Mini 1764: Netherspite's SORM III [Game Over]

[Yarrrrgami]

Yar, I be the firstest, most first-postin'est pirate on this vessel!

VOTE: firebringer

Now I don't know what kind of fire ye' be bringing, but this ship be flammable, so ye'd best leave that at port.

[Yarrrrgami]

RM is townpool.

Actually want to know the cognitive process behind random voting fire considering relative mislynchability of slots.

Both these statement be ticklin' me ears in funny, slightly distressin' ways.

We be voting fire because he be bringing fire on a ship full of wood and gunpowder. That thar' is scummy behavior if ever there was.

If my parrot and I wanted to see some non-scurvy hands walk the plank, there be better options than some silly sailor who not be list'ning to the wise words of Smokey the Piratebear: "Only ye' can prevent ship-fires."

Why do ye think Firebringer has a shorter plank than the rest of the lot, and why do ye think that matters so early in the voyage?

[Yarrrrgami]

RM is townpool.

Ye have some barnacles in your ears, so this old seadog is going to reiterate what shorty-pirate was saying all clear-like:

Mglw'nafh fhthagn-ngah cf'ayak 'vulgtmm vugtlag'n. Iä Hastur cf'ayak'vulgtmm, vugtlagln vulgtmm.

ch'yar ul'nyar shaggornyth, ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthugha Fomalhaut n'gha-ghaa naf'lthagn.

ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn.

[Yarrrrgami]

hey guyz

wats going on

*raises sword at the shitty wagon on us*

VOTE: yarrgami

I have role information that tells me this is 100% scum.

yeah no you don't but lynch us so you can be speedlynch in under 5 seconds.

lol what are you pple even doing here

how are the rest yar' all doing

can some1 plz help me clean this deck tia

pick up

[Yarrrrgami]

VOTE: yarrgami

I have role information that tells me this is 100% scum.

yeah no you don't but lynch us so you can be speedlynch in under 5 seconds.

lol what are you pple even doing here

how are the rest yar' all doing

can some1 plz help me clean this deck tia

Me parrot -- Parrot Mollie I calls her -- has some artic'lation problems from one too many jugs o' rum, but she speaks sooth.

We be free o' the scummy scurvy. So scurvy-free be we that on long voyages, when the lime juice be running low, our fellow pirate be lickin' our boots for the sweet, delicious vitamin C that be exuding from e'ery pore of our towny being.

I assume the snowpirate be jestin', lest confirmed-scurvy be he.

[Yarrrrgami]

Well, then yer carrot must be growin' longer by the minute, 'cause a scurvy liar be ye.

VOTE: SnarkySnowscumpirate

[Yarrrrgami]

kagami said that the game was moving at a slow pace I did not realize it was at a crawl.

we are town btw!

there isn't a whole lot to chew on here. I am assuming the bs wagon is an rvs 1.

eta: you are lying through your teeth ss!

ahoy!

eta2: I am good with that captain kagami!

his lying is bad and i am not getting the feeling he is reaction testing if he is he is very bad at it

[Yarrrrgami]

hi anen!

[Yarrrrgami]

Me first pass in reading the shorty-pirate's scribblins was that it was odd that 13 suggests he has cults on the brains, but that doesn't sail smoothly with the suggestion that nobody walks the plank today.

The main thinkin' I've been comin' to is not that the shorty-pirate be scum o' some sort, but rather that callin' him town seems for suggestin' a no lynch be a bit superficial.

[Yarrrrgami]

...
He might be a jester
...

Havin' perused the Captain's scribblin's about what kind o' mateys and scurvy dogs be on this vessel, this is what be makin' the most sense to me mind. If the snowpirate wanted to make us walk the plank, he'd have made sure the claim wasn't obviously rubbish and bilgewater. Also, methinks it's unlikely that he has the snowballs to pretend to be a jester in such a manner as a scurvy-ridden seadog.

[Yarrrrgami]

UNVOTE:

[Yarrrrgami]

Whar be the squinty-eyed deckhand?

[Yarrrrgami]

Apparently me speech is too sophist'cated for ye, so I'll scrawl the answer to ye question out good and proper-like:

Piratical Scroll o' Truth

no.

[Yarrrrgami]

I be findin' it very hard to be workin' out who is scurvy and who be a good limey while there be so little postin'.

I want to hear more from shos and aronis, and would like for the squinty-eyed pirate to be standing at attention.

[Yarrrrgami]

So now ye be immune to cannonfire?

How was claimin' nonsense going to get ye shot?

[Yarrrrgami]

Exceptin' that the jester walkin' the plank doesn't end the voyage, so the only musketball that would be findin' your heart would be coming from a musket wielded by a non-scurvy hand.

