Open 39: Crush Nightless - Game Over! before 484

[JDodge]

/confirm

[JDodge]

OMGUS LOLZ

Vote: Crub

Which I somehow managed to mistype three times!

[JDodge]

So, other townies, don't get mislynched, and as town you should obviously scum hunt and try not to lynch town, but townies shouldn't be

that

particular about who is lynched as long as it isn't them -- though we do want to get the mafia first, probably. Ironically, in this game, it is the scum who have particular ideas about who they want lynched and not lynched.

Gee, I thought the idea was to mislynch the townies...

[JDodge]

Still here. Don't get a good feeling from everyone. Will elaborate eventually, once I have had sleep.

[JDodge]

AH I WAS TRYING TO REMEMBER WHICH GAME I PROMISED A POST IN THANK YOU.

Crub has contributed absolutely nothing. He's lurking in plain sight, so-to-speak.

I just don't get a good vibe from Guardian. I think it might have to do with this:

Kerplunk - OMGUS vote. Possible mafia.
schismatized - Too eager. Maybe mafia/lyncher.
Jdodge - Jdodge. The man, the myth, the legend. Obviously town.
Guardian - I am town. See my avatar.
Crub - Random voted Jdodge. Possible mafia.
spectrumvoid - Town?

I don't like people trying to analyze the random. It makes no sense whatsoever.

Kerplunk seems somewhat like a mix between how Guardian and Crub have played so far.

Schism has done absolutely nothing but with an added bonus of being overly-aggressive.

And SV has said absolutely nothing, aside from the fact that she lost really badly in the last nightless game she was in.

[JDodge]

In short because I think a shis lynch is going to mean insta-lose. I don't care if my vote would put him at 4/3/2/1 away I'm not going to vote for the person who I think is probably the lynchee.

I don't like how kerplunk's random vote turned into a serious vote, and I especially don't like the post kerplunk made about finding the lyncher. To me he's trying to subtly confirm himself as not the lyncher.

Having said that

vote: JDodge

for accusing me of lurking in plain sight and then not posting at all.

Sorry, I've been sick.

AT LEAST YOU AREN'T LURKING ANYMORE YAY

[JDodge]

Kerplunk, wouldn't you agree that the whole "I made a mistake" thing could be a quick cover-up?

[JDodge]

Unvote, Vote Count please

I'm fairly certain Kerplunk is the lyncher.

[JDodge]

Why do you think Kerplunk is the lyncher? I get a pro-town feeling from him.

I choose not to say at this time.

[JDodge]

Because I was unsure of how many votes were on you, of course. I didn't want to put you at -1 in case I was wrong.

Vote: Kerplunk

[JDodge]

Jdodge, anytime you want to provide us with reasons, let me know...

I will.

[JDodge]

I don't have any clue who the lynchee is.

[JDodge]

I'm a little skeptical about JDodge being town because he still hasn't provided a really logical reason for his Kerplunk vote, and I think it's strangely late for random votes. He may be a lyncher and d3sisted, I don't know but you seem like mafia to me.

Someone needs to learn two things:

Unexplained =/= random
Unexplained =/= reasonless

[JDodge]

It may seem like that to you, JDodge, but where I come from we use reasons.

What sort of backwards-ass place are you from?

[JDodge]

I would think that would just strengthened the case on Kerplunk as not-town. Not sure if it strengthens Kerplunk-lyncher, though.

[JDodge]

Unvote; Vote No Lynch

On the other hand I haven't found much proof that anyone is anybody, though I still have my suspicion of JDodge.

Mislynchs won't help us at all.

IT'S A FUCKING NIGHTLESS GAME.

LEARN TO REEEEEAD.

[JDodge]

I am too.

HELLO.

THE. GAME. IS. NIGHTLESS.

YOU. CANNOT. NO. LYNCH. IN. A. NIGHTLESS. GAME.

[JDodge]

I fully agree with the above statement and add that it is so full of win I couldn't possibly hope to top it

[JDodge]

I WON'T SAY ANYONE IS ANYTHING BECAUSE THEY COULD BE SOMETHING ELSE

[JDodge]

Jdodge, who's scum?

And give reasons. Enough is enough -- you mock Sammich for it, and you've done 0 scum hunting with reasoning this game, period.

Why do I think you are town again...?

I don't want to give reasons, Guardian, but my guess is now d3sisted and Kerplunk. I feel that Sammich might be newb-lyncher and I might be his target.

[JDodge]

I'm not explaining, so I guess you're just going to have to be "VERY wary".

[JDodge]

WHY aren't you explaining? It's not like the mafia can NK you or something, I can't understand why you don't want to give reasons.

