Street Racers: New York (Game over!)

[Jal]

I want to lynch DeasVail, but I would be okay, I suppose, with lynching Edosurist or Skyhook.

Of you want to lynch him, why aren't you voting for him?

[Darthe]

Juicy contradiction?

I'm sorry, I won't really be involved here until at least 4-5 more people are dead and shit is factual rather than hypothetical. I got bored when we made it to week... three or so.

Doubly when my neighbor died and scum stopped attempting to push me as a valid lynch candidate.

[thezmon221]

Though he looks only half done, I'll take my vote off DV, as I promised earlier; I'll put it on a likelier candidate (my reasoning for MattP was a bit of a reach anyway).

VOTE: JacobSavage

[DeasVail]

Also, we're not lynching Angel because of whatever reasoning that she'll be bad at lylo. That's stupid reasoning to promote a mislynch.

This so much.

[DeasVail]

Edosurist-

Weak Scumread

First, I don't like his reads/catch-up post in 614. I don't know if it's much more of a gut thing, but finding PMyst town for being too blatant (about his IIoA) and then finding njoseph weak scum for not being very pro-town don't seem to come from the same scumhunting mind. Basically, I think the type of player to look past PMyst's IIoA and think it's too blatant, would also be the type of player to not leave njoseph as weak scum for "not being very pro-town". This makes me think that the reads are contrived (and a few of the other reads I'm not a big fan of either).

Despite voting for Sixx at the beginning of his time in the game, he doesn't really seem to be making much effort to determine Sixx's alignment and 946 indicates he's happy with lynching him.

In 1471 the part about TML being scum because of what Nacho said feels contrived. It's just very mechanical and not considering other aspects of TML's play.

810 and 2001 are examples of him complaining about nothing happening, but he doesn't really try to make things happen (this ties in with his play on the sixx wagon). Sometimes he does call out people for not voting, but I don't know, I think it's a lot more talk than actual action. This is one of the weaker things though.

JacobSavage-

Moderate Townread

49 is probably quite a significant part of my townread. First the daystart PM thing, which I already said my thoughts on, but it was basically that scum are more likely to know when day starts. The second part of that post, about not lynching Roger because he won't learn anything is something I think scum would avoid because it's not scumhunting, but I could see town actually thinking it and saying it.

Jumping off the very popular thez wagon in 363 due to reading him as town (and I think being the first to jump off) is, although possible from scum, something I think is more likely from town.

Question: Did you notice Arc in NY 160?

My main concern about Jacob is him attacking Arc, BUT, he unvotes her at a time when I thought she had a particularly townish run of posts, which makes him not too bad.

Jal-

Strong Townread

I thought Heather's replace out post was really townish. I think that the extent to which Heather gets annoyed (and it's pretty much confirmed as genuine in the post where she actually replaces out) is only really possible from town, and Jal's play being townish as well makes my read pretty strong.

I just like 364. I think it's really natural.

The exchange that happens beginning at 1190 I feel is really genuine because I didn't understand what was going on either, and I think scum would be much more careful about possibly not knowing something that town would know.

Jmj3000-

Weak Scumread

I had a very weak townread on the slot from Robert's posts.

As I read through, I thought jmj was pretty much null, but looking again, I don't think he's putting much thought into his reads in 1369. Still mostly null though, but I'm going with weak scum, just because almost everyone else is more town.

Lurker-

Strong Townread

I thought KillerApple was scummy, but I remember seeing the post he made after he was already going to be replaced, which was actually designed to help the town, which I think is really unlikely to come from scum. I can't see it in his ISO though, so it must have been quoted somewhere before getting deleted.

Also, I thought SlySly's insistence that he had caught Sixx when the whole thing was pretty dubious really indicated town, as scum usually try not to be so controversial and it has the whole "trying too hard to be cleared" association that I think they'd avoid. Also, his play was not at all cautious, which is what I think scum are more likely to be.

[Slandaar]

I see you ignored my question Darthe

Why is this?

[thezmon221]

I thought Heather's replace out post was really townish. I think that the extent to which Heather gets annoyed (and it's pretty much confirmed as genuine in the post where she actually replaces out) is only really possible from town, and Jal's play being townish as well makes my read pretty strong.q

Yeah, Heather was beyond pissed and ranting about it on my other mafia board, which she doesn't really do often, which is also what indicated to me that her slot was probably town.

