NY 166: Knight-Errant 18p - Game Over!

[Metal Sonic]

For no reason

[Marquis]

Ok fine I believe MS.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Beast

We'll just have to vote KX tomorrow, folks. Don't lynch Beast until everybody posts and I can figure out who KX is with.

[KX]

@NotSci, your logical fallacy is Ad Hominem. Ad hominem attacks can take the form of overtly attacking somebody, or more subtly casting doubt on their character or personal attributes as a way to discredit their argument. The result of an ad hom attack can be to undermine someone's case without actually having to engage with it. Using Ad Hominem is generally regarded as something exceptionally scummy. So, I'll take that as a no, you haven't come up with a defense yet. Also, since when am I not trying to lynch you, and care to back up your claim of me as scum with reasoning?

@Metal, you are aware of this games set-up, correct? There are four PRs, two Masons, who are guaranteed to be in the set-up, and then two other PRs who's roles are determined by a chart on the first page. Also, I believe that the serial killer has a one-shot strongman, so you actually aren't killproof.

@Marquis, what the actual fuck again. There are only two mafia left. Beast is obviously mafia. Therefore, if I have a partner, that partner has to be Beast. And nowhere do I say "that's not fair, stop targetting me." Instead, I question your vote's anti-town nature, and show why your "reason" is shit. In regards to calling out HD, since when do me and HD play at all alike, and I believe I already explained why the D1 lurking thing was stupid. NotSci actually doesn't need to defend himself, since everybody appears to believe he's clean and I'm scum, but in general when somebody calls you scum, you either explain why you aren't scum, or get lynched for being scum.

[notscience]

Nah, that condescension makes the case all on its own

[KX]

@NotSci, can't remember what it's called, but basically it's a Fallacy in Debate where, because of the way an opponent states something, you discard what they've stated. Maybe if you stopped making logical fallacies, there would be less condescension?

[dopog]

vote beastcharizard

[dopog]

whoops

vote beastcharizard

[Marquis]

lol

KX is scum

But with who

KX ruling out that Beast could be SK lol.

I'm not going to respond to your other statements right now because it's 3 AM and because there's not much I can do when someone decides to be a butthead in addition to being scum

(also stop talking about NS unfairly discrediting you when you're pretty much discrediting me in a worse way. If you really are town thinking he's scum then why the hell does him getting his logic right matter and why do you so badly want him to townread you??)

[The Knight-Errant]

Vote Count 3.1

beastcharizard (4) - Metal Sonic, KX, Marquis, dopog
Marquis (1) - Evil Regals
Metal Sonic (1) - meeps

Not Voting (7) - oriole, beastcharizard, Hopkirk, Abdelrahman, Shattered Viewpoint, EddieFenix, notscience

Countdown:
(expired on 2013-09-15 20:00:00)

13 alive, 7 to lynch.

[beastcharizard]

MS your claim is crazy. Also, strange how you choose the role the exact opposite to me. Mafia has a bullet proof role and it is a possibility with my 3-shot commuter role. I am thinking that you tried to shoot me last night and are mad you missed. I no longer think you are SK though but rather are with the scum team.

As KX, the actual serial killer, pointed out he has a strongman kill so if your role is real you just outed yourself to get killed tonight. I don't think you are that dumb and coupled with the fact that my role is real you are faking it.

[notscience]

VOTE: BC

Last post is a scumclaim, thanks for letting us know mafia has a BP

[Metal Sonic]

i wanted to unvote when reaising that masons werent PRs in the 4-role thing

then i saw BC's post right up there^

"lol nah"

[Metal Sonic]

actually wait


i'll work this out

http://prntscr.com/1ov6er

http://prntscr.com/1ov6lw

^setup poissibilities


because i didnt read the rules/setup (properly)


all i did was to include the setups which has "Town BP + Mafia RB"

none of them have "Town 3Commute" in them together (I think?)


so beast lynch thanks

thats double checked


triple check for me pls guys

[Metal Sonic]

i've triple checked

T 3Com only occurs in 6/48 of the setup posibilities.

none of them have Town BP

2/6 of them have Mafia Roleblocker


therefore beast is lying through his fire-breathing mouth



lynch beast ALL CLEAR

[Metal Sonic]

if beast is SK even better

i will be unkillable

[KX]

@Marquis, how am I discrediting you? And if you really think, after yesterday, Beast is SK . . . wow. I don't see how you can think beast is so town the votes by him don't mean anything, but so scum that compared to metal he deserves lynching. I keep pushing on NotSci not because I want his logic to match up or for him to townread me, but because I want other people to take notice of the fact that his logic doesn't match up, and want to keep that an active topic instead of letting it drop away.

@NotSci, my genuine apologies, thinking it over I realize I was rather mean to you, sorry for doing so, I was frusterated and in part took it out on you knowing you couldn't defend yourself.

@Metal, your claim isn't for nothing, a set-up were the town has both a bulletproof and a commuter is impossible, meaning it's still a counter-claim.

@All, beast's sentances make very little grammatical sence anyway, isn't it possible he's simpky talking about that of the two setups with a commuter and roleblocker, one also has a mafia bulletproof? That said, if you'll belive this mistake condemns his as scum, how can you believe his activity yesterday didn't make him scum? And on yesterday, I must say beast, valiant effort even if it didn't work.

[Hopkirk]

VOTE: Vote beastcharizard

L-1

[Metal Sonic]

hammer so we got extra time


cmon serial killer come sh00t me

it will be the 2nd time i ever get nightkilled in forum mafia

im too good at being a bad target for nightkilling

[Metal Sonic]

except in this game for some bell curve reason i somehow become one of the pro-towns or mostly experienced

yeah im dying by night this game

[Marquis]

KX your defense is bad and you should feel bad. All of that is scum motivated reasonimg and while I can't point out much on a phone, your tone and attitude toward other players are way off.

[Metal Sonic]

hammer beast and stuff

wagon analysis is probably useless since he may have a possibility of getting bussed(if scum) or crushed(if SK)

lets have +13 days for the next day

[Shattered Viewpoint]

Vote: beastcharizard

[EddieFenix]

If SV just hammered, then we Policy Lynch him tomorrow.

[EddieFenix]

Hopkirk and SV need rope. This is just bad footing all around.

[beastcharizard]

KX is SK. I promise you on this. I tried to kill him last night.