If I remember correctly, he never actually said they did. I remember him arguing with people about their misrepresentation of the post, but that's a tad muddled in the confusion he created with the scum/town neighborhood.
Slandaar wrote:
How did Bumi post in the QT if not?
Pre-game.
Slandaar wrote: In post 2636, Darthe wrote:
Simple really. I propose that mafia is a game. People are drawn to games, and more so people like power. The mafia team is the team with certain power that the town does not necessarily have. Also, the mafia team is smaller than the town. If the majority of town members replace, can we not assume that at most a like majority of mafia members has been replaced? All of them is simply unlikely. Combine this with the fact that JS (moreso than Spice, but her as well) have been pushed since day 1 and yet 8 of us are dead and I think we need to test something.
Yes OK this is correct I think. But it doesn't mean anything.
THE ODDS OF FINDING SCUM IN THE NON REPLACED ARE THE SAME AS LYNCHING FROM THE REPLACED.
Anyways my point was; why are you assuming one scum team?
I agree. Replacing vs. Not Replacing has less of an impact in this sort of game. There was a ton of confusion and the day lasted forever. Newer scum especially would probably have replaced out. More experienced scum would probably stay in, though because they are more experienced.
I also think that since there's two teams, there's an even better possibility for the majority, if not all, of the scum team to have replaced out. There are not many people left in the game who have not replaced, but if you notice, the past 3 people who have died were all town, and none of them had flaked. True, the only scum dead didn't replace, but he's a more experienced player.