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

mastin2 ( 5 )

[/color]

(L - 0 )

CooLDoG, UberNinja, BBmolla, havingfitz, Kimor [[LYNCH!!!]]
redtail896 ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

UberNinja ( 1 )

[/color]

(L - 4 )

Axxle
No Lynch ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 5 )

Not Voting ( 2 ) mastin2, redtail896

Total Votes ( 8 )

Needed to Lynch [ 5 ]

Deadline: November 3rd at 6:00PM EST

[MattP]

mastin2 was lynched Day 3. He was a 1-Shot Doctor.

There are three scum left and four town left. No town remaining have any roles permitting them to prevent the mafia from killing a townie, meaning that scum will be equal in size to town tomorrow, thus fulfilling their wincon.

Scum, consisting of Kimor (Mafia Goon), UberNinja (Mafia Goon), and havingfitz (Mafia Goon), win!

Axxle, the Universal Backup (1-Shot Cop Backup) has been endgamed.

CooLDoG, the 1-Shot Vigilante, has been endgamed.

redtail896, the Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.

BBmolla, the Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.

________________________

Mod Notes: So, this was my first time modding and I made two mistakes which allowed two extra posts from TheTrollie that implicated scum. I apologize for this, but I did feel that it was fair to finish the game. I am completely open to criticism/feedback. Thank you for taking part in my first modded game, I really appreciate all of your efforts. BTW, this game is perfect proof that whoever is scummy in the first 5 pages is most likely scum, because you guys were on scum immediately and if you stuck with that you would have won.

Town MVP goes (unfortunately lol) to TheTrollie for picking out the scum quickly and going after them persistently, directing the town to them. I do think that your TACTICS to convince town to follow your lead were not incredibly strong and consisted of a lot of cases rather than succinct, convincing point, but you did manage to make the town a more cohesive entitity.

AngryPidgeon did a decent job but you should focus on being more effective with what you post. You immediately made yourself a social pariah by being obstinate about spamming the thread, which caused you to be a lot less convincing when you starting getting on the right track.

Axxle played a very good game, and I'm excited to see what comes from you in the future. Your scumdar is pretty well tuned you're very good at being concise and effective. Unfortunately the town was completely fucked in lylo due to a discouraged townie (BBmolla) and a delusional one (CooLDoG babe)

BBmolla, WTF

CooLDoG, WTF

mastin2, you pulled yourself together endgame and I thought you were very obvious town, but maybe I was just biased. Idk, I thought your case the last day was very convincing, it was just a shitty position to be in in lylo

redtail896, you should have pushed harder. You were too reserved this game. However, you at least were on the right track but you just got bored a lot or didn't push hard enough and would either resolve to subpar lynches (RM) or be unable to aggressively push your desired lynch.

Slandaar, you were spot on and you would have ripped scum a new ass if you lived, sorry 'bout that. I think if you lived past D1 the outcome of this game would have been entirely different.

RobertMontana, your "kill me and you'll enjoy my mislynch" thing was bad news bears. I would have lynched you too.

Fancy-Pants I don't remember your play, you died too fast

[MattP]

Night 1:
Pine (mafia goon) kills Slandaar (successful)
Slandaar (1-shot cop) investigates havingfitz (action failed)
Axxle (universal backup) becomes a 1-shot Cop (passive ability)

Night 2:
AP (1-shot hider) hides behind UN (successful, dies)
Mastin2 (1-shot doctor) protects TheTrollie (successful)
Axxle (universal backup turned to 1-shot cop) investigates mastin2 (successful)
CooLDoG (1-shot vig) vigs Trollie (failed action)
UberNinja (mafia goon) mafia kills Trollie (failed actions)

[MattP]

Scum QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/P82wUwVHcev

Dead QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/rbg4wV3rGRn

[Axxle]

Scum had day chat? I'm really surprised none of them claimed a power role.