[Yarrrrgami]

But that's fine by me. Ye won't be walkin' the plank today, and if anyone can see fit to slip a knife in the snowpirate's belly overnight, that would be much appreciated.

[Yarrrrgami]

NinoMasaki. Apparently there also be a Frequently Asked Question deckhand hidin' below deck as well.

[Yarrrrgami]

seriousy, I can't read any of your posts, Yarrrrgami. Are you scum?

lol, no really we aren't. I warned you pple in the sign-ups thread that there wld be pirate speak. kagami is having too much fun with it she is even doing it in our hydra pt.

this is what I have so far, ss is probs town cos to fakeclaim like that on us wld be stupid and suicidal for scum. I think fire is town and I think you probably are too mebbe? I think so. I am thinking mebbe anen is scum, I will have to go do a metadive but I will do that later.

that is all I got.

[Yarrrrgami]

And what about my other ideas?

The other thinkin's in that post be just usin' yer noodle in a common way that be pretty clearly correct.

Me parrot wants the snowpirate to be campin' for some reason, but I still be thinkin' he's the self-plank-walkin' lonely frumpler.

Me good eye be lookin' hard at the tautological pirate and the inky pirate, but I reckon looking for the fellow non-scurvy campy hands be the best way to proceed on this voyage.

[Yarrrrgami]

@Anen: There are at least two roles, one mafia one town that both only work at night if there was a no lynch the day before. The Jailor variants.

Har! I hadn't seen that! That changes me opinion o' shorty-pirate.

[Yarrrrgami]

So the inky-pirate be claiming to be the yellow-bellied survivin' pirate... He probably be speaking sooth, methinks, but may still be worth it for him to be walking the plank in case he's one o' them scurvy cthulu-loving folk.

But the tautology pirate be scurvy, regardless of what inky pirate be up to.

VOTE: this be me jollyroger

[Yarrrrgami]

I think the wagon on rory is pretty bad.

do you know who is missing from this game?

NinoMasaki

[Yarrrrgami]

On second thought, I'm thinking I would prefer policy lynching one of aneninen/yarrrrgami today on account of their unreadable posts.

yeah no, pretty sure my posts are readable. you aren't even interested in finding scum like you haven't even tried.

VOTE: aronis

[Yarrrrgami]

While I don't really agree with me parrot unvoting the tautology-pirate, that post be bilgewater.

If ye be thinkin' me votes be vengeance votin', ye not been readin' the ships logs rightly.

If ye be thinkin' this pirate's speaking be random gibberish, then point out the offending words that be too sophist'cated for ye and I'll lay them out all plain-like. It seems unlikely to me that ye actually think what ye just said, so be ye a lazy landlubber, or has the scurvy gotten to your brains?

[Yarrrrgami]

NinoMasaki

has been prodded.

@Cap'n: Give the Frequently Askin' Question pirate a good pokin' with your scimitar while ye at it.

[Yarrrrgami]

Inky = Espeonage?
Tautology = This is username?

Inky-pirate be "rory."

[Yarrrrgami]

I *might* be able to get down with an espy lynch!

[Yarrrrgami]

NinoMasaki

has been prodded.

@Cap'n: Give the Frequently Askin' Question pirate a good pokin' with your scimitar while ye at it.

Thanks, I overlooked that.

FA_Q2

has been prodded.

and then what happened

[Yarrrrgami]

Ahoy there Wizard-hat pirate!

Have ye been on a voyage with the pigeony pirate before?

Despite me parrot's objections, to send tautology pirate off swimmin' with the sharks where bring a smile to this old sea dog's face. What thinks ye there?

[Yarrrrgami]

I've not yet had enough sand in me hourglass to be thinking too deeply about what we should be doin' with inky-pirate.

Seems to me as though he be claiming survivor, which be difficult to get rid of in any way that don't involve plank-walkin', and he be sure to mutiny against us once the opportunity be arising, lest he be violating the captain's orders.

At the same time, it looks like there be lots of potential killin', and methinks we'll only have a few plank-walkin' opportunities.

[Yarrrrgami]

Seems to me as though he be claiming survivor, which be difficult to get rid of in any way that don't involve plank-walkin', and he be sure to mutiny against us once the opportunity be arising, lest he be violating the captain's orders.

What makes you think so?

My vote was totally OMGUS. I'm not Frumple though. I'm not Camper either. I can play with both Frumple and Camper if I need to. I'd rather work with the other Campers, so let's find these Frumples.

[Yarrrrgami]

I feel like scum are just waiting it out until they can kill me

[Yarrrrgami]

some1 plz come into the thread and remind me that it is not all about meeeee

[Yarrrrgami]

its about kagami

[Yarrrrgami]

I got bored

[Yarrrrgami]

i know it is pretty terrible yeah?

shos is scum btw, I think

when pple are being so quiet it is hard to tell.

