2015 Open Setup Design Contest - Winners!

[mykonian]

Replay ability means that if we look at your setup and there is a very clear course of actions that optimizes play for town it will lose some points.

That is called beaking the game. It should fall under balance.
Now 80% of the score is decided by balance, way too much imo. Is there any way this can still be changed?

I feel balance is a part of fun.

90% in fun is way too much, please change this

[mykonian]

You think there is a difference between balance and replay ability, myko?

empking already said it better than I could, but on top of that, they are just arbitrary numbers that set the boundaries to a contest. Arguing them doesn't really go anywhere, they'll stay pretty arbitrary even when moved. In the end you'll still be designing opens that you think are going to score well in the categories.