Scummies 2012 Nominations (Deadline For Noms)

[UberNinja]

If it's a recurring hydra, I would assume the hydra account gets it.

If it was a one-off and they don't plan to use it again, I'd prefer it be given to both heads separately, on their mains.

[Faraday]

I think the suggestion was more whether the alt gets it, the main gets it, or both? And while we're on the subject, what theoretically happens if a hydra is nominated?

Depends on if it's public, if it's a public alt used to supplement a BOW award then it can go on the main. Hydra goes to Hydra and main's in the mod awards, at least. See: Andrius and Plum as Bilbo Baggins.

[Baseline]

Thanks for the nomination Dunhamganger but I am indeed an alt and have only replaced into two games ever with it and given it's a BoW award I'm barely eligible.

[Dunhamganger]

That's why I went for Most Memorable Event. But. You're a p. cool guy regardless.

[Faraday]

Thanks for the nomination Dunhamganger but I am indeed an alt and have only replaced into two games ever with it and given it's a BoW award I'm barely eligible.

2 games would be fine if they were oustanding, I guess, but yeah the more the better for this type of thing. Pity you're bad, eh?

[RedCoyote]

Nominate PiggyGal15 for

Best Moment

&

Rising Star

in Micro 49: Double Elimination.

Great fakeclaim. She was part of a "three" (see game for how this works) person scumteam where two of the scum died on D1/N1 and went on to win it fairly easily.

Edit: Clarified nomination. ty, Faraday & Medhi.

[Faraday]

Eh. Petapan got lynched day 1 and died night 1? Have you considered rising star for piggy or something instead?

edit: just because it doesn't sound like it quite fits best performance scumgroup unless peta was part of some massive gambit or...something.

[RedCoyote]

Well, what can I nominate her for, Faraday? If Rising Star fits, then that's fine. I thought that was just for people that joined in 2012 though. I just think her play was worthy of recognition, whatever the category is. I agree that peta's play was nothing spectacular, but I was really impressed with her.

[Mehdi2277]

Best Manipulator, Best Moment (since her good fake claim is what really helped her), rising star all fit fine. I believe rising star includes most improved and doesn't have any year limit.

[Faraday]

Rising Star isn''t limited by year , Red. Newbie was, which is why it was gotten rid of.

Memorable Moment might work, too. You could try both? Always best to err on the side of caution if unsure of a category, imo. Doesn't actually create extra reading for then judging, anyway.

[petapan]

yeah there was 0 communication due to the nature of the setup so it wasn't really a group performance thing

[RedCoyote]

Okay, cool.

[mastin2]

Nominate UberNinja for Don Corelone

. Not for any specific game, mind you. (It's a body of work awards, after all.) He's just a strong scum player overall. Rather, he's good at doing what he needs to do in order to survive. For instance, in 1377, it didn't matter how many people were suspicious of him; he threw up a storm and posted

exactly

what he needed to do to create that vital doubt from people. His posting there was fairly strong and most the living players had, at least at some points in the game, been reading him quite strongly as town. Plus, look at his posts in the scum QT; he nailed down exactly what the scumteam needed to do in order to pull through with the win, laying out quite clearly their plan; of the three scum players, he was the one I'd see as being most in charge of what to do.

Also, I followed along the ending of MLP, and knowing DJ is UN, well, he won when both his scumbuddies died on d1 and d2, so he eliminated the whole town by himself.

To put the nom in words, He's not very good at keeping suspicion off of himself, but he's VERY good at keeping the suspicion on him from getting him lynched, AND at coordinating the scum's actions, both qualities of a good scum player.

[drmyshotgun]

Nominate UberNinja for Don Corelone

. Not for any specific game, mind you. (It's a body of work awards, after all.) He's just a strong scum player overall. Rather, he's good at doing what he needs to do in order to survive. For instance, in 1377, it didn't matter how many people were suspicious of him; he threw up a storm and posted

exactly

what he needed to do to create that vital doubt from people. His posting there was fairly strong and most the living players had, at least at some points in the game, been reading him quite strongly as town. Plus, look at his posts in the scum QT; he nailed down exactly what the scumteam needed to do in order to pull through with the win, laying out quite clearly their plan; of the three scum players, he was the one I'd see as being most in charge of what to do.

Also, I followed along the ending of MLP, and knowing DJ is UN, well, he won when both his scumbuddies died on d1 and d2, so he eliminated the whole town by himself.