3 dice is calling us town so I am naturally sus of him.

I think you are town. rory and ss probs are too. if I were to get weak on a read it wld be ss.

kagami, the beautiful pirate, has anen as town. I am going to listen to her. I feel like when I do not want to read his posts he is town. this dates back to his newbie game.

he is a player who does better with more info I think.

I wanna see where this goes:

VOTE: droog

[Yarrrrgami]

how dare you get bored Yarrgami, and break character

I be a full-blooded pirate, there be no character for breakin'. I learned me piratical ways at the Harvard School o' Piracy.

Me parrot, on the other hand, went to that Yale School o' Piracy, so it's only natural she be speakin' strange-like and be otherwise challenged in her piratical learnin'.

Personally, I be ambivalent on the scary-clown pirate. Parrot Mollie be right that he be tip-toin' around us all careful-like, which makes sense if he be scurvy, since I crossed swords with his scurvy self on a couple o' past voyages.

I was hopin' Wizard-hat pirate and pigeony pirate would continue to parlay. That be int'resting.

[Yarrrrgami]

FA_Q2 is growing on me

I think I like him.

YARRRR

[Yarrrrgami]

I can beat that.

I'm not actually a survivor.

How's that?

If ye be a not-so-scurvy pirate who be wantin' someone to walk the plan, then out with ye target. If it be someone showin' signs o' scurvy (like, say, "this be me jollyroger"), then mayhaps we can make a deal.

[Yarrrrgami]

If he be the forgetful deckhand, then he'll be grabbin' the first scurvy role he can get on this voyage, unless he's got barnacles for brains.

[Yarrrrgami]

I still think he be a non-scurvy pigeon.

I be expecting the scum-pigeon to be getting all friendly-like with us, but he began the voyage with appropriate suspicion. Scum-pigeon would also be quite happy to see us walkin' down the plank, but was one of the first to sheathe his plank-prodder.

It also be interestin' that he be wanting to use the sayin's o' me parrot. I don't think he'd be so keen on them if he were a scurvy scoundrel.

What be the reason you have for thinkin' he's scurvy? I don't think the reaction to ye pointing your cutlass at him be terribly significant.

[Yarrrrgami]

That was for the robe an' wizard hat wearin' pirate.

[Yarrrrgami]

i forget
why

this looks like droog claiming amnesiac, actually.

This be a good observation.

Perhaps ye can be promoted from survivor-probably-going-to-be-stabbin'-us-in-the-back-at-lylo to lookout.

[Yarrrrgami]

The snowpirate still be a self-plank-walkin' scurvy dog.

If rory be speakin' sooth, I be wishin' on the north star that the third one be a forgetful deckhand who really likes being non-scurvy, or one who wants to make a scurvy dog walk the plank.

[Yarrrrgami]

I remain ambivalent with a somewhat non-scurvy leanin' on the pigeon pirate.

Inky-pirate is a cowardly survivin' deckhand; snowpirate be the funny deckhand who has a bein'-eaten-by-shark fetish. Scary-clown pirate and pigeon pirate might be scurvy, but I think both those be at least reasonably likely to be good limeys.

Wizard-hat pirate seems non-scurvy to me. Firebringin' pirate needs to learn something about ship safety, but otherwise strikes me as a limey.

Waitin' a bit longer to see if shorty-pirate is going to be developin' some opinions about the other pirates before making a judgment there.

All glory to hypno-ring pirate. Might be scurvy, but he be glorious nevertheless.

I be havin' a hard time figurin' out why ye all be ignoring the most obviously scurvy dog on this vessel. He's been hidin' below deck and pokin' out only to make superficial comments that fail to indicate any real int'rest in making this ship be free o' scurvy.

VOTE: This be me jollyroger

[Yarrrrgami]

I don't know why me parrot likes the frequently askin' question pirate, especially since he hasn't been askin' many questions: Very suspicious.

[Yarrrrgami]

Limeys be drinkin' their lime juice full of delicious Vitamin C, and scurvy free they be.

[Yarrrrgami]

Srry guys. I forgot about this.

And just policy lynch them with me snarky. So much easier then having to ask for a translation every five seconds.

So umm what did I miss?

if this thing lives past d2 omg

[Yarrrrgami]

@Yarrgami: I'd like to know which of you is the trigger happy one and which is the commentator, if possible. I am thinking Mollie and Pie respectively but it'd be nice to have confirmation.

I like eatin' pie after a hard day o' plundering, but there be no pie here.

