Post
Post #5 (isolation #2) » Sat Jan 23, 2016 8:07 pm
Postby pieguyn »
it is probably worth looking into. 3 scum replace outs in a row and I'm assuming 0 town replace outs is a very bad sign. even if it's not malicious, it's something he should prob be made aware of so that it doesn't start breaking things later.
speaking of replacing into games, can I say how much I love you for replacing into 3 (4 if you count Equi's game that I emergency backup modded) of my games now? you have legit helped me out a lot.
Post
Post #22 (isolation #11) » Wed Jan 27, 2016 8:27 pm
Postby pieguyn »
she was being pushed as scum for, as far as I could tell, actually no reason. like someone can correct me on this but I am pretty sure there was no actual reason given anywhere that held any water. the same kind of thing happened with talah.
if I could rant a bit, this kind of stuff is something I've seen a lot of recently and amounts to what (IMO) is a really huge problem in today's site meta - people rely exclusively on forming reads or working based on whatever people are currently posting instead of analyzing every post objectively, which 1. often leads to a bunch of people "agreeing" someone is scum with no reasoning behind it, or 2. opening the door for the "flooding the thread" strategy a la what Wisdom does, which is actually awful as either alignment. you have no idea how many times I've came into a game thread and seen serious wagons with basically no good reasoning, and said to myself "what the fuck is wrong with you all?". (see: THE FUCKING BRUNNEIS WAGON IN C9++ AAAAAAAAAHHHHH)
Spoiler:
and the other point, about her voting Fire's counterwagon, everyone is sooooo sorely mistaken on that it's heartbreaking.
Post
Post #41 (isolation #16) » Sun Jan 31, 2016 12:47 pm
Postby pieguyn »
so this night is gonna be a disaster for town unless the second doc saves correctly. cop is on one of the scum, but the scum have figured out who the cop is by now and are obviously going to kill them. plus, since I don't think it was crumbed anywhere, the cop's inno on
Spoiler:
Wisdom
will be lost.
this = very likely scum win if they can succeed in killing the cop.
Post
Post #44 (isolation #17) » Sun Jan 31, 2016 1:03 pm
Postby pieguyn »
as it stands, if town loses this game, he will undoubtedly be the leading cause of the loss imo.
it's games like this where I want to somehow tell him that I wish I could see the Wisdom from i.e. Makai Mix where we worked sooo well together and lynched a ton of scum (until we got fucked by one scum who both of us were town reading but that's beside the point), but I don't feel optimistic about it. I know he can do so much better than this if he would quit being so ridiculously stubborn about every single one of his reads.
Post
Post #46 (isolation #18) » Sun Jan 31, 2016 1:06 pm
Postby pieguyn »
I'm not actually sure that's what he did, I think he just pushed Sakura-slot really hard without realizing it'd look like faking a cop guilty. but, /shrug
Post
Post #61 (isolation #20) » Mon Feb 01, 2016 5:37 pm
Postby pieguyn »
In post 59, Spiffeh wrote:I'm surprised I died though I thought I had at least one more night left in me
@pie how did they figure me out?
Spoiler:
actually their reasoning was off; they thought you had inno'ed Ank on N2 bc they thought you were way too overconfident in your meta read on him. oooooops???
Post
Post #62 (isolation #21) » Mon Feb 01, 2016 5:38 pm
Postby pieguyn »
In post 60, Spiffeh wrote:Yo I'm gonna be pissed if they ml my inno without even trying to go back and look
I could totally see this happening. I didn't even notice you had crumbed it, but then again I'm hilariously awful at picking up on PR tells and I'm obv not reading everything in the same depth I would if I was playing the game. x_x
Post
Post #98 (isolation #25) » Wed Feb 03, 2016 8:19 am
Postby pieguyn »
In post 91, hiplop wrote:When all the people I pushed mislynches on replaced out in super townie ways, I was fucked
I was predicting you'd win until this game day where town went from mostly running around with wrong reads to all agreeing on correct reads and suddenly bloc'ing up. up till then I was foreseeing a Wisdom lynch and from there Gork or maybe Ranger coulda been possible.
finding PRs can do a lot to make or break a game for scum, esp in an open game where it's practically impossible to lynch any of them. the first scum game I played after I came back we wound up with an almost impossible-to-win MYLO because we had left 3 of the PRs alive -.-
Post
Post #117 (isolation #27) » Thu Feb 04, 2016 11:12 am
Postby pieguyn »
Ranger had GODreads in the open game I played with her, too, and I spent most of D2 pushing her because her reasoning for it came off as disingenuous. like, calling the whole scum team and linking them all together via associatives _before any of them had flipped_ tier reads. then D3 I reversed all of my reads and we wound up agreeing on everything, and I felt like a dumbass for pushing her the way I did on D2. -.-
there was a micro game me and Spiffeh had with her where me and bork were scum and we obliterated the entire town. IT CAN BE DONE
