Once Upon A Winter Night - [Game Over]

[Nobody Special]

Primarily because he got a scum Role PM.

VOTE: curiouskarmadog

[Nobody Special]

But the servants should not name claim in the neighborhood.

Why are you assuming that there is a need for name-claiming within the neighborhood?

[Nobody Special]

But the servants should not name claim in the neighborhood.

Why are you assuming that there is a need for name-claiming within the neighborhood?

I'm not?

I'm assuming that people will always do what they do in neighborhoods and that's claim their characters/roles or suggest it.

It should go without saying, but people shouldn't be claiming their characters in neighborhoods this game.

What I meant was, why do you assume that the neighbors haven't already been told each other's role names?

[Nobody Special]

Also, can everyone stop with the meta-based circlejerk and just play

this

game? Thanks.


/getoffmylawn

[Nobody Special]

Calling it now: ckd + Antihero scum teammates.

[Nobody Special]

Calling it now: ckd + Antihero scum teammates.

just for that future record.

is antihero scum because of my interaction with him

or is he scum on some other actions you deem scummy?

if I flip town, is antihero still scum or back to "?"

Antihero is being too "over the top" to be real; I think it's his feeble attempt at distancing. So, to answer your question directly, it's the interaction.

[Nobody Special]

@nobody special: You're sheeping abr too?

Yes. Problem?

Nobody Special, what are your reads?

Town:
ABR
Bert
Gaiden
Tammy

notscience?


Null:
Equinox
Konowa
Kovara
Katsuki

beastcharizard?
Hooney Bee?


Scum:
Marquis?
ckd
Antihero

With the exception of name cop ability, all actions must have character name as their target.

Hey tammy

What do you think of Mara's post with the above being noted?

Thinking about it.

I'm not sure scum mara does that. I don't think it's a good idea though, but I was interested if anyone else reacted to it.

Who does mara refer to?

actually, scrap that this cub has another idea!

katsuki
Konowa
SXTLHGaiden
Honey Bee
Albert B. Rampage
beastcharizard
Nobody Special
notscience

I think these guys should either name-claim, or claim PR. That way, it'll force the scum-team to make sub-optimal kills each night. I also think that, among those who claimed name, we should keep our lynch pool in there because we will lynch scum eventually, and it means we probably won't lynch any of the PR's. Since we are making names public, we could also lynch the name cop each day phase, in the chance they are scum, they won't learn the names of those we want to keep hidden.

pedit: that's how I understand it, yes!

How did you arrive at this list?

You can't seriously expect us to believe this is you scumhunting...

Surely I can pretend?

Are you scum?

[Nobody Special]

Perhaps I'll find out over time.

[Nobody Special]

NS, why is CKD Scum?

I agree wholeheartedly with post #8 (and far less so than #7). So it's primarily a flavor-based read; one which I came to independently from but apparently simultaneously with ABR.

[Nobody Special]

Scum might be able to decide which character to kill without knowing which player has that character's role.

I took this as given, with the added surprise of "Oh look! XYZ died!" if they didn't know who that role was beforehand.

Perhaps I'm reading too much into it.

[Nobody Special]

Alternatively, it might be that they have to choose a player and associate the correct role to that person in order for the kill to go through.

What if it's the above? Is there any proof it's not?

No, no proof; but it seems unnecessarily complex to require a linked playername/charactername in order to kill. This is getting dangerously close to outguessing the mod, but it just seems

really

unlikely.

[Nobody Special]

I also have a reason I'm not interested in Beast lynch that I'll fight for to stop.

Do you mean

"I will fight against a beast lynch because

reasons

"

or do you mean

"I'm not interested ENOUGH in a beast lynch for

reasons

"

....or something else?

(Sorry for not understanding.)

[Nobody Special]

Calling it now: ckd + Antihero scum teammates.

I'm comfortable switching.

unvote

Vote: Antihero

[Nobody Special]

That's L-1.

[Nobody Special]

Marquis is still the way to go.

That may be, but there is no way we'll get a flashwagon in less than 24 hours, right before Christmas, during a marathon weekend. Perhaps tomorrow.

[Nobody Special]

Bert, NobodySpecial, back on CKD. Let's proceed with this lynch and stop the Antihero wagon in its tracks.

If the ckd wagon picks up again, I will switch. I plan on being here near deadline, as well.

[Nobody Special]

I don't think it's all that dangerous, as I think Antihero and ckd are a team.

[Nobody Special]

Oh, alright.

unvote

Vote: curiouskarmadog

[Nobody Special]

Why not?

[Nobody Special]

Why do you think all these people are scum?

Why not?

This is not an acceptable answer to beastcharizard's question. Why do you think there might be two scum in the immediate line of succession? How did you come to the conclusion that Antihero and curiouskarmadog are a team?

People, seriously. There is a game here, and it would help if you read it. I have not been vague about why I think ckd and Antihero are a scumteam. Check my iso, it's short. Okay, fine: I think Antihero's histrionics early on were too over-the-top to be real; it seemed like distancing (from ckd). ckd is scum for the flavor reason ABR stated (that I'm sheeping).

And I think that numbers of scum potentially in the line of succession is in the realm of outguess-the-mod, so therefore not up for discussion.

[Nobody Special]

especially Nobody Special

, who seems to think that any wagon is perfectly fine whee happy fun times --

I seriously object to this mischaracterization. I have been on precisely two wagons today -- and both I have long maintained are scum. You are making it seem as though I'm wagon-hopping willy-nilly without a care in the world, and that's just false.

You seem town to me thus far...... are you trying to change that?

[Nobody Special]

I know you think CKD and Anti are a scum team. I was talking about the Marquis/CKD thing. You have to think they are on the same team. You also never gave a reason for Marquis being scum and you put a question mark next to his name in your reads list.