Also:

[Axxle]

MattP, the one critique is that I wish there were a bit more vote counts. Even if the votes don't change, having one every few pages it makes it easier to keep track of things.
Or maybe the next step for me is to keep notes on what's happening.

[AngryPidgeon]

I cannot believe UN wasnt lynched so hard. Axxle, good playing. Mastin, what the FUCK? Why would I target Trollie???

[Kimor]

Most scum have daytalk on this site, in my experience.

As for me...I didn't claim a power role because I felt that it would draw unnecessary attention to me. I was alternating between 2nd or 3rd lynch of the scumgroup, and I felt that there was plenty of time in that position to turn the vote around to you or BB if necessary.

Sorry, Mastin, you were spot on...I am curious, though, you kept saying that I lost all my townie cred - what was it that caused that? I never did quite understand it.

Also, to address the folks in the dead QT, I didn't hammer until later because I was hoping we'd get a vote count...I was a bit nervous because I didn't want to accidentally put somebody at L-1 without justification...And I figured that if it WOULD have been a hammer, I'd have gone to conftown.

[BBmolla]

Fuck mastin that's why.

[BBmolla]

Seriously the options were no lynch or lynch mastin and for some reason mastin is still pushing this UN lynch which I've shown clearly I wasn't going to do.

I give zero fucks.

[BBmolla]

This town was fucking retarded, the Robert lynch was fucking retarded, we deserved to lose.

[Kimor]

This town was fucking retarded, the Robert lynch was fucking retarded, we deserved to lose.

You were a serious contributor to the town sucking. You didn't make a single post of substance during the entire game.

[BBmolla]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Kimor

This is pants on head retarded

VOTE: Kimor

Fuck you. I'm voting someone who is actually scum. We tried your guys's method and it just got Robert(FUCKING TOWN LIKE I SAID) lynched and wasted everyone's fucking time.

I'm voting scum, feel free to continue being retarded and trying to get someone who is either town or unobvious scum.

^K

[Kimor]

Sure, but you gave nothing for anybody else to work with. A vote without reasoning is patently worthless. It counts for only its own value. A vote with reasoning, on the other hand, is pro-town and encourages others to follow suit.

[BBmolla]

Can't explain gut.

[UberNinja]

BB, I'm sorry

[UberNinja]

And Axxle, I feel terrible.

[BBmolla]

You really shouldn't, you played to your win condition, I'm very happy with your play this game.

[UberNinja]

Well, I'm glad you don't hate me.

[BBmolla]

This just reasserts my "If UN is playing well, he's scum" theory.

[UberNinja]

What the hell are you talking about, I played amazingly horribly! It's a literal miracle I wasn't lynched. lol

[BBmolla]

Then my "If UN isn't pissing me off, he's scum" theory.

[UberNinja]

Damn. I can't win with you, can I?

[havingfitz]

Matt...thanks for modding. It was an enjoyable game.

I can't believe scum won. Though I also do not see how all the town who were on all flippin 3 of us mafia most of the game came to their conclusions. Most of the suspicions were crap IMO until D3 where I do not know how in the world UN did not get lynched. AP's actions were obvious.

Not sure I liked my game's mod having a person he is so close to in it as a player. Too much room for conflict of interest...similar to the rule where people from the same IP address can't be in the same game. No offense. It's my opinion.

If there was an MVP in a losing cause it wasn't Trollie...more like a toss up between AP and mastin. Still can't believe people weren't buying mastin's D3 efforts.

I thought AP and mastin played great.

Slandaar wasn't around enough to comment on. redtail seemed competent but he wasn't involved enough so made no impact. BBmolla was a detriment to town. Axxle was kind of an innocent bystander. CoolDog was scum's best friend Trollie was a lot of hot air and abrasive without logically backing up his suspicions.

UN's BS kept town confused most of the game despite also drawing attention to himself. It was a pleasure playing with him. And even though Kimor lurked a bit much at te end he was a huge improvement over his predecessors.

I had fun. A win is a good thing.

Cheers!