Scummies 2014 - Nomination Thread!

[Bulbazak]

Nominate 4nxi3ty's Imaginary Fights for best flavor.

You got to it before I could.

2nd. I'd also like to nominate the game for Best Setup.

The setup really worked with the flavor to create a unified whole and one of the most unique experiences I've had while playing a mafia game. I'd actually compare it more to a literary work as far as theme goes. It echoed in everything from flavor, to role PMs, to the actual roles themselves. Everything fit perfectly. The setup was balanced in a way that the game remained close, even until the bitter end, and even when either side seemed down, there was always a way to win utilizing the mechanics of the game. This game engaged the puzzle solving aspect of my brain better than any mafia game before it, where I had to try to think several moves ahead given the roles of the setup, and I was town! It's among my favorite games so far, and it's not one I will soon forget.

[Bulbazak]

Nomination for Best Performance: Pro-Town

:

emogirl123 in NY 170: Georgetown II

. She withstood being at L-1 in a mountainous game, corrected the approach that led people to vote for her, and correctly (and doggedly) outed scum in a game where most players tended to be over the map.

2nd

Major props.

[Bulbazak]

in that there was no player who had all three as the scumteam

I think Pidgey nailed the team at one point, but then he let paranoia carry him away.

2nd both noms

[Bulbazak]

I've played with Bjc a few times. Unless he's stepped up his game, I haven't been impressed.

[Bulbazak]

SKOT is PeaceBringer.

[Bulbazak]

I think it was just a reference to the elasticity of personas on the internet.

[Bulbazak]

Nth Mastin for Excellent Moderation

Her game was my first coming off a several month hiatus, and I looked forward to every minute of it.