- BipolarChemist
Day 1:
Night 1:
Day 2:
Night 2:
Day 3:
Endgame:
1. goodmorning
2. RedCoyote
3. TierShift
1. BipolarChemist
2. BROseidon
3. Formerfish
1. Blackfish
2. LeMidget
3. Who
Why would you need a private thread if you are town?In post 12, TierShift wrote:So, are we gonna majority FoS or just let the groups decide for themselves? I'd prefer the latter.
And uh, are we getting private threads? The opening post hinted at it
Why would I need one if I were scum?In post 13, Blackfish wrote:Why would you need a private thread if you are town?In post 12, TierShift wrote:So, are we gonna majority FoS or just let the groups decide for themselves? I'd prefer the latter.
And uh, are we getting private threads? The opening post hinted at it
You'd need one if you were scum to talk to your scumbuddies obviously. The OP mentions that it is in lieu of QTs. Why would the groups of 3 get anything analogous to QTs? That doesn't make any sense.In post 16, TierShift wrote:Why would I need one if I were scum?In post 13, Blackfish wrote:Why would you need a private thread if you are town?In post 12, TierShift wrote:So, are we gonna majority FoS or just let the groups decide for themselves? I'd prefer the latter.
And uh, are we getting private threads? The opening post hinted at it
I was wondering if the groups of 3 got a private forum but prolly not.
But it said "in lieu" of QT's. QTs are generally used by scum to talk among themselves. Why make the assumption that town would receive them?In post 20, TierShift wrote:I dunno, I saw 'this game is being used as a test case for private threads' and I just assumed.
Nothing about the nature of the game suggested that the three groups would have private communication. As far as I understood it, the group divisions are made solely for voting purposes and to help town with POE, with group members only being able to vote for themselves and town getting 2 confirmed townies when a mafia member is lynched. This I believe to counteract the mountainous effect of the game and provide a mechanic to help town in the absence of power roles. I assumed scum use the private threads instead of having a scum QT since that's what the OP implied. I am not following why I should think that the game implies town have private communication.In post 15, Who wrote:It's the fishes.
VOTE: Blackfish
Why would you assume that they are only for scum when the nature of the game (Town being divided into groups) implies that it could be for town as well?