Open 590: Diffusion of Power (Town Win)

[Newbie]

/confirm

VOTE: BBT

Out of the two hard pushing a newbie, GC seemed more genuine.

[Newbie]

@

Creative

What alignment do you think each of Mentor, BBT, and GC are?

[Newbie]

I found that statement weird as well. It sounded a little too sure pertaining to three players' alignments.

[Newbie]

I hope this game doesn't become those that one has to state about his unsureness every single time he gives a read, it gets really redundant. Mafia is a game of imperfect information, not even scum has all the info in the game. Of course the info i discussed is one that i could have if i was scum, but i mean, do you think that was exactly a 3 town or 3 mafia interaction, it's even statistically unlikely.

Fair enough. I understand your point.

[Newbie]

/confirm
VOTE: BBT
Out of the two hard pushing a newbie, GC seemed more genuine.

@

Creative

What alignment do you think each of Mentor, BBT, and GC are?

I found that statement weird as well. It sounded a little too sure pertaining to three players' alignments.

if you think creative is "weird" for enforcing a false dichotomy, what's so "not weird" about it when you do it?

It's the way it was worded. Since scum know who are who, they sometimes like to connect players, if that makes sense. That's why I asked him for his reads on each so he wouldn't be able to so easily back out of it. I'm satisfied with his posts so far, though.

I also agree about ChriVi.

VOTE: ChriVi

[Newbie]

I googled 'Joke' this did not come up.

but anyway I'm a little surprised you haven't been warned by the mod for being overly volatile to other players, 'GTFO piece of trash and I'm blacklisting you after the game' is quite excessive for questioning if you had ever run into a suicidal townie before.

I have however seen players flip out Anti early into a game when they are both scum, therefore

Can you clarify what you mean by this?

[Newbie]

Anti was the first to vote Chriv when Chriv had no pressure on him at all, though.

[Newbie]

I'm surprised that Chrivi didn't continue to engage further with killa and that it's just these few posts.

@ ChriVi: I am not sure how you selfvote in one post, then chastise BBT in the next for being suicidal? Seems a little weird to me.

@Not_mafia: I'm not a fan of seeing naked votes thrown about, keep it up and I'll vote you on principle.

@all: start attaching reasoning to your votes, when you vote or risk being misread as scum.

@ ChriVi: I am not sure how you selfvote in one post, then chastise BBT in the next for being suicidal? Seems a little weird to me.

Google: Joke

I googled 'Joke' this did not come up.

but anyway I'm a little surprised you haven't been warned by the mod for being overly volatile to other players, 'GTFO piece of trash and I'm blacklisting you after the game' is quite excessive for questioning if you had ever run into a suicidal townie before.

I have however seen players flip out Anti early into a game when they are both scum, therefore

vote: ChriVi

[Newbie]

/confirm
VOTE: BBT
Out of the two hard pushing a newbie, GC seemed more genuine.

@

Creative

What alignment do you think each of Mentor, BBT, and GC are?

I found that statement weird as well. It sounded a little too sure pertaining to three players' alignments.

if you think creative is "weird" for enforcing a false dichotomy, what's so "not weird" about it when you do it?

It almost seems like killa knows what Chriv will flip and is using early associative reads to connect him to another player by reaching.

[Newbie]

Sorry. Ignore the quote in that post. Didn't mean to quote anything.

[Newbie]

Killa

post 170: The tone of this post comes off as too cautious to engage Chrivi, especially the bolded.

post 175: Using pre-flip association + reaching looks like scum knowing there’s a big chance that his partner is being lynched, so he jumps on the wagon for town cred but doesn’t want to come up with any valid reasons, so he just uses pre flip association, connecting a townie to scum.

post 177: How convenient that the interaction that caused the pre flip association stopped him from voting NM for naked voting.

post 240: A bussing attempt.

randomidget

post 182: The is so fake, lol. I would also love to hear randomidget’s reason for why House is confirmed town.

post 248: Omg. He avoids the Chrivi lynch for the whole day and then puts him at L-1 out of nowhere, and his reason is “bc bandwagon”. Would scum act so obviously scummy?

post 250: Lol. Another fake-toned post.

Mentor

post 254: I agree with House. The “late” vote looks planned.

My reads so far are:

Town
BBT
GC
NM
Creative

Null
House
inte

Scum
killa
random
Mentor


VOTE: killa

[Newbie]

Ignore the "especially the bolded part" since I was too lazy to actually quote.

[Newbie]

Dude, how the fuck am I null to you?

Commit to a read before people figure out that we are scum together.

Your sarcastic posts are funny but pretty null atm.

[Newbie]

And droog, you should probably go back and read killa's posts, especially in relation to Chrivi who was scum.

[Newbie]

Do you often agree with null reads?

Not poking at you, I'm simply curious. Personally, I try to get a bead on a player before I give their posts much credence.

Eh. It all depends on the player and the circumstances. Some do things regardless of alignment.

[Newbie]

VOTE: inte

[Newbie]

Why do you think inte and I are town and BBT is possibly one of the mafia?

[Newbie]

@BBT Because I am. I want Creative to answer the question.

[Newbie]

VOTE: Mentor

[Newbie]

@Creative How is NM being a troll and useless? What do you think of droog?

@Mentor Why NM and BBT?

@House So you think Creative is scum who gave his partner a town read, but you're not voting for Creative? Wat.

[Newbie]

Ok. First of all - why is inte town?? Why is Newbie town? I seriously have no recollection of Newbie doing anything substantial.

On the killa wagon, I'm looking at inte, NM or BBT, with preference on inte then BBT.

So you don't think I've done anything to be seen as town by, but you don't have me down as one of your suspects on the killa wagon? Wat.

I would think self-interest comes from being nervous about how people are reading you, and the only people who would be nervous about that are scum

. Town just get mad.

What? Then why am I not a suspect along with BBT and NM?

@Creative How is NM being a troll and useless? What do you think of droog?

@Mentor Why NM and BBT?

@House So you think Creative is scum who gave his partner a town read, but you're not voting for Creative? Wat.

Actually I wanted an excuse to unvote Mentor after he unvoted me, if you want to get technical about it.

So you never thought Mentor was scum in the first place?

[Newbie]

If you're town, can you please put in a little more effort to clear yourself? Who do think the scum are on your wagon? Who do you think is scum that isn't on your wagon? Make cases and reads on them.

[Newbie]

@House You took your vote off of Mentor just because he unvoted you? I thought you had him as scum before that? What happened that changed your mind?

[Newbie]

I find it funny that Mentor didn't address my vote on him.

[Newbie]

Um, so it's possible to have cops for the same nights?

[Newbie]

Somebody hasn't been following the game.

I'm pretty sure I have, that's why I'm wondering if I missed something.

[Newbie]

Newbie, what does a nail need?

Right...

VOTE: BBT

[Newbie]

Oh and also, I was night 1 doctor. Protected GC.

[Newbie]

Why should it matter, though? If you and Mentor are telling the truth, then you two + NM and random are confirmed town. There's only two mafia left which can only be BBT and Creative.

[Newbie]

VOTE: Creative

[Newbie]

Thanks for the game.

Nice work, town.