Me parrot (Parrot Mollie) be the one who be speakin' funny and non-piratical-like.

[Yarrrrgami]

Me parrot just be doing whatever she be wanting, really.

Correctin' me vote for readability for the landlubbin' types:

VOTE: this is me jollyroger.

[Yarrrrgami]

i like that
but counterpoint

if we lynch a 3rd party
the other 2 3rd parties will resent us

O no; They be resentin' us, how dreadful that be!

If they be the types who want to be makin' someone walk the plank, then they be trying to "work with us" regardless, and will likely be startin' tomorrow with "I be a medical examiner, I checked Mr. TargetPirate and he be scurvy!"

Survivors be "working with us" only insofar as they aren't walkin' any planks. According to the captain's scrawlings, they don't have to be afraid o' being killed anyway. No amount of ill-will toward their survivin' buddies is going to change that.

Making Rory walk the plank isn't a bad idea. Being all nice-like and not feeding anyone to the sharks in the hopes that shorty-pirate be a non-scurvy brig-watcher is ridiculous. Shorty-pirate isn't any better at figuring out who is scurvy then the rest of us, so at best he accomplishes exactly what we'd do ourselves: kill someone who seems scurvy. There's also no guarantee he's not scurvy himself, though I doubt he is.

[Yarrrrgami]

It be reasonably clear that shorty-pirate is a brig-watchin' deckhand, I think we agree there. So be he scurvy or no?

I was thinking it would take a pretty brave buccaneer to be suggestin' a No Plank-walkin' as scum so persistent-like. I would be expectin' him to drop it and concern himself elsewhere once it appeared not to be happenin' were he a scurvy dog.

You're correct that he hasn't been doing much else that caught me good eye, but his fixatin' on his deckhandly duties be something that I see more often in non-scurvy folk than their scurvy counterparts.

[Yarrrrgami]

Btw, callin' brig-watcher a "power" role be stretching the term pretty thin, captain.

That deckhand duty is garbage, an' if shorty-pirate is a non-scurvy brig-watcher, we might have gotten that as our "killin' or power deckhand" instead of something actually useful... like a snowman stabbin' vigilante or a bodyguard.

[Yarrrrgami]

It almost be as if the snowpirate be

wantin'

to walk the plank...

[Yarrrrgami]

Catching up soon.
I've looked into the game without reading the new posts thoroughly, and I have a naive question.
Am I the only one who thinks we're talking too much about the third parties while there's a whole Mafia team out there?

nope.

usually it is scum who worries about indies but I think they are actually dim town. I feel like scum are in aronis and shos.

not sure about who the third 1 is.

[Yarrrrgami]

None of them are doing anything. One of them could be a lurk-scum but I don't think

both

of them. I'd say Aronis, because Shos's [according to Site Rules I'm not allowed to explain this]. And at least one of them must be amongst those "speculator players".

third 1 might be anen.

[Yarrrrgami]

VOTE: aronis

[Yarrrrgami]

How about we all play one o' me favorite games for long voyages like this.

It be called "Stop talkin' to the snowpirate, he be a jestin' deckhand."

The rules be pretty self-explanatory.

[Yarrrrgami]

I be thinkin' hypno-ring pirate is just being his usual self, and his "push" for a No Lynch be not motivated by his duties as a deckhand, scurvy or no.

At this point, we may be best off just makin' the inky pirate walk the plank, and sortin' things out tomorrow when there be some corpses to look at, especially if ye all be so worried about feedin' the sharks some non-scurvy meat.

[Yarrrrgami]

It seems to me that most of the killin' third party types are motivated to be slitting scurvy throats tonight if and only if the pirate who be feeding the sharks is not one o' the organized scurvy types.

I think me mind be made up and that this discussion is lost in the doldrums.

VOTE: Rory

[Yarrrrgami]

I just had the most wonderful vision, in which we put Aronis, Frequently-be-askin-question pirate, sneaky-sneak pirate, inky-pirate, snowpirate, and scaryclown pirate on a lifeboat, let them drift about 50 yards from our vessel, and blew them all to pieces with some well-aimed cannonfire.

[Yarrrrgami]

Ye be thinkin' correctly, a survivor he most likely be.

Could be worse, which seems possible since the only position scary-clown pirate has been layin' down is "Please don't be making inky-pirate walk the plank."

Either way, 'tis a fine way to keep the sharks happy.

Forgot me pirate hat and cutlass!

[Yarrrrgami]

Inky-pirate has absolutely no ability to "help us." So I have no idea what ye be thinking there. The only way he'll not be turnin' on us is if we never be near lylo, which is impossible on a voyage like this one.

