Mafia 57: Good Ol' Mafia - Game over!

[TheJiveMachine]

Delibird

I think he meant the "certain players are turning out to appear more experienced then they first seemed to let on..." bit.

[Nightfall]

RafK, Jive, Panzer, autoload too name a few...

[ShadowLurker]

RafK plays on other sites.

[Nightfall]

*I also thought his join date said Jan 2007 not Jan 2006....

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I'm not sure how to say this any more clearly, but Channeldelibird is the scummiest scum.

[pevergreen]

Yep, why should we believe you?

[TheJiveMachine]

I'm not sure how to say this any more clearly, but Channeldelibird is the scummiest scum.

Why can't anyone in this game provide reasoning for their accusations? They just say "Oh, you're scum." It's getting us nowhere.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Step 1) Turn on brain.
Step 2) Scroll to bottom of page and "Display posts from previous: All Posts by ChannelBelibird"
Step 3) Read.
Step 4) Vote.

It's so friggen obvious it hurts me.

[PJ.]

I don't see it.

[autoload]

I wouldn't rule Channel being scum out of the realm of possibility, but I think we have higher likelihood scum to fry first...

[pevergreen]

like?

Examples would be nice...I dont know at this point, votes are going places..its confusing.

[autoload]

Rafk and ~N9V~ in that order.

[Dagger]

I give up. I can't make sense of this entire thing. People seemed to be calling each other scums and giving reasons like read back again, it was there somewhere, or I know he's scum, etc. I am not used to this type of playstyle.

Also, if there are 2 scum groups, around 40-50% of the players are scums, and with 4 townies death the first night, with no crossfire some more, the town is in a bad position. I think it's more likely that there are 2 SK, or 2 Vig.

And I don't like SL's way of posting, the way he knows who and who is scum with such certainty. That'll be my rationale of voting for now.

Vote: ShadowLurker

.

[ShadowLurker]

And I don't like SL's way of posting, the way he knows who and who is scum with such certainty. That'll be my rationale of voting for now.

Vote: ShadowLurker

.

That makes no fucking sense at all.

[autoload]

I agree. Dagger complains about the fingering of each other without spelling out the reasons word for word, but then basically does the same thing to you. Does not necessarily make him scum, but wrong.

[ChannelDelibird]

Step 1) Turn on brain.
Step 2) Scroll to bottom of page and "Display posts from previous: All Posts by ChannelBelibird"
Step 3) Read.
Step 4) Vote.

It's so friggen obvious it hurts me.

I'm afraid that no 'ChannelBelibird' exists. My username is ChannelDelibird.

Anyway, until you feel like presenting a case against me, perhaps you'd like to share your views on some of the other players?

autoload - have I missed the post where you outlined your case against RafK? If either you could let me know whenabouts that was or explain it again, that would be appreciated. Can't really be bothered to trawl through the whole thread to find it.

[TheJiveMachine]

Until someone is willing to

ACTUALLY QUOTE A POST THEY FIND RELEVANT AND POINT OUT THEIR THOUGHTS AND RATIONALE (zomg)

, this game won't be going anywhere.

Seriosly, I'm fed up with people saying "oh so and so is absolute scum" with nothing to back it up except "CUZ THEY'RE SCUM" or "go back and read every fucking post they made, it should jump right out at you." Guys and gals, get off your lazy asses and post some goddamn content if you want anyone (me at least) to acknowledge your opinion.

[JDodge]

I can see some contradiction in CDB's posts. He wonders why scotmany is at 8 votes for being a newbie, yet continues to go after BM when it was painfully obvious all along that BM was town.

~N9V~'s posting seems off, but I'm not sure if it's inherently scummy or not.

I'm not so sure I see the case on RafK.

I really don't have anything at this point.

[TheJiveMachine]

I can see some contradiction in CDB's posts. He wonders why scotmany is at 8 votes for being a newbie, yet continues to go after BM when it was painfully obvious all along that BM was town.

I don't know if it's necessarily

painfully

obvious that BM was town, but CDB did seem to be going far harder on BM than scotmany for essentially doing the same thing: making newbie mistakes that were interpreted as scumtells.

~N9V~'s posting seems off, but I'm not sure if it's inherently scummy or not.

QFT

[PJ.]

Alright, this is my scum list

~N9V~
ShadowLurker
Nightfall

N9 for voting himself, trying to confuse town, and not being concerned with catching scum.

Shadowlurker for saying that everyone but him and Twito are scum, for saying with such certainty that people are scum then denying it when they turn out to be town and then exploding for thinking he is scum, claiming a kill role in his first 5 post, and confusing the town.

Nightfall for kissing ass, posting little of content, and delibratly confusing the town.

Unvote

I will think about who my vote will belong to later.

[~N9V~]

How was I trying to confuse the town?

[ShadowLurker]

Shadowlurker for saying that everyone but him and Twito are scum, for saying with such certainty that people are scum then denying it when they turn out to be town and then exploding for thinking he is scum, claiming a kill role in his first 5 post, and confusing the town.

What the fuck? All of these are blatantly false.

[~N9V~]

Again ShadowLurker, may I ask why you beleive I am scum, lets see, it's been 4-5 pages, and no answer from you yet.

[livingod]

I see a lot of identifying, especially this page. Although a group who identifies tends to be pitted against another one. Either we have more than one scum group, or we have masons. I will reread to solidify any such suspicions I see, but in the meantime:

I think N9V and Dagger are buddies, be it scum or mason, but I'm thinking scum.

[Nightfall]

I'm kissing ass?