Micro 153: Sherlock Holmes Mafia (Game Over)

[Blue Yoshi]

/confirm
Well we already know there's 2 mafia

[Blue Yoshi]

Pressure's on now!
VOTE: Blue Yoshi

No wait that's wrong!

[Blue Yoshi]

It's not like we have a forensics expert.
Also since there's only 2 mafia (according to the first post) one or both of them probably has some sort of special role.

[Blue Yoshi]

I didn't expect many people to notice what I said in my first post, given it was in the confirming stage.
And I'm trying to kind of ease our way out of RVS with actual info.

It's not like we have a forensics expert.

heh...rolefish much?

Considering it was in response to the flavor, nope.

[Blue Yoshi]

Not trying to defend anyone anyways.
I'd love to give info on other people but not many people have talked beyond RVS, and there's still not much to analyze there. Or really at all.

[Blue Yoshi]

Let's skip the point where there's no way what you're saying is true.
Considering you probably know that's not true why are you voting me for it?

[Blue Yoshi]

I'm wondering why he is voting for me for that reason, considering that reason is generally considered false.

[Blue Yoshi]

Oh yeah I should probably UNVOTE: Blue Yoshi before I die.
Now to the rest of the wagon.

sword_of_omens:
2 good points. I didn't even think forensics expert was a real role, as I've said I was responding to the flavor. I wouldn't expect someone to go "oh lookie here i'm the forensics expert good guess". No one would even do that.
I wouldn't have expected everyone to actually read the whole first post and notice that we actually had 2 scum, and I don't know if people would have noticed my post in the confirmation stage.

His reasons are legitimately made and I don't consider this vote suspicious.

Seanald:
I honestly still don't know what to think of this one. You're saying trying to leave RVS is scummy? What the hell are you talking about.
The exaggeration doesn't really help either.

Syryana:
I see a combined sheep of sword and seanald. I don't know if this is hiding a sheep under a relatively big post or what, but it's not really good.
Also that L-1.

[Blue Yoshi]

I never really expect people to bother to do so. Experience on another forum with hosting games shows that not a lot of people bother reading the first post.

[Blue Yoshi]

It's not the exact scumtell he talked about, but scumtells that are that exact aren't really very good.
How insistent he was trying to be with it confused me too.
And no, I don't know why you asked me.

[Blue Yoshi]

Which scumtell are you referring to, though?
What makes you think it was exact?
What makes you think he was being insistent?
Why did you change your wording from "generally considered false" to "not really very good"?

I'm referring to the "every scum ever said this" thing.
The fact that he said "every scum ever" said this, which is an exaggeration and not true.
While it doesn't disprove the basis of what he's saying to be true, the fact that he tried to put more heat on me by saying "every scum ever" did this is just an excuse to try to get me lynched.
Because when I said "generally considered false" I was just going off of whoever said it wasn't a very good idea, moving over to "not really very good" was just because the way he was trying to use that one piece of info to get me lynched.

I don't like the way he was taking my lynch with not much info.

[Blue Yoshi]

Sorry for my absence, I went on a day long family trip that didn't have internet access, which I thought it would. D:

I'd like to say one thing right now before I read back...

I overreact as town. Not so much as scum. Should probably work on fixing that.

Holy metawifom.

[Blue Yoshi]

Not really enjoying Syryana's distance of Seanald, even though they perfectly agree with each other, it's a completely baseless FoS. How can you agree with the person and be suspicious of them as well?
While slightly rhetorical I still want you to answer it Syryana.

[Blue Yoshi]

The exchanges between Ms M and Syr over the last few posts have been kind of odd, but what I find as the most implausible is Syr's Ms M vote.
Considering Syr knows his own alignment, someone else trying to defend him as town shouldn't be suspicious at least to him, yet he thinks so.
It also looks like he's even trying to pour his suspicion off of him and on to, well all sorts of people. Every one of his last few posts has been a vote on a different person.
It's not at all logical for town to think this way, but scum can use it as a distance ploy. Possibly even 3rd party?

VOTE: Syryana

L-1

Inb4 vote on me in next post

[Blue Yoshi]

UNVOTE: Syr

I see no problem with his claim.
I'll be gone for all of tomorrow, so I'll likely be reading, just not posting.
...I really need to make up for it at one point.

[Blue Yoshi]

In your last read post, you said you "liked me as town". In about 15 posts, with me not making any of those, you suddenly name me as part of the scumteam?
Don't pull any "my last read was a typo" bull.

[Blue Yoshi]

Syr is scum...
MsM is most likely scum..
mollie shouldn't be allowed to skate by in the background with minimal input..
TNE also needs to step it up..
Zack could very well be lurking scum...
only real town read I have is GM....

im also liking BY for town now also....

About one day ago.

[Blue Yoshi]

I'd also like to ask why you did another read so soon after your first one?

[Blue Yoshi]

okay I see now
I'm gonna...go somewhere else for a while.

[Blue Yoshi]

Embarrassment has worn off.
A lynch on Syr is sub-optimal and can be worse than a no-lynch.
I believe Syr's claim, I believe pirate mollie is losing it and I believe I will go after anyone who hammers Syr.
Marangal has started to look towny in the last few posts, so the only lynch I can get behind is a s_o_o lynch, which I don't see happening.

Useless VOTE: Sword is useless.

[Blue Yoshi]

It's funny how much I told you guys.
VOTE: RachMarie

[Blue Yoshi]

Fuck it, nothing else good will come out of me.
Knowing we have no more power roles and my ability is spent, I am claiming

note-keeping prodigy

.
I am a backup for Sherlock Holmes's man in the field/prodigy whatever. As well, upon his death I receive any results he may have had.
Funny thing is, he watched night 1 and I only got

one

result, leading me to believe we have no more power roles.
My result? RachMarie visited Syryana.
Syryana was killed, Rach visit Syr, and there were no other actions.

Of course, if anyone wants to invalidate my claim as a power role, be my guest.

(Fun fact, I had this post typed up a few hours ago and never submitted it. Bah.)

[Blue Yoshi]

/late
The setup did seem a little bit town-leaning, but a 1or2-shot mafia roleblock would be just the ticket to make this balanced.
Hell, give BOTH of them 1-shot roleblocking.