Sorry for double post, but I don't think this is Catch 22. It's the pitfall of using AtE in games with (I presume) more logical players. wgeurts lost credibility the moment he self-voted, as does anyone outside of RVS (and some would say inside), so in this case I'm gonna have to defer to Wisdom's reasoning here: frustrated town is usually too frustrated to just go ahead and listen to everyone.
Also, awkward moment when we're all still tunneling wgeurts.
FinnLaw
, you probably didn't notice because I put it in the middle of a line, but I asked what your other reads were, if any.
The problem this game is I've got 4 suspects that I've created (Victor, wgeurts, TTH, Wisdom), but I'm really finding it difficult to even see more than 1 scum in there; I think if I had to pick, it'd be wgeurts-TTH, but even that seems a bit off to me. So let's go PoE.
I'm very much getting a townread on
Mala's
one liner reactions to everything.
blindmewithscience
I'm getting a townread on, he seems like he actaully wants to help and I feel like I'd notice from his first few posts if he was scum (he's very much new to forum mafia, and like I said, I know the guy).
Hmm,
acryon
. I'm a bit biased, because answering questions for other people was one of my problems as town early on. It's not helpful to interrogators but I do see it as trying to help with discussion. Townread on him.
Victor
is town due to the latter half of his ISO. I do hope he posts more results of his questioning though, otherwise I'm still gonna see how he acted in the first few pages as just throwing out suspicions.
Wisdom's
votepost was pretty much the main thing that made me suspect him. I can't see a Wisdom-wgeurts scumteam at all at the moment, so I'll reserve judgment on him until tomorrow. Town for now.
That leaves FinnLaw, TTH, NM, Silver, and Undertaker.
Undertaker
I'm obviously throwing out for now. Did an ISO on
NM
and I realised there's really not as much to discuss as I thought (still not sure what TTH is smoking).
Finn's
whole Catch 22 thing
kinda
leans town, but it also seems like it could be an AtE in defence of a scum-wgeurts (as in "we're being unfair to this guy, give him a chance"). There's also how he responded to wgeurts self-voting. I can see a Finn-wgeurts team. Lean null-scum for now.
TTH
I've already stated my thoughts on. Can't get a friggin read due to her playstyle. She's my only non-lurking nullread.
If you skimmed this post, this is the part where you start reading.
Which leaves us at
SilverWolf
, who I actually ISO'd 2nd or 3rd in order to put her in the townreads list. See, when I ISO people, I mostly look out for anything that was their original reasoning, anything they created. But then I noticed there was basically none in her ISO. Seriously, take a look at it. I'll be here when you get back. Or you could keep Silver's ISO on another tab while you read the below, since I don't expect you to click a dozen links.
Alright.
35 repeats what I said about reaction testing.
84 is literally "I agree".
85 and 86 are suspicion and a vote for Victor, I don't think I have to explain how this isn't new.
95 is literally repeating my (and possibly other's) reasoning for voting Victor.
121 is jumping on Mala's "Stop butting in, acryon, sheesh" train of thought.
135, repetition of wgeurts reasoning for voting Newbie.
207 is fencesitting on the me vs wgeurts issue. Free pass on
238 since I literally asked for her thoughts on Wisdom and NM. And finally,
257 (unvote yourself, wgeurts) was already said by Finn.
I spent most of the game under the impression Silver was being helpful and contributing, but there have been 0 no lines of reasoning in the ENTIRETY of the ISO. I think Silver is playing it safe, blending in. And with that I have my new 2nd highest suspect.
FoS: SilverWolf
. Someone let me know if I'm crazy on this by the way, that took a long time to do. Also open to defence on Silver's part, but honestly, more contribution from her will do more than responding to this post.
Edit: I like Victor's above post.