I don't really have an actual reason for scum!Marquis (thus the question mark); I am more-or-less aware of the sentiment that he is scum, but I'm not really sure I buy it. Maybe. It's obviously not a solid read.

I haven't really put a lot of thought into whether Marquis/ckd/Antihero all make sense together, I was more focused on ckd (and then Antihero) for today.

[Nobody Special]

Just looking for a reaction, I guess.

[Nobody Special]

I am like the only one saying Marquis is scum so you are just grabbing onto my sentiment and going with it? What makes you do that?

I thought it was more than just you. I'd have to look.

[Nobody Special]

Whoever wants towncred can point out why [my vote on Honey bee is] not moving.

I would love the free towncred, but honestly, I don't see why you're voting her. She is pretty solidly town, to me.

Step 1: Lynch Antihero
Step 2: Lynch Nobody Special
Step 3: ????
Step 4: Profit

I would not follow this plan of action if I were you. I think we should give AH some time to assert his towniness, if possible.

but I do want names of NS and Gaiden.

I may have missed it, but why do you want my name?

[Nobody Special]

Fine, then.

Tell us your name.

[Nobody Special]

I could've sworn I posted Intent to Hammer.

So, here:

Intent to Hammer

[Nobody Special]

VOTE: Antihero

[Nobody Special]

You

order

me?

[Nobody Special]

one of the neighbors can watch the same target. Other neighbor can notsci.

It's almost like you know exactly how many servants there are.

[Nobody Special]

Yes, I am prince of the pridelands, and as future king I order you to give me your character name. If it wasn't obvious,

I'm town-cop

(though, because I'm so young and inexperienced, I spend all of N1 learning how my role worked, and thus couldn't take an action) and I copped Geneviere/notsci who is now confirmed town poisoner.

No, Kovara is the claimed cop, not Konowa.

I have no issue with a massclaim.

[Nobody Special]

Oh, I thought we were massclaiming names AND roles. I guess I misunderstood.

So, anyway, I'm Aria Chatowic, Maid and Town Neighbor Watcher. Also daughter of Matthew.

Although I am still in favor of massclaiming both roles AND names.

[Nobody Special]

In the absence of any other wagon at all, I'm placing this vote in case I'm not around near deadline:

VOTE: Gaiden

[Nobody Special]

I sincerely apologize for my absence. I have been overwhelmed recently.

I also sincerely apologize for allowing my busy schedule to prevent me from submitting a night action.

My schedule has become more manageable now and yes, I do understand that I am watching Kovara tonight.

Having said all that, I need to go back and re-read about Honey bee, as I do not understand why she is scum. I also think two scum-watchers in a neighborhood of three is excessive, but this is Fake God, after all.

[Nobody Special]

Yes. Watching Kovara tonight.

[Nobody Special]

Okay. I read more carefully and see the result on HB.

Shall we lynch now, or are there other matters {ooba, beast} we should attend to?

[Nobody Special]

Anyone played with HB prior to this? Does she lurk as scum? She has the lowest post-count aside from an altslip. That includes all the dead people.

[Nobody Special]

Okay. I read more carefully and see the result on HB.

Shall we lynch now, or are there other matters {ooba, beast} we should attend to?

Why specifically these two?

Because they were the two that stuck out in my mind at 5 this morning just before bed?

I'd feel better if nobody special said he forgot to submit actions both nights than his schedule prevented him from it when I've seen him on site.

I don't really have much more to say about the day and considering this is mega lurk had game, I doubt anyone else does either, but I kind of want to wait and have nobody special confirm that he has placed a watch target on kovara before we lynch honey so he doesn't oops it.

I am checking with Mod as to whether I can submit a night action prior to nightfall; however, rest assured I am available enough to submit during Night this time.

Also, Kovara, to save me the trouble of looking, what's your character name?

[Nobody Special]

Honey bee and I are neighbors (along with AH).

I'm sure she posted a summary of our conversation.

[Nobody Special]

I have been told that FG will accept early actions, so I have submitted it.

[Nobody Special]

No way. Seriously?

[Nobody Special]

I'm rather taken aback that she's scum. Although, as noted earlier, she was rather lurky. I guess I'm more surprised that there were two scum neighbor watchers.

[Nobody Special]

No one visited Lydia Norweld last night.

[Nobody Special]

Katsuki is scum too.

Let's make a bet. If I'm town, you write me a nice 100k USD (or pound) check. If I'm scum I'll give you my soul and a plate of Tammys. Deal?

You know better than this. Stop.

[Nobody Special]

I am concerned about nobody special right now. I was expecting honey bee to flip sophia.

nobody special's dad is our first scum lynch;

how much do we believe she wasn't involved either.

Actually, no. My father was a VT.

[Nobody Special]

VOTE: ooba

This is where we are voting today.

Just for giggles, please tell us explicitly

why.

[Nobody Special]

VOTE: Konowa

[Nobody Special]

Eh, probably because ooba was in my to lynch list leading up to Today, but Mara and beast's weird push on him considering things is making me back off of that.
I have you solidly as Town.
I'm sticking with my read on kats as disinterested Town over lurker Scum.
notsci's Night actions make him Town.
Leaves {NS, Mara, beast}.

You realize I am cop cleared right?

I have my doubts about said cop's alignment.

[Nobody Special]

Yes, the three of you not voting..... why not?

[Nobody Special]

Nobody Special - Sophia Norweld, pseudonym: Aria Chatowic - Secret Daughter of the Norweld Household, pretending to be: Maid of the Norsweld Household - Town Watcher Neighbor

Nothing like finding out you aren't who you think you were....

[Nobody Special]

The Lovers PT is still private.