Town won 46% of Matrix 6 games

[Alduskkel]

@OP: I'm most interested in seeing the stats on the individual setups of Matrix6.

And yeah, replacing out should have some moderate penalty for more experienced users, that can be wavered on a case by case basis by either the game moderator or the list mods (if the latter then the system needs to make it at least something of a hassle for the user so that the list mods aren't overworked).

Replacements are just plain annoying and are a disruption to the natural game state. As a player it can be annoying because it drastically changes a slot, especially if I'm scum and have been carefully cultivating the game state so far. As a moderator it's annoying for obvious reasons, but especially when there are so many replacements that deadline extensions are required.

[Alduskkel]

I am not convinced the results are statistically significant.

@emerald: Of course 1-shot BP is weaker than the other PRs. It can only help itself and only once.

[Alduskkel]

Sorry, I meant the balance statistics. I wasn't looking at the replacement statistics.

[Alduskkel]

Setup 1 being biased against the Mafia makes little sense to me; Jailkeepers are powerful but not that powerful.
Setup 2's stats are definitely screwed up. This thread shows that the F11 setup with Cop/Doc/M. RB was about 55-45 M-T
Setup 3 is obviously scumsided, but it's difficult to say if the statistics are portraying it as more scumsided than it actually is.
Setup A seems fine.
Setup B seems fine although those F11 statistics I linked gave a 65-35 breakdown instead, oddly enough.
Setup C is probably not as scumsided as it appears.

So, sadly, there's not much that can be concluded about balance I think.

[Alduskkel]

Actually, the two setups showing 70-30 M-T win percentages are definitely not as scumsided as that because the all-VT version of F11 was about 70-30. Since the two setups both have two PRs they clearly should trend better for the town than 70-30.