The truth o' the matter be that every one of us who the captain cursed with non-scurvy deckhand duties be trying to row up a waterfall. The only way we have a prayer of winning this is if the scurvy killin' types be murdering each other. The best way to be makin' that happen is to remove the killin-proof survivin' type right now.

There be no "advantage" that be magically happenin' overnight. The very best we can be hopin' for is that the sun rises to greet us with a scurvy corpse delivered by the third party scurvy killin' type, and not too many dead limeys. If there be cthulhu-lovin' folk, then our ship be sunk regardless.

[Yarrrrgami]

The types that be dancin' round hopin' for dead cthulhu to rise again from the briny deep in his palace o' R'lyeh. They also be lovin' that fishy Dagon fellow.

They be dancin' round their idols, hopin' that cthulhu be opening the gate in reality so that the realm o' Yog-Sothoth be invadin' us; those types.

Bad news, they be.

[Yarrrrgami]

Well, assuming he is actually a Survivor, his single vote could potentially help us. And if we were to lynch Mafia today, then I think that would give us an advantage. And even more so, if we got even luckier and another Mafia was Nked (pretty unlikely, I know). We would then have a definite numbers advantage.

The thing be this: If a scurvy dog walks the plank, there won't be any scurvy dogs gettin' their throats slit tonight unless it be a non-scurvy deckhand who did the deed. The third party killin' type will be incentivized to go for a non-scurvy kill, since they won't be wantin' to reduce the number of survy dogs too quick-like.

On the other hook, if we be feedin' inky-pirate to the sharks, the third party killin' type has to be thinkin' real hard about eliminatin' some o' the competition. If he kills a limey, he's likely to get himself outnumbered by the more organized scurvy pirates. In that case, we be gettin' rid of the survivor who will certainly be stabbin' us in the back if we leave him be, and probably still gettin' a dead scurvy one overnight. That's even ignorin' the possibility that inky pirate is simply speaking falsehoods, and is some other sort o' scurvy type.

[Yarrrrgami]

If Rory be a survivin' deckhand, he be immune to musketballs. He will never be cross-killed.

He'll be voting "with" us, which means little since he has no idea who the scurvy dogs be anyway, and he doesn't really care who be walkin' the plank so long as it isn't him. There be no disadvantage to feedin' his cowardly corpse to the sharks. None at all. If ye can come up with a situation where not proddin' anyone off the plank is better than sending inky-pirate to his watery grave, me ear be ready.

Dismissin' me words as "speculation" is rubbish. We know what the captain's orders are to all the scurvy dogs, and they'll be followin' them. Followin' the captain's order for the third party killin' type means he'll be looking to slit a scurvy throat tonight unless there be some other pirate he be especially ascared of. It be a little more complicated if he be the fire-lovin' type, but the idea be ultimately the same.

[Yarrrrgami]

How about we just send the 3rd party who we know to be musketball-proof off the plank right now?

[Yarrrrgami]

Inky-pirate.

[Yarrrrgami]

Don't mind scary-clown pirate, he just doesn't want inky-pirate to be walkin' the plank for mysteriously mysterious reasons.

[Yarrrrgami]

Because he be a claimed survivor. If we approach lylo, his captain's orders are to prod a non-scurvy pirate so that the scurvy pirates will win and so will he.

He be musketball-proof, so we have no means of otherwise getting rid of him, and we know for certain he's not on our side.

[Yarrrrgami]

I could be wavin' me cutlass at other pirates who look pretty scurvy to me, but the fact is that there is no better way to feed the sharks than a nice, inky snack.

[Yarrrrgami]

I can beat that.

I'm not actually a survivor.

How's that?

Amazing how everybody has ignored this post for so many pages.


The waste.

I'm down with a massclaim. I am Busdriver.

interesting. You could busdrive me with the most likely nightkill. I can activate my vest at any time, so this might save a kill.

[Yarrrrgami]

An' we'll be finding out if ye be lynchproof too, har!

[Yarrrrgami]

oh my gawd, only now I understand - is this a hydra of Kagami and mollie?! w0000000000000000000000000000000ttt

omg are you actually town this game

where have you been

[Yarrrrgami]

Jesus fuck anen, it's like, every single game I play with you, there comes a time, (after like 2-3 posts) where I stop reading your posts

impossibru

timu is bad.

yessssssss

[Yarrrrgami]

Please claim Aronis.

With 2 votes? One of which is from a person who has been out to get me from game start and the second from someone mindlessly sheeping them. So neither of which are very credible. Not to mention you've played like a complete VI. I'll pass up this opportunity, tyvm.

Actually, you have 3

VOTE: Aronis

oops, I mean 4 votes on you. You really should start reading better.

VOTE: aronis

This should be 5.

