NY 166: Knight-Errant 18p - Game Over!

[zMuffinMan]

my understanding is that he's not technically confirmed scum if town has a roleblocker... and there's always the possibility that, you know, beast was lying. but sure, whatever. i'm happy to have him lynched if it means i get to lurk through the day without reading.

i will try everything in my power to prevent you and maquis getting the hammer, though.

[notscience]

No shit we both can't

But I need my poetic justice

[The Knight-Errant]

Vote Count 4.2

KX (1) - Evil Regals
notscience (1) - zMuffinMan

Not Voting (9) - dopog, notscience, Marquis, meeps, Yraelz, Shattered Viewpoint, KX, EddieFenix, Metal Sonic

Countdown:
(expired on 2013-10-03 15:00:00)

11 alive, 6 to lynch.

[Metal Sonic]

will watch "Kx attempts to mislynch notscience" show

meanwhile will also watch "notsci vs marquis FIGHT FOR THE HAMMER"

[Shattered Viewpoint]

I am the other Mason.

Vote: KX

[Metal Sonic]

oh boy

and i thought you were a scumbutt

why did you claim


any counterclaims????

[notscience]

Any CCs?

[KX]

I already said why NotSci is scum. Nobody gave a fuck. I could restate what I previously said but with more eloquence, but the content wouldn't change very much. Next push would be one on Marquis. Considering SV's claim, and assuming nobody counter-claims, he can't be SK, so I have to cross him off, and there are a few things about Marquis looking seriously bad. Can't post now, but weekend coming up, so I should have time during it. Also, can anybody explain why to me why my explanation of why Beast's claim on me is bull, and can NotSci and Marquis elaborate on if they think I'm scum or SK, since Marquis seems to be saying I'm SK while NotSci is saying I'm scum. As for Muffin, please read asap. @Evil, Metal, and Shattered, assuming you two aren't just bandwagoning, why do you think I'm scum? Final note, if there is a Roleblocker, they really should claim, since the lack of kills basically confirms that they're going on scum.

[Marquis]

beast had no reason to lie after being hammered, you must be sk or were doc'ed which i doubt. his scumplay was bad which leads me to believe he was telling the truth

your pre-hd-hammer behavior was scummy as hell too, and end of day 2 all of your posts looked and sounded incredibly forced, sticking around simply for towncred. the fact that you were asking scumhunting-sounding questions means nothing since sk needs to do that too, and your scumslips lie in how your attacks on notsci grow progressively weaker because you're still "scumreading" him for the sake of trying to show consistency, and the fact that you're not already voting him with muffin's vote on him too makes no sense.

hint: if you scumread notscience, vote him. that's what i'm doing with you, except notsci and i are caught in a perpetual battle for the hammer which is really annoying but i srsly want it

p.s. you also pretty much confessed but now that there's subs which may not want to lynch you, you're trying to play it off as town giving up/sarcasm.

we're lynching you. and i want the hammer

[Evil Regals]

@1341

pretty sure there is possibility of tracker/doctor/roleblocker too

24. M RB, T Track, M BP, T BP
29. T Track, M BP, T BP, M RB
31. M BP, T BP, M RB, T Cop
32. M BP, T BP, M RB, T RB
39. T Doc, M BP, T BP, M RB
45. M BP, T Cop, M RB, T BP

so it may explain the fact there was only one kill the last two nights roleblocker may have hit a mafia or used it on kx. afaik strongman cannot be roleblocked tho according to the wiki, butthe game mechanics does not specifically state it does tho.

