It's the Team Mafia Tea Party (Dead Thread)

[Gammagooey]

yeah I was a bit of a jerk in that I basically just played the large theme solo for the most part, if Titus had gotten really close to being lynched I probably would have jumped on but I just had no confidence in people being able to read Titus correctly regardless of what her alignment actually was.

Also my townreads were I think reeally good throughout the whole game but pretty much all of my scumreads until the 4nx+Titus situation started exploding were pretty bad.

[Gammagooey]

ps sorry for tunnelling you so hard day 2 UT

I started having some doubts near the very end of day 2 since pretty much the only people who made sense as possible alquin counterclaims were FF and one or two other superlurkers but figured it'd be better not to voice them in case you were town and scum thought they'd be able to get you lynched.

[Gammagooey]

also, I still just completely don't understand why everyone wanted to murder espy so bad

he did some dumb things but all of them made soooo much more sense to be coming from town than scum

[Gammagooey]

The mini theme getting rerolled changed things pretty significantly too

I think Kats would have played way better as scum there and anyone looking back at Day 1 after the reroll I really think should have seen that shos and LLD were scum together after LLD's terrible switch off of him

Also you guys lynched all of my teammates and they were all town

stop that

[Gammagooey]

also also

hito's flavor is the best you guys

[Gammagooey]

I think given that we'll be rating everyone anyway the teams that had major replacement issues are going to get punished for it there anyway

it's not perfect but team mafia isn't gonna be

[Gammagooey]

hiiiiiii

[Gammagooey]

white flag was the one game I wanted my team to be scum in regardless of who was in it

Statistically it should be a town win more often than it is but I think white flag is 100% about how well scum can manipulate the town.

[Gammagooey]

I liked the ability to swap teammates between games relatively early-game, exactly once, and that it was planned for and fine, but I'd want some sort of penalty for replacing out after that.

Every single scum player in the large theme except Titus replaced out and that is not really okay.

[Gammagooey]

the revolving slot with mollie and eddie in nightless was bad too but Grey and ABR's comments towards her were absolutely unacceptable. ABR's were bad enough that if I were actually modding that game I would instantly force-replace ABR, that was incredibly personal and was meant to be hurtful.

[Gammagooey]

katsuki why is your avatar a bird now?

[Gammagooey]

@sonic-It's almost like the setups are fairly close to balanced and either side could win them depending on how well each side played ohhh man.

Also for as much as everyone hated on him espy did try to get Titus scum lynched day 2 and had a town enough mindset for a few of us to push him hard as town all game, I don't think they were objectively *the best at mafia* here but I'd say they did at least contribute to every win they were a part of. If I were to pick out the team that played the best I'd go with empire+singer+regfan+mina+zar for blowing open the large theme and pushing through a scum win in white flag despite getting screwed with token luck in there and the nightless.

Pretty happy with all of my team's performances at the end of everything except for Hoopla in the nightless, and there I at least understand that the enormous amount of ego and spamposting there was really demotivating.

[Gammagooey]

guys

guys

its over

we're free