Is there a reason for that, or are you just hopping on a wagon? Because as far as I can tell, this is the only thing you've said about Aronis:

If aronis was scum in secret hitler, he is here too

Which is pretty flaky, unless you actually have a connection between this game and that one, that you can explain.

trust me

You know full well how ridiculous of a thing to say that is.

I agree that aronis be mighty suspicious.

Do ye know who the galley-driver be switchin' you with, spinny-ring pirate?

[Yarrrrgami]

I hope the sharks didn't catch whatever terrible nautical illness inky-pirate had when they gobbled him up, or they might have become too senseless to eat the next pirate we throw their way. Har!

[Yarrrrgami]

I be assuming that Vigilante's use the pistol-type o' killing, while the stabby-stabbing be coming from the scurvy cap'n crunch killin' type.

So the message be bilgewater.

[Yarrrrgami]

O, only scurvy dogs can leave scrolls behind anyway.

[Yarrrrgami]

About how im about to be conftown?

If this be so, do it now so we be wasting no more sand in the hourglass.

[Yarrrrgami]

I don't know what ye could be on about, spinny-ring pirate. There be no deckhand that can be identifying the funny gettin'-eaten-by-shark-fetish sort o' scurvy dog.

His int'ractions with the chemical scurvy pirate implies he's the fancy suit wearin' sort of scurvy scalawag, anyway.

[Yarrrrgami]

Rubbish, making inky-pirate walk the plank was the correct thing to do.

It makes no sense that a 1-shot musketball-proof non-scurvy hand would claim survivor. He just had barnacles for brains and deserved to become shark-food.

If ye be claiming brig-watcher, then mayhaps it makes sense for no one to walk the plank, but only because we appear to have no killing-type deckhand and need to get rid of the snowpirate eventually.

Sending Aronis to feed the sharks still makes more sense though, unless he has something important to say. I doubt he's the self-plank-walkin' funny type as spinny-ring pirate be claiming, but we could send no-one off the plank and let you throw him in the brig as a safe alternative.

[Yarrrrgami]

I'm not certain how pigeons be traditionally findin' scurvy dogs, but here's how pirates do it:

When a confirmed scurvy dog be placing a weak vote on somepirate, then be attackin' the next pirate who be prodding him down the plank without removin' his original vote, it's a good indicator that it was his buddy he was prodding.

[Yarrrrgami]

Be we forgettin' that aronis is still pretty clearly a scurvy-ridden scoundrel?

Though I wouldn't be surprised if one of the lazy deckhands who didn't report to the captain is the king o' scurvy.

[Yarrrrgami]

based upon his interactions I don't think either of these is Mafia: Aronis ...

Explain why ye be thinking his int'ractions with aronis be scurvy to non-scurvy.

[Yarrrrgami]

My night result supports him being a Jester

There be no deckhand that could discriminate between the non-killing third party type o' scurvy dogs.

[Yarrrrgami]

Obviously, Xkfyu's push on Aronis was probably pigeon poop. (Although we can't rule out that he was scumhunting for real, I mean, searching for a 3rd Party player.) But, I don't think Aronis handled Xk differently than anyone else (as far as I can remember), and scums may act differently whenever their partner is attacking them.
More importantly, it's not Xk's push in itself. It's the timing of the whole stuff. Day1 Bussing itself can be detrimental in a Setup like this. But, at that time Aronis's wagon, as the leading one topped at L–2 (on Page14, I've just checked it) and an Aronis-lynch was a real possibility. (Although Xk jumped on the Rory-wagon at the end of next page.)
I must admit, my read may be bias-ed because of Shos calling him a Jester and the fact that I can imagine Snowman as Xk's Mafia partner strengthens this.

Almost every word of this pigeon scribblin' is nonsense.

Why is Day 1 bussing detrimental on this voyage? This is exactly the sort o' voyage where pushing a buddy off the plank Day 1 be a pretty good idea. On most voyages, where it actually is detrimental to offing your own buddy in scurvyness, are Day 1 scurvy-lynches entirely composed of non-scurvy dogs?

Why, if letters-pirate wanted to see Aronis become shark-food, does he attack the next prod on the wagon so hard? Why is he so happy to jump off so soon?

He never, ever "pushes" Aronis. He was ignoring Aronis until it looked like aronis was likely to be feedin' the sharks. Then he hopped on the wagon with little justification, then hopped off again, occasionally tossing out a "aronis be scurvy" remark while voting inky-pirate.

[Yarrrrgami]

My night result supports him being a Jester

There be no deckhand that could discriminate between the non-killing third party type o' scurvy dogs.

This, hence shos being a good lynch.

Letters-pirate attacked spinny-ring pirate without ever callin' him scurvy. Spinny-ring pirate is scurvy-free or third party.