@mod

can you clarify if strongman bypasses roleblock or not

also reading through the game mechanics

5. Players are not told if their action failed, unless they used an investigative ability. So Trackers, Watchers, Gunsmiths, and Cops know if their action failed, but not other roles.

so if beast did try to kill kx, he may have been roleblocked, as im pretty sure the roleblocked player does not know if they were roleblocked, and the above rule suggest he does not know if his kill failed which made beast assume he was sk

but yeah, this is just assuming we have a town rb, we may still have cop/tracker/doctor. if doctor is in they may have just managed to protect the same target as who the mafia/sk attempted to kill (so kx could have been protected by doctor)

if cop/tracker is in most of wat i posted is irrelevant then lol

but i do feel confident the last town pr is roleblocker

I don't get this logic at all.

You are possibly scum too.

I can see SV being the last mason. Make sense now with Purple's comments towards me.

[KX]

If Beast were the last on his team, I'd agree with you, but he wasn't. He still had a reason to lie in that it might help his remaining partner. How does bad scumplay mean he can't be lying? If anything, the fact that he lies badly makes the bad logic leading up to why he'd kill me makes it seem like a lie even more.

Scummy how? You can say whatever you want, but without reasoning it's bullshit. I want my vote to mean something. What's the point in voting NotSci if he's not going to get lynched. Where do I scumslip? Ok, so yesterday I go on a passionate rage rant taking out my frustration with the NotSci case, and it's scummy, and now I've given up voting him, and it's scummy. Also, because I'm SK, I need to scumhunt since it helps me as much as town, but obviously my scumhunting is faked and only done for town-cred. One more thing, I apparently give up, and then become interesting again in the game because there are subs, despite the subs happening before I supposedly gave up. Good job.

[notscience]

lol

so much "ugh cant do anything just gotta flip shit"

Seb I really want that hammer

[zMuffinMan]

As for Muffin, please read asap.

only serial killers want people to read.

[zMuffinMan]

i will probably stop being lazy and read the thread this afternoon.

[notscience]

Okay muffin heres all you need to know

I'm town

KX is the SK

[meeps]

@1359

what do you not understand

either cop, tracker, doctor, roleblocker is the other town pr

the result of one kill occurring the last three nights may be attributed to either a roleblocker or doctor being the other town pr

beast did not know if he was roleblocked or kx did actually evade his kill (assuming he didnt lie) so rb may have been on him when he attempted to kill

the remaining mafia, attempting to kill kx or ms would be a really silly move as ms is claimed bp and kx was not killed when beast targetted him.

and yeah, sv being mason is plausible as purple rose was somewhat defensive to sv (posts 387, 566, 568, 570, 1076, 1173 in particular)

[meeps]

@1359

what do you not understand

either cop, tracker, doctor, roleblocker is the other town pr

the result of one kill occurring the last three nights may be attributed to either a roleblocker or doctor being the other town pr

beast did not know if he was roleblocked or kx did actually evade his kill (assuming he didnt lie) so rb may have been on him when he attempted to kill

the remaining mafia, attempting to kill kx or ms would be a really silly move as ms is claimed bp and kx was not killed when beast targetted him.

and yeah, sv being mason is plausible as purple rose was somewhat defensive to sv (posts 387, 566, 568, 570, 1076, 1173 in particular)

[KX]

once more; why would beast kill me if he knew another power role? and forgive me, might not get around to making the main posts tonight.

[zMuffinMan]

Okay muffin heres all you need to know

I'm town

KX is the SK

2 questions. who's the last scum and was oriole obvtown before he flaked?

[Metal Sonic]

Okay muffin heres all you need to know

I'm town

KX is the SK

you forgot me




@muffin

last scum unknown, oriole was not obvtown before flaking

[Evil Regals]

Meeps due to confidence in your post.

Anyways can we stop fighting over the damn hammer and actually lynch scum? Thanks in adv.

Muffin vote KX.

Ms vote KX.

[zMuffinMan]

has kx claimed?

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: KX

p-edit no

[Evil Regals]

Marquis is probably the last scum, js.

[Evil Regals]

Or dopoq for the hammer, but it was so close to DL so maybe not. I have to recheck in the morning to see if someone stayed on Beast after he claimed. He would have known it was a lie and distanced,