Telling you why would defeat the purpose of not explaining

[JDodge]

Because both you and schism are the only people who have really gone after me the entire game

[JDodge]

Because both you and schism are the only people who have really gone after me the entire game

That's not a valid point.
Schism isn't playing anymore.
Meanwhile, it's not my fault you're making yourself look suspicious to me.

Schism = you. Anything he did reflects on you.

[JDodge]

unvote vote: Jdodge

.

"I don't see it", says the blind man.

[JDodge]

I'll give reasons just as soon as you give yours.

Then I suppose we have reached an impasse, Mister Guardian. We may either stay at this standstill, with danger looming over my head, and my potential doom upon your conscience; or you may reconsider your position, and decide if your claims have any actual ground when you review my position on one Mr. Sammich. I ask that you consider the facts of the matter, set your presumptions aside, and then say that your basis for suspecting me is at all warranted.

I FELT LIKE BEING DRAMATIC

[JDodge]

-I want Kerplunk to explain why he thinks Sammich is scum.

His posts are strange. But that may indeed be that he is a n00b.

unvote: Sammich

.

vote: JDodge

, because this game needs a lynch and because JDodge seems overconfident. Townies should be in general less confident about their accusations.

Lynching me for being overconfident? How boring.

I dislike the way Guardian just essentially said that he wouldn't mind a lyncher win if I am the target. Seriously. Not to mention his entire case on me is that I "haven't given any reasoning", when I have given clear reasoning as to why Sammich is the lyncher if I am the target.

[JDodge]

That isn't what I said at all, Jdodge.

You haven't given *any* reasoning for your suspicions on d3sisted or Kerplunk. Your "clear reasoning" on Sammich being a lyncher had the caveat that he could just be new, as well.

I find the incredibe lack of explanation suspect. You continue to not give any reasoning even when at lynch -1, only defending yourself by trying to deflect attention to Kerplunk and myself.

Really? What would you argue is more important to find first; the lyncher or the scum? I'd argue lyncher by far; and knowing that wish not to muddy the waters with undertone-ish suspicions.

[JDodge]

I want to find the scum first.

A non scum lynch means lylo day two

-- and ignoring scum hunting means people can not give reasons for their suspicions -- like you are doing -- and instead just try and get someone lynched -- which would be perfect for the lyncher that you supposedly want to get lynched.

I think you are anti-town.

If we don't get rid of the lyncher we have to be extraordinarily careful even if we find scum.

[JDodge]

I want to find the scum first.

A non scum lynch means lylo day two

-- and ignoring scum hunting means people can not give reasons for their suspicions -- like you are doing -- and instead just try and get someone lynched -- which would be perfect for the lyncher that you supposedly want to get lynched.

I think you are anti-town.

If we don't get rid of the lyncher we have to be extraordinarily careful even if we find scum.

JDodge, you haven't done much scum-hunting as apposed to lyncher findings.
If the lyncher wins, we all lose, but I think most scum would find getting the lyncher out of the way a #1 priority.

I think that if you actually think about it a lyncher is more of a danger than the scum.

[JDodge]

I think that if you actually think about it a lyncher is more of a danger than the scum.

You thought?
No way!
Well, all taunting aside, who do you think has a good chance of being the lyncher? I know you're very pressed on your belief that I'm not town, but I would like to hear any of your other suspicions.

WILL YOU PLEASE DO US ALL A FAVOR AND READ THE FUCKING GAME.

FIRST YOU VOTE NO LYNCH IN A DAMN NIGHTLESS GAME,

THEN

YOU ASK ME WHO I THINK IS THE LYNCHER WHEN I JUST SAID IT.

[JDodge]

Jdodge, explain your suspicions. Seriously.

Or are they just fabricated?

They're thinking off the top of my head and remembering who was scummy, not exactly what they did. I do this for secondary suspicions because otherwise they are a waste of my time. Happy?

[JDodge]

Jdodge, explain your suspicions. Seriously.

Or are they just fabricated?

They're thinking off the top of my head and remembering who was scummy, not exactly what they did. I do this for secondary suspicions because otherwise they are a waste of my time. Happy?

No, I'm actually not happy with that at all.

I could say that about anyone in the game, and then never back it up with anything if that was acceptable. I think it is not acceptable, and a response easily used by scum.

d3sisted isn't your lyncher, we'll see if Crub is, but I doubt it -- I think if Crub is scum he's teamscum.

I think a Jdodge lynch today would be great.

I think you're an idiot.

Clearly I don't wish to act on those suspicions, just broadcast them. Your lack of logic is worrying.

[JDodge]

Probably could. Don't wish to. As a matter of fact I have already told you the reason as to why I don't wish to, yet you ignore it.

[JDodge]

Jdodge, explain your suspicions. Seriously.

Or are they just fabricated?