[Yarrrrgami]

I think he be the suit-wearin' scurvy type.

[Yarrrrgami]

fancy suit, that is, and with expensive shoes.

[Yarrrrgami]

VOTE: droog

[Yarrrrgami]

while I feel the heartstrings pull of lynching snarky I am still wanting droog lynched.

[Yarrrrgami]

cos i want it

[Yarrrrgami]

I be Low Activity due to some RL deckhand duties. Me parrot is supposed to be doing the scrawlin' for both of us.

I still be not convinced that aronis be the self-plank-walkin' type, and vague claims to the otherwise mean little to me. If Aronis were the funny type o' pirate with the bein'-eaten-by-shark fetish, he wouldn't be keeping up the "har har, I be actin' all suspicious-like and gettin' the pagetops," thing. He'd be concerned that his game be over and either be givin' up until he can self-prod at the end of the voyage or be tryin' to get back in everypirate's good graces.

[Yarrrrgami]

Droog is probably town or 3p

. Yarr has thrown me off a bit. I wnat to look into that now that you mention it. At the time I didn't think many people were scumreading espe.

explain. cos when I am having this much trouble pushing a lynch through and it keeps stalling it usually tends to be on scum. so unless you have inside info on droog's alignment I wld like for you to explain your read here.

@ anen

you can go through my posting history and see that my overall site activity has dropped off. I am not signing up for anymore games for a while cos I need a break. I am not as plugged into this game as much as i wld like to be and I can' really explain why except that I am just tired and I haven't really found anything to sink my teeth into. a droog flip wld do wonders for me cos he is the only 1 who jumps out at me as not quite being in sync with the overall flow of the game. I am not as confident in that read as much as I wld like to be cos I have no idea what droog's towngame looks like but he is hitting all of the markers for his scumgame so far.

I really don't like you pitting random against us when you yourself have yet to engage us in any meaningful way in this dayround. so if you have some questions, I think now wld be a fantastic time to ask them!

[Yarrrrgami]

also ANOTHER THING.

it pisses me off to no end that aronis will live forever and be allowed to get away with crap play. that is the number 1 thing that has been frustrating me about mafia and it is why I need a break. cos I remember a time where he wld have been sped lynched and not allowed to get away with it.

[Yarrrrgami]

Can we please lynch the guy literally prod dodging his way through the game. Tyvm.

if you are talking about espy he did this in 1 of our hydra games and we were town. so I dunno. I can't really remember a single solid thing he has said so there is that.

[Yarrrrgami]

I will sheep you guys, just because espe wagon isn't taking off, but espeonage tomorrow, okay Mollie?

VOTE: droog guy

I will help you sort espy 3dice.

@ espy

yo wassup? I haven't felt you at all in this game so lets chat.

plz do not ignore me! kthanx

[Yarrrrgami]

sorry anen, i think applying rhetoric in that particular way is a waste of time and I don't do it as a general rule cos it gives scum room to hide. they eat that shit up like candy.

I look at the motivations behind a post, timing, what the atmospheric condition at that point that a player made the post that they made. that is how scumhunt.

if you want to talk to me about reads on specific players but need more than generalized questions that really don't amount to much in my opinion.

[Yarrrrgami]

what is your reason

cos the answer shld be very obvs.

[Yarrrrgami]

So, Yarrrrrr,
What do you think of Snarky?
Can you see anything that tells you Aronis's not Jester but he's impersonating one?
What do you think of Random? Including his answers for my questions?

1. I can't really tell if he newbtelling bad town or if he is actually scum. he has pinged in a lot of places but ugh
2. if aronis was a jester I feel like he wld have been lynched by now. it isn't hard and there is actually a textbook formula that works every time.
3. I don't feel like your questions are particularly very good nor do they seem like they are coming from a game solving place. just like your question to me about who was posting right now that you are somehow managing to tie to your original point to random.

your questions look like fillers and it looks like you are trying to look busy cos I have not seen any useful conclusions after you ask them and they have been answered. and yes I gave you a very direct response to your obtuse question/observation whatever the fuck you call it earlier so stop trying to throw shade.

it looks like you are trying to construct a narrative rather than trying to figure the game out. the problem that I am having is that I have seen you do this as both alignments.

[Yarrrrgami]

also ANOTHER THING.

it pisses me off to no end that aronis will live forever and be allowed to get away with crap play. that is the number 1 thing that has been frustrating me about mafia and it is why I need a break. cos I remember a time where he wld have been sped lynched and not allowed to get away with it.

Was jester a prevalent role in those games/times?

