Mini 1684: Shucking Bullfit Mafia - Game Called

[Pegasus30]

Confirm

[Pegasus30]

This game is setup as 9-3-1 so right off the bat, we have more scum than normal. Assuming one townie can't vote (that's what treestump means, right?), the game can end even faster. Hypothetical: Let's say that third party has a kill and we mislynch on day 1. The third party and mafia kill a townie each. We'll be left with 10 players among which scum control four votes, town control five and one is a treestump. Even if we lynch mafia, we could end up with 7 players the next day 2 of which are mafia, 1 third party, and 3 townie votes. That's not enough to have a town-controlled lynch because we need 4 to lynch. Bottomline - the game may be unwinnable after a single mislynch which is bad game design.

If there is a treestump, it is mathematically more likely to be scum of some sort or have additional powers which activate later on in the game.

Tammy, vote someone please. If you are a tree-stump, then your vote shouldn't count.