Dance of the Title Fairy: Pale Moonlight Edition

[Fro99er]

w/e

don't really care. Just thought it was worthy.

You old timers decide.

[sthar8]

All the "old timers" want to chime in and rip the last few apart because they are 2015'ers. Awesome.

I'm sorry you feel that way?

I'm actually just saying that if it were me, I wouldn't want that title. Looks like Tatsuya's ok with it, so you're golden!

[InflatablePie]

quadzypie

NO ONE WAS SUPPOSED TO KNOW ABOUT THAT, FUCK



Sun Tzu or Orange in Sharp Contrast?

because I don't like his new title so if OiSC was based off one game I'm gonna feel stupid

p.s. - if the title would go through no matter what, I'd support "For information." - with the period, not with the allcaps.

[pedit]
point 1 is a logical fallacy
point 2 - yes. and I dislike both those titles for that reason.

I'm opposing the meme-ness of it just like I oppose(d?) Kayak for Cheery given the timing. And 4/6 of the noms/support in both Pers and Tatsuya's were from people in those games, so... yeah, I think they work best as Kayak Moments

also, I guess sthar and I are "all" the old-timers. regardless, SK does have the final say. honestly if Pers' title was up to SK's standards than I guess this one is similar enough. see my p.s. above.

[Cheery Dog]

I still think Orange In Sharp Context was a better title for sonic.

[Psyche]

The 2015s are organizing :lol:

[Kublai Khan]

Sun Tzu or Orange in Sharp Contrast?

because I don't like his new title so if OiSC was based off one game I'm gonna feel stupid

"Orange in Sharp Contrast" was because Metal Sonic popped in and said "Hey a title thread, I want my title to be 'Blue Blur'". So it was funny shenanigans to give him the exact opposite.

Because funny shenanigans are what titling is supposed to be about. Damnit. *storms off in a huff*.

[The Bulge]

I still think Orange In Sharp Context was a better title for sonic.

[SleepyKrew]

I don't think it's a great title. But I also don't think it's bad, and I'm not going to deny it just because I don't think it's great. 48 hours

For information.

Or maybe without the period. Whichever way Tatsuya prefers. Not a fan of putting it in all caps unnecessarily.

I put some thought into answering "should titles based on one game remain okay?" a while ago. I realized that some of my favorite titles, eg POWERFUL WIZARD, Premature Assassination, and NK Immune Miller Vig, are from single games. Plus I don't really see a reason to not allow them.

[Psyche]

yay passive fairy

[Kublai Khan]

laissez-fairy

[SleepyKrew]

how dare you

[N]

I'm still boycotting this thread jsyk

[singersigner]

All the "old timers" want to chime in and rip the last few apart because they are 2015'ers. Awesome.

My title noms have never been approved/supported/accepted as "good noms" and look at when I joined. Alternatively, I've disliked several title noms (Metal Sonic's for example) for older scummers just because I feel like there's something more suitable for them or I know them by something more commemorating. Join date has nothing to do with liking or disliking a title.

If it has support, it has support. Who cares. It's a fucking title.

[Plotinus]

it’s not just us who are saying for information now, because mario is doing it too and he wasn’t even in that game, and other people seem to at least know what we’re talking about when we say it? and the game itself was pretty epic it was one of the longest newbie games ever. + that was Tatsuya’s first completed game and he won the game as scum and even though he was a newbie and he was a bit lost he did really well at not implicating me as his partner and he did really really well at acting like his partners were zakk or yukari which were the designated mislynches we needed for the win and he played his part really really well and we wouldn’t have won the game if he had messed that up which would have been easy to do because all the newer players were pretty lost in that game because we had too many SE replacements. >.>

As such it’s not a “tat said something dumb in his first newbie game” title. It’s more about how inspite of being somewhat obvscum in that game (to his buddy at least >.> ), he developped a good raport with the other players and gained enough allies in the town that they were really hesitant to lynch him and a lot of the things that he said were pretty cute and the for information thing wasn’t making fun of him but if he did feel that way and didn’t want the title then that would be fine and understandable because I can see the other side of this too but really we all thought he was pretty great.

[SleepyKrew]

As such it’s not a “tat said something dumb in his first newbie game” title. It’s more about how inspite of being somewhat obvscum in that game (to his buddy at least >.> ), he developped a good raport with the other players and gained enough allies in the town that they were really hesitant to lynch him

Looks like "he said something cute and silly in a memorable way" to me.
(which is perfectly fine)

[Plotinus]

It also took him two day phases to get lynched after using dice tags to decide whether to hammer someone without a claim, while his buddy was deathtunnelling him the entire time. That’s how magically cute he was in that game (or how bad I am at wagon driving; take your pick.)

[DeathRowKitty]

I still think Not the Blue Blur was a better title for sonic.

[Tatsuya Kaname]

Accepted the title. And... Let's just not put them all capitals, they look messy actually. Thanks!

[SleepyKrew]

Do you want it with or without the period?

[Tatsuya Kaname]

Without the period looks fine to me.

[Plotinus]

<3

[Tatsuya Kaname]

<3

Decided to join another newbie game. Tried the open one but it's sooo quietttt...

[MarioManiac4]

Good luck Tatsuya!

[Plotinus]

Good luck! You can do it! Try to remember the things we were trying to do as scum and try to look for other people who were acting like we were! Ask people lots of questions and you’ll do fine I’m sure!

[Not_Mafia]

I still think Orange In Sharp Context was a better title for sonic.