To put the nom in words, He's not very good at keeping suspicion off of himself, but he's VERY good at keeping the suspicion on him from getting him lynched, AND at coordinating the scum's actions, both qualities of a good scum player.

I'd totally

2nd

this.

[Axxle]

Nominate UberNinja for Don Corelone

. Not for any specific game, mind you. (It's a body of work awards, after all.) He's just a strong scum player overall. Rather, he's good at doing what he needs to do in order to survive. For instance, in 1377, it didn't matter how many people were suspicious of him; he threw up a storm and posted

exactly

what he needed to do to create that vital doubt from people. His posting there was fairly strong and most the living players had, at least at some points in the game, been reading him quite strongly as town. Plus, look at his posts in the scum QT; he nailed down exactly what the scumteam needed to do in order to pull through with the win, laying out quite clearly their plan; of the three scum players, he was the one I'd see as being most in charge of what to do.

Also, I followed along the ending of MLP, and knowing DJ is UN, well, he won when both his scumbuddies died on d1 and d2, so he eliminated the whole town by himself.

To put the nom in words, He's not very good at keeping suspicion off of himself, but he's VERY good at keeping the suspicion on him from getting him lynched, AND at coordinating the scum's actions, both qualities of a good scum player.

3rd

. I felt completely powerless as town in that game.

[Venmar]

Nominate UberNinja for Don Corelone

. Not for any specific game, mind you. (It's a body of work awards, after all.) He's just a strong scum player overall. Rather, he's good at doing what he needs to do in order to survive. For instance, in 1377, it didn't matter how many people were suspicious of him; he threw up a storm and posted

exactly

what he needed to do to create that vital doubt from people. His posting there was fairly strong and most the living players had, at least at some points in the game, been reading him quite strongly as town. Plus, look at his posts in the scum QT; he nailed down exactly what the scumteam needed to do in order to pull through with the win, laying out quite clearly their plan; of the three scum players, he was the one I'd see as being most in charge of what to do.

Also, I followed along the ending of MLP, and knowing DJ is UN, well, he won when both his scumbuddies died on d1 and d2, so he eliminated the whole town by himself.

To put the nom in words, He's not very good at keeping suspicion off of himself, but he's VERY good at keeping the suspicion on him from getting him lynched, AND at coordinating the scum's actions, both qualities of a good scum player.

4th

, I can vouch for UberNinja when I say that his scumplay is quite spectacular.

[Salamence20]

5th UN

[BBmolla]

nth UN

[Bitmap]

(Σ from i = 1 to inf of nth) UN

[AngryPidgeon]

Day Kill: Uber Ninja

I mean..I support this wagon for his nom.

[N]

• Outstanding MishMash Game
  Spoiler: Description

  Awarded to the person who runs the best game in the Mish Mash subforum. The Mish Mash Moderator will choose a panel to decide the best Mish Mash Game.

Are we supposed to nom mish mash games here too? I want to nominate Ether for Telephone Pictionary.

[Xisiqomelir]

+1 UN

[izakthegoomba]

• Outstanding MishMash Game
  Spoiler: Description

  Awarded to the person who runs the best game in the Mish Mash subforum. The Mish Mash Moderator will choose a panel to decide the best Mish Mash Game.

Are we supposed to nom mish mash games here too? I want to nominate Ether for Telephone Pictionary.

Yes, you are. They are nominated like mafia games, and just judged separately.

[Nachomamma8]

Nominate Klick for Rising Star

So, Klick used to be this, and was a serial flaker who used to join a shit ton of games and then disappear from all of them soon after. Now he stays in games and posts in them, and still does weird shit on occasion, but you can see reading through his games that he is improving fast (mostly because he's in so many damn games). I've played with him three times recently: Newbie 1270, Micro 28, Newbie 1272. In Newbie 1270, he replaced in, didn't do much, got lynched because I didn't like his predecessor, so that's not really that big of a deal. Micro 28, he was a serious town buddy of mine, and ended up being killed night 2 because there was clearly no way that anyone was going to execute him, and in 1272, he helped energize a town that was pretty much fucked in 5p LyLo, was regarded by town by pretty much everyone, correctly identified me as scum, and only *barely* didn't get the lynch through. I don't know if he just needed a new account or something, but wow.

[Klick]