They're thinking off the top of my head and remembering who was scummy, not exactly what they did. I do this for secondary suspicions because otherwise they are a waste of my time. Happy?

You all need to learn basic reading comprehension

[JDodge]

Jdodge, explain your suspicions. Seriously.

Or are they just fabricated?

They're thinking off the top of my head and remembering who was scummy, not exactly what they did.

I do this for secondary suspicions because otherwise they are a waste of my time.

Happy?

You all need to learn basic reading comprehension

I bolded the important part because you seem to be having great difficulty finding it

[JDodge]

I bolded the important part because you seem to be having great difficulty finding it

I did that too...

I am not OK with you having only one primary suspicion -- only one player whose alignment you have put significant thought into.

That's nice.

Interestingly enough I'm trying to look for scum, not play "do what Guardian tells me to do", so I'm just going to start ignoring this and focusing on getting rid of Sammich the Lyncher.

[JDodge]

Mod

: PROD CRUB PLEASE

LURKERCRUB = BAD

[JDodge]

Then why are you voting for Kerplunk?

[JDodge]

Because he's the lyncher.

Of whom, might I ask?

[JDodge]

Why?

Meh.

That really isn't good enough. What is wrong with me advocating JDodge's lynch?

Obviously he's a lyncher looking for the scum. Or scum looking for the lyncher.

[JDodge]

Perhaps it's time for a deadline.
JDodge, I'm still waiting for you to make a recent post.

That's nice.

[JDodge]

Perhaps a deadline's in order?
It seems we're not getting anywhere.

Wanting a deadline is anti-town

[JDodge]

Given all this... why are you voting for Kerplunk right now?

More universally anti-town

imo, we don't need a deadline, we need two more Jdodge votes.

imo, we don't need a deadline, we need players who don't go "ZOMG NO CONTENT SCUMZ DEI LOLZ", rather people who act like they know something about how there is no universal scumtell.

[JDodge]

imo, we don't need a deadline, we need players who don't go "ZOMG NO CONTENT SCUMZ DEI LOLZ". Instead we need people who act like they know something about how there is no universal scumtell.

Rephrased for better grammarz

[JDodge]

I'm not getting why Guardian is so intent on getting JDodge lynched. The whole "lack of reasoning" expostulation doesn't seem to hold much water to me. Nevertheless, you've been clinging on so pertinaciously to JDodge that you're starting to look more like the lyncher than Kerplunk.

Despite this, I'd rather let mafia deal with the lyncher at night than have to waste lynches in the day.

THIS IS A NIGHTLESS GAME. SINCE YOU ARE THE SECOND PERSON TO THINK IT ISN'T, I'M GOING TO BOLD THIS AND MAKE IT HUGE SO NOBODY CAN MISS IT THE THIRD TIME.

[JDodge]

d3sisted... the game is nightless.

I want jdodge lynched because I think he is very likely to be scum. Kerplunk is a good second choice for me, but I slightly fear him jdodge's lyncher.

GUESS WHO ISN'T GIVING REASONING

OH THE IRONY

[JDodge]

no hammer.

You have no idea how much I want to, and would if I wasn't afraid of you being his lyncher.

[JDodge]

HAY I READ THE VOTE COUNT WRONG!

[JDodge]

I find it interesting that as soon as Kerplunk puts me at -1, Guardian backs off while trying to seem like he isn't actually backing off, especially since he's been pushing rather hard for my lynch the past few pages

[JDodge]

......

I have

0 tolerance

for people using my hesitance/wanting to make a good decision as a "scum tell". Especially coming from someone whose schtick as of recent has been "there are no universal scum tells".

vote: Jdodge

.

"Seem like I'm not backing off" -- my ass.

Funny how you get all defensive when I call you on it.

Also note how Sammich conveniently leaves Crub out of his analysis.

[JDodge]

Also note how Sammich conveniently leaves Crub out of his analysis.

Lol.
I said lyncher info. I don't find Crub lyncher at all.

Because he's your scumbuddy obvobv

[JDodge]

You had a chance to hammer him earlier. No way, lol.


I'd like to see Jdodge's alignment before we start discussing who is the play for tomorrow . I am happy with the lynch, he was my #1 target.

You're a retard.

[JDodge]

It is...

I hate you Guardian

[JDodge]

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php ... _Nightless

For reference purposes.

[JDodge]

Townie obviously. Guardian was of the "HELP THE LYNCHER WIN LOLZ" alignment.

[JDodge]

Jdodge was right about Sammich....

too bad he wasn't VOTING him.

I really should have hammered Kerplunk .

Because nobody believed me about Sammich, obviously. Possibly thanks to someone going "OMG LYNCH HIM LYNCH HIM LYNCH HIM" non-stop. GOOD JOB PLAYING AS LYNCHER'S HELPER.