In post 1834, Amrun wrote:I have literally said the opposite of what you just said, though: Baezu is not scum for lurking. Baezu is scum for the things (s)he has posted, which I find scummy. Her newest reads list was the least terrible thing she has posted, but I still didn't find it terribly internally consistent, or like that it took L-1 levels of pressure for her to produce. I want to analyze it a bit better when not limited access. Why are you ignoring the biggest reason for Baezu scum, her initial catch up and posts about elvis? It's pretty significant. I found that really scummy.
Ironically enough, it was that reads list that convinced both fery and myself that Baezu is town. (And the fuckawful AtE right before). It's terrible. I wanted her dead for it. Fery convinces me to take a look at some of her completed games just to make sure this is scum behavior. And dear merciful God, it cannot be more obvious that Baezu is as town as town Baezu gets. It's pretty apparent that she has no fucking clue what's going on here (and that in and of itself is a towntell). Pretty sure we explained this.
As for the initial catchup and elvis posts, they're very sheepy. Super poorly explained, even more poorly justified. However, in the light of recent meta, it's pretty obvious she's fucking lost and sheeping whatever the hell reads she agrees with. Originally I construed it from scum going with the flow, but after looking at her scumgames it's pretty goddamn obvious that's not what she does as scum. I misread her, and you are too.
In post 1834, Amrun wrote:Broseidon I've pretty clearly articulated. My scumread on him formed, in REAL TIME, over the course of discussing things with him. I liked Zoidberg's case on Bro related to the vote parking, but his response to that case was far scummier than that. He used very bizarre defenses, such as "I didn't mention my lurker vote much because I am lurking, duh," amongst other things that are smack-me-across the face scummy. In addition, he is in a group of five players that are four town reads + him, with one mod-confirmed scum.
Zoidberg's case was "BRO hasn't done shit", or, more simply, "BRO is a lurker". That's a shitty case. Furthermore, BRO's reaction was "Well no shit, I'm lurking". Hmm, can't imagine why he'd have that reaction to Zoidberg's case. Did he flail a hell of a lot? Yup. Is that scummy for BRO, given the knowledge (now) that he's probably a cop? Nope. Again, see JobPick. Or hell, see him in Xenoblade, where he was scum. Either will show you what I mean. Not only that, but when BRO felt threatened, what did he do? He
deliberately crumbed his role and dethy results.
Yes, he did. He crumbed them to me specifically. I didn't figure it out about the dethy specifically since I've never even heard of it until now (and it's dumb, you should be ashamed of yourself 4nxi3ty), but I got the gist: here's these people (namely rofl and Slandaar I believe he was referring to), I know they're town, don't fuck with them. Why in the name of seven fucks would scum-BRO go so far out of his way to crumb that information to me? The info was confirmed by Slandaar when he outed the dethy to the world.
So no, BRO isn't scum.
In post 1834, Amrun wrote:Zoidberg is not scum with broseidon because of how his (good) case brought the game to a head and really put the limelight on bro.
His good case was shit. It also, fascinatingly, timed with BRO suspicion coming to a head in the QT, something that
no townie could possibly have known about when he posted
.