Street Racers: New York (Game over!)

[PeregrineV]

Early posting argued and clarified and translated. She's been giving opinions on relevant topics, and generally posting my way of thinking, even if I don't agree with some of her reads.
Nothing recent (today) indicates otherwise.

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

Albus Dumbledore (1): JacobSavage
ArcAngel9 (2): penguin_alien, Baby Spice
Baby Spice (3): Slandaar, ArcAngel9, Darthe
Edosurist (1): DeasVail
JacobSavage (7): Albus Dumbledore, Jal, Edosurist, thezmon221, Boniface, PeregrineV, The Mini-Librarian
Not voting (2): jmj3000, Lurker

With

16

alive, it takes

9

players to lynch.

[Jal]

Slaandar, I read that as her trying to build reads off on information (Sixx's mod kill) that we already have and working on possibilities regarding it.

[Jal]

Also: Jacob has been like this long before his v/la.

[Slandaar]

Hmm.. Mostly after we had agreed to have some level of trust for the purpose of using our role. So, near the end of january, IE Night two.

P-edit: I agree. Shit needs to stop. Baby is a good train, lets actually run something up to get infoz.

The quote was from Day 1 (before night 2)

[Slandaar]

Slaandar, I read that as her trying to build reads off on information (Sixx's mod kill) that we already have and working on possibilities regarding it.

OK. Link me to where Baby talks about Albus being Sixx's buddy.

[Albus Dumbledore]

It seems pretty clear that Baby Spice meant that given she thinks neither Jacob or myself are Sixx-scum, and we aren't scum together, she must be wrong in her scumread on one of us and isn't comfortable voting for me. I suppose I could be wrong.

Do you think Arc is the scummier of the three of us, Baby Spice? And what's the case on her anyway? It seems as uselessly sparse as the times it built up earlier in the game.

[ArcAngel9]

It is so irony that She calls you, Jacob scum and you both are life time scum buddies with Sixx..but she puts her vote one with no tiny reason.
What kind of play is that? I can't even start describing how funny her play style is.... Not sure if she is playing dumb or Is this her game play.

[Baby Spice]

Also: Jacob has been like this long before his v/la.

Granted. But what's the point of voting him right now if he's not around to answer? If I was certain, yes of course it wouldn't matter so much.

Albus, bingo.

Albus/JS are stronger reads that AA, but see above. Well, JS more than Albus after the last couple of pages.

[thezmon221]

Before Matt's, after Albus, and Jacob's and Now Babyspice... Please stop this madness, we are on Day 3, we haven't got the single scum yet.

You can come join us on JS's wagon he's at L-2 now. I know you said Spice is scummier to you, but I personally don't see her as being very scummy compared to what we already have. Plus, better chance of lynching him.

However, perhaps it is better if we wait until he comes out of V/LA and perhaps force a claim out of him...

But yeah, if you didn't notice from before, I don't think Spice is

that

scummy. I mean sure, the unvote of AD is a tad strange, but her play overall feels more town to me.

[Albus Dumbledore]

The thing about his V/LA is that I see him browsing the forum at least once every day, including just a little bit ago. Obviously he's around to answer, he's just choosing not to.

[thezmon221]

Yeah, I looked through his profile on that note, and as of the typing of this post, the last time he visited was:
"Mon Feb 11, 2013 3:59 pm" (EST).

I looked through his posts, and he hasn't really made any posts, I think he might have made 1-2 posts on like... 2/7, but nothing recent.

So AD, I think there's a definite possibility that he's actually V/LA, but maybe able to check in once in a while. Right now I'm just going to write it down as him trying to keep up, but unable to post. Optomistic, I know, but what am I going to do? Besides, we can always lynch him after his V/LA is up... unless we decide to flip wagons AGAIN.

[DeasVail]

Slandaar, have you looked at Baby Spice's play in NY 160B?

[Slandaar]

No.

Here is the point; When you have multiball scum do not look the same as they do in other games due to being able to scumhunt (they appear more town) and due to this her reads will change as she as scum is in fact genuinely scumhunting (the other team to her)

So your arguments don't hold and I don't need to meta her to know it.

[Slandaar]

If I had to call a scum tram now I'd say Sixx, Thez, Robert and Killer with just looking at the vote count and a memory of a couple of posts.

I think this makes Jacob town btw.

I think.

And yes I know the arguments against it and I think they are wrong.

[Slandaar]

So, how about we don't lynch the easiest lynch in the history of mafia and actually try and lynch scum ie Baby Spice?

[DeasVail]

I still don't really agree, but I would choose her over Jacob at this stage. (What's with people making it a choice between Jacob and Baby anyway?)

I think Edosurist is better though, but no one seems to have a read on him?

[Slandaar]

I havn't really looked into him yet.

[JacobSavage]

I really didn't want to post at all but I'm going to have to clear something up.

Firstly I'm not going to address anything game related here, you can have that later.

Secondly, I have access, in fact in regards to that nothing has changed.
However my V/LA is for academic reasons. I have a big report due on the 14th and when you see me around here it is when I really should be working. I took the decision that I wasn't going to post purely to make sure that I would spend my time when I really should be writing about Semi-Conductors building a case or looking into meta.

So, quit bitching about my lack of posts, they'll come when I get back.

[ArcAngel9]

I am not confident about Jacob, I am not joining his wagon people...

[PeregrineV]

@DV- Your last 5? And anything to say about 2591?

[penguin_alien]

I find it shady that ArcAngel9 is willing to vote for Albus Dumbledore with the strongest reason I can find being that he's on an unflipped player's presumed town list and said unflipped player (Skyhook) is a top scum suspect of hers. And she seems to have no problem with the fact that another of her scum reads, in The Mini-Librarian, is right there joining her wagon. And for that matter, ArcAngel9, why do you think The Mini-Librarian is scum rather than what was claimed?

ArcAngel9, could you please address this? And as soon as Baby Spice votes you she's scummier than someone you spent a lot of time making a case on?

Boniface, what's your take on the Albus Dumbledore wagon? You keep saying you [were] curious about it, or wanted him to claim for 'everyone's benefit'; if you still think he's town, are you curious about the wagon because you think there was scum there or because you think a misguided town is making a big mistake?

[ArcAngel9]

Penguin, Please refer to my Post # 2607 & 2594 about Baby Spice.
And about Mini, His reasons didn't sit well for me... He seems to be agreeing with alot with others on this game. i have played with him before and he is not like this .. At least that is not he is when he is town... that's is just my suspect, there is a good chance he could be town too... But for now. BabySpice has most point less reasons to go after people which is totally a scum slip....

If you can vote someone right now, who would you vote?

[Darthe]

I have a theory.

ArcAngel
Thez
Spice
Dumbledore
JS
Librarian

These names are all suspect or have been through the course of the game. If we limit them further by those who have been suspect most of the game or recently with a valid reason we get

Spice
JS

What separates these from the rest of the living is that none of these people have been replaced. Unless someone thinks the entire mafia team has been replaced?

[Baby Spice]

I have a theory.

ArcAngel
Thez
Spice
Dumbledore
JS
Librarian

These names are all suspect or have been through the course of the game. If we limit them further by those who have

been suspect most of the game or recently with a valid reason

we get

Spice
JS

What separates these from the rest of the living is that none of these people have been replaced. Unless someone thinks the entire mafia team has been replaced?

lol. Big lol.

Are you saying that you had no valid reason for voting Albus as little as about 30 hours ago Darthe?