I see you ignored my question Darthe

Why is this?

Dude, he's been working on a few reads posts. Have some patience, give him some time.

[Slandaar]

No, I don't believe he is.

[thezmon221]

Considering the fact that he only gave reads for 10/15 players, I believe he is.

[Slandaar]

Stop derping please.

[Slandaar]

thezmon tell me something.

Do you not think the quote I asked my question regarding is strange?

[thezmon221]

Yeah, sorry, mixed up Darthe and DV

What do I think of the quote? I don't entirely know what you're getting at in it, to be frank. I don't see scum Darthe calling Bumi, who is his neighbor, a scum. It seems like he was basing too much on speculation of Bumi and the fact that oftentimes neighbors aren't of the same alignment.

As for the suspect queries, I just see this as speculation on Bumi's part of who would be scum, or possibly who might have a PR.

[Slandaar]

Yes I have read that argument its bad.

Why if he was scum wouldn't he think exactly the same; ie he needs to lynch his neighbour before he is lynched due to thinking there is nearly always one scum in hood and so there is a high chance he is lynched.

[thezmon221]

Because if he was scum and he brought up that theory, there's the chance that when Bumi flipped town, the whole town would come after him for exactly the same reason he went after Bumi. It's a high risk, low reward factor.

[Magua]

VOTE COUNT

Albus Dumbledore (4): Darthe, JacobSavage, ArcAngel9, The Mini-Librarian
ArcAngel9 (2): Slandaar, penguin_alien
Edosurist (1): DeasVail
JacobSavage (4): Albus Dumbledore, Jal, Edosurist, thezmon221
DeasVail (2): Boniface, PeregrineV
Not voting (3): jmj3000, Slandaar, Baby Spice

With

16

alive, it takes

9

players to lynch.

Modperson

, Edo is voting for Jacob and your votecount doesn't have Slandaar in it.

Fixed.

[Darthe]

I see you ignored my question Darthe

Why is this?

Who are you and where is your question?

[thezmon221]

This shit is all irrelevant because you lot aren't voting Bumi who had suspect queries in the QT

What were the suspect queries?

(No I am not dedicated enough to read this far already)

This is what he's referring to, Darthe.

[Boniface]

I want to lynch DeasVail, but I would be okay, I suppose, with lynching Edosurist or Skyhook.

Of you want to lynch him, why aren't you voting for him?

I am voting him.

[Boniface]

And Deas, I am keeping up to date, but there's a good deal of things said that don't do anything for me. This is my first game in quite a few years, I'm definitely rusty, and I feel like I don't have as much to say.

[DeasVail]

Ok, well that's kind of the wrong answer then, because the reason you used to vote for me was shown later to be invalid and I don't think you commented on it at all.

[DeasVail]

Also, I'm sorry, but I'm really busy today, so the last 5 probably won't come until tonight my time.

The reads without the reasoning are:

Penguin_alien- ??? (There's something I noticed which may be a really strong towntell except I need to think more about it. I may bring it up, but I'm not sure how good I'd feel about it, as it's something that the mod said. Otherwise the slot is kind of eh though.)

PV- I don't know. A player I wanted to ISO again to decide on a read. A weak read either way though.

Slandaar- Maybe weak town but I was going to check.

TML- Moderate Townread

Thezmon- Moderate Townread

[StrangerCoug]

jmj3000 has requested replacement. If Magua could take care of that, please.

[Slandaar]

Must admit the thing that makes me think that JS isn't a scum buddy of Sixx also applies to Albus, and I really doubt Albus and JS are scum buddies either.

Unvote[/b]

OK so this is scum

VOTE: Baby Spice

Tip: she isn't on Sixx's team.

Lynch her, no need to mess around and it means I don't need to catchup then because I will be dead tomorrow.

JMJ is town btw.

[Baby Spice]

that WoW ISO looks completely different and I looked at it for 2 seconds

Then you should read her posts this game.

Vote AA

[PeregrineV]

Hate Sunday prods- more tomorrow.