Mini 1456: Revenge (Game Over!)

[Hoopla]

interesting play majiffy. if you end up losing this because you opted not to take elyse to lylo instead of beastcharizard, then i will laugh.

@beastcharizard. you're confirmed town. i don't know what you want me to say (have you read all of the game?), but you ought to find it suspicious that majiffy came straight into lylo without even considering you a suspect. i know now that he is scum, and to me, i can tell you that if he were town and genuinely had a choice on his hands, he would be likelier to deliberate, rather than win/lose the game straight up.

also note that majiffy has never really expressed any suspicion of me for much of the game, and now he suddenly can see me as scum since we're in lylo without any analysis (or considering you scum)? i've been fairly detached from this game, and honestly didn't know which way i would have voted this lylo, so majiffy's lack of uncertainty is pretty jarring. any questions for me beastcharizard?

[beastcharizard]

You say I am confirmed town but yet you are not voting him. Are you hoping for him to switch to me? I don't understand why you are not voting at this point in time if you are so sure he is the scum.

I find him coming into LYLO and voting suspicious which is why I said something about it. I am going to ISO both of you to see what I think. I am leaning Majiffy though because of that vote. You are suspicious.

The town is going to hate me if I mess this up.

[Hoopla]

derp. i forgot to vote.

VOTE: majiffy

[Majiffy]

Charizard's slot was already a townread.
Elyse kill makes sense from HooplaScum.

2+2=4, despite how much Hoopla wants it to be 5.

[beastcharizard]

I would like to start this post out with an apology. If I lynch the wrong person then I am deeply sorry to the village.

I just ISO'd both Majiffy and Hoopla and I am inclined to believe that Majiffy is town while Hoopla is scum. Majiffy was hounding AC the entire time basically while hoopla wasn't on the vote for either scum lynches. Majiffy did say he has played blind as Mafia though which made me hesitate a little. His predecessor didn't really do much about anyone but Monkey so can't get anything there.

Hoopla has been pushing everyone but the scum in this game. He agreed the miller claim meant sense from Elyse but in the end wanted to lynch them. Then in their most recent post they "forget" to vote majiffy, which i find really weird in this type of situation. You also said Majiffy didn't see you as scum but post 901 said his town read of you was out the window.

I am afraid I am wrong but oh well. Nothing ventured nothing gained.

VOTE: Hoopla


All that analysis was for me to think things through and if I am wrong at least you all will see my logic. Once again, I am sorry if I messed this up.

[Majiffy]

Danke.

[Rob14]

Hoopla,

Vanilla Townie

, has been lynched Day 6.
beastcharizard,

Vanilla Townie

, has been endgamed Day 6.

Majiffy,

Mafia Goon

, has survived to endgame and won.
jmo16mla,

Mafia Rolestopper

, killed himself (was lynched) Day 3 and won.
ac1983fan,

Mafia Godfather

, was lynched Day 4 and won.

Mafia wins!

The full role distribution, the scum QT, and what night actions I have (all night except the fourth) will be posted either later tonight or tomorrow when I have a moment. I do not have all the role PMs, so Sora will post those when he gets back.

[Hoopla]

I would like to start this post out with an apology. If I lynch the wrong person then I am deeply sorry to the village.

all good. unlucky!

~~

majiffy, i still think your choice to bring beastcharizard, a wildcard, with me to lylo was a weird play. to me, it looks like you threw away an autowin to the whims of chance (unless you thought elyse would randomly turn on you?).

it worked out though.

[Elyse]

If I was in LyLo with Hoopla and Majiffy I probably would have voted for Majiffy because no way Hoopla would bring me but meh Majiffy made the right play. Being so brazen about AC scum was ballsy. Good job.

[Hoopla]

If I was in LyLo with Hoopla and Majiffy I probably would have voted for Majiffy because no way Hoopla would bring me but meh Majiffy made the right play. Being so brazen about AC scum was ballsy. Good job.

that is some level 2 wifom right there

[Elyse]

Yeah I know and watching from outside is different but meh. You seemed like you actually thought I wouldn't vote anyone else so I was pretty sure I would die if you were scum.

[Elyse]

And I did and you weren't....I'm tired

[Rob14]

Role Distribution
1. Ankamius-One-shot Neighborizer
2. Zionite-VT
3. Elyse-Miller
4. beastcharizard-VT
5. mario and luigi-VT
6. Scott Brosius-Two-shot Vig
7. Keybladewielder-VT
8. ac1983fan -Godfather
9. Hoopla-VT
10. Nul-Cop
11. jmo16mla -Rolestopper
12. MonkeyMan576-VT
13. Majiffy -Goon

Night 1 actions:
Chevre-Nothing
Nul-Investigate Chenoan
jmo-Rolestop Nul
ac-Kill Zionite
Diabolik-Kill Keybladewielder.

Night 2 Actions:
Ankamius neighborizes enomis. (resolves)
Nul investigates JMO (result: guilty)
ac1983fan kills ankamius (resolves)
JMO rolestops av1983fan (resolves)

Night 3 Actions:
ac1983fan kills Nul (resolves)
Nul investigates Hoopla (result: innocent)

Night 4 Actions (determined by forensics):
Scott Brosius - No action
Majiffy - Kill Scott Brosius

Night 5 Actions:
Majiffy kills Elyse (resolves)

Scum QT: http://quicktopic.com/50/H/cuX5549gGbf
Neighbor QT: http://quicktopic.com/50/H/ZAXMR53Pq5w

Good game, everyone! Role PMs will be posted by your mod when he returns.

[Majiffy]

majiffy, i still think your choice to bring beastcharizard, a wildcard, with me to lylo was a weird play. to me, it looks like you threw away an autowin to the whims of chance (unless you thought elyse would randomly turn on you?).

it worked out though.

That was the point. The kill made no sense coming from me, and you had all the reasons in the world to get rid of Elyse.

And I did and you weren't....I'm tired

<3

[Majiffy]

Although I did poop a little when BC received my early vote very negatively.

[beastcharizard]

I must say Majiffy you played well. You being so hard on AC tricked me.

[Majiffy]

You've never played with me before; I bus the hell out of my teammates.

[Majiffy]

It's actually more of a towntell when I'm

not

leading lynches on scum.

[Rob14]

So you're saying that if I follow your flowchart and it works, you're probably scum?

[ac1983fan]

So oi the last few days of this were painful to follow along with (especially without a dead qt???) but yeah I credit this win mostly to majiffy actually being a good player and the town being one of the most apathetic towns I've every played with
seriously guys I am the worst as scum because I absolutely hate it, so if I win at scum town must be doing something severely wrong.

[Majiffy]

So you're saying that if I follow your flowchart and it works, you're probably scum?

[Hoopla]

That was the point. The kill made no sense coming from me, and you had all the reasons in the world to get rid of Elyse.

that's what i assumed you were going for, but i would have expected you to highlight the point more.

[Chevre]

What do you guys think about the one-shot neighborizer? I didn't use it because I couldn't feasibly see a position where it would be beneficial to my game.

[Ankamius]

I was really surprised to see myself nightkilled. That was one time I figured for sure that I'd survive for sure.

[jmo16mla]

Lol at nul.

I thought he was a PR night one, but didn't want to kill him because he suspected me, you know, wifom.

That turned out to be bad for me in the next day though.