Normally he would have been lynched. There is a real possibility that such an action is anti-town though. I fear that we may be seriously lacking killing roles though and that might be an issue dealing with jesters...

there is always the chance of a jester in any closed themed game. what I am not liking is that it is being treated as a probability rather than the possibility that it actually is. and aronis doesn't dislike me and I don't dislike aronis but lately when he has rolled scum he keeps trying to pl me.

I HOPE we have a vig and they do their vig mojo and vig aronis.

@ anem

when I say scum, I mean mafia I do NOT mean indies cos indies are not scum no matter how much like to marginalize that entire alignment. and I am sick to death of having to explain this shit.

and textbook jestering is spamming the thread until pple will do nearly anything to get rid of you or deliberately dropping a "scumslip" that pple will zealously pursue to the ends of the earth. none of that is what aronis is doing and he strikes me as cheeky scum.

I really wish you guys wld let me sort espy first before you ram his lynch through, espy isn't afraid to post as scum so I dunno. I can't sort him if he is not present in the game.

[Yarrrrgami]

Hey aristo!

Your slot claimed Doctor, who did you protect last night?

Lol
Has this ever actually fooled anyone?

It be time for some philosophatin', philosophy-pirate. At least ye be less frightening than that scary-clown pirate.

I be not disagreein' with making sneaky-sneak pirate walk the plank, but me parrot be telling me that he wouldn't be afraid of scrawlin' in the logs as a scurvy dog. I think his behavior was scurvy-ish prior to his hiding below deck anyway.

[Yarrrrgami]

We should totally no lynch.

The sharks be hungry, matey.

[Yarrrrgami]

@ faq

Spoiler:

also ANOTHER THING.

it pisses me off to no end that aronis will live forever and be allowed to get away with crap play. that is the number 1 thing that has been frustrating me about mafia and it is why I need a break. cos I remember a time where he wld have been sped lynched and not allowed to get away with it.

Was jester a prevalent role in those games/times?

Normally he would have been lynched. There is a real possibility that such an action is anti-town though. I fear that we may be seriously lacking killing roles though and that might be an issue dealing with jesters...

there is always the chance of a jester in any closed themed game.

Is there? I thought jester was not a normal role.
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Jester
It is normally considered a bastard role. In general, there is literally zero reason to suspect a jester in a standard closed setup. Your reasoning here is incredibly specious. You also act as though you really pushed for his lynch when I really do not see that in your ISO.

what I am not liking is that it is being treated as a probability rather than the possibility that it actually is. and aronis doesn't dislike me and I don't dislike aronis but lately when he has rolled scum he keeps trying to pl me.

I HOPE we have a vig and they do their vig mojo and vig aronis.

@ anem

when I say scum, I mean mafia I do NOT mean indies cos indies are not scum no matter how much like to marginalize that entire alignment. and I am sick to death of having to explain this shit.

and textbook jestering is spamming the thread until pple will do nearly anything to get rid of you or deliberately dropping a "scumslip" that pple will zealously pursue to the ends of the earth. none of that is what aronis is doing and he strikes me as cheeky scum.

Endlessly spamming the thread seems like exactly what he is doing.

I really wish you guys wld let me sort espy first before you ram his lynch through, espy isn't afraid to post as scum so I dunno. I can't sort him if he is not present in the game.

You are getting your wish here - he is being replaced.

1. it honestly depends on who the mod is, they are not required to advertise if a game has bastard elements. som mos consider a game to be non-bastard as long as there are no alignment changes and that no lies will come from the mod that cannot be reasonably anticipated. so *shrug*

2. nono
nononono
spamming the thread is having over 1000 posts on d1. <----- that is spamming the thread. aronis is nowhere near that.

3. I didn't want espy replaced I wanted him to participate so i cld read him cos I have a pretty good track record for being able to do so. the fact that he was completely staying away from me makes me think it was disengaged town!espy rather than OMFG HOW AM I GOING TO SNEAK PAST MOLLIE GOD I WANT TO GET HER SO BAD AND SOMEDAY I WILL scum!espy but I wld have needed interaction to be sure.

[Yarrrrgami]

I am not liking the shos wagon, like at all.

and I am not liking snowthing's deathtunnel to the exclusion of doing anything else this game.

also I am wondering how ranger came to the conclusion that there 2 benign indies when he has only read this page or did I miss something.

[Yarrrrgami]

yeah I know. it is just weird how espy stayed completely away from me, but I guess the last time he tried to go after me when he was scum I got him lynched that very same day.

[Yarrrrgami]

I just realized that the deadline is in very short time.

I'm an investigative role, and I targetted Aronis. The result suggests he might be Jester. pretty sure I've said this already.

Now let this stupid wagon collapse and onwards with a scum lynch?

can you be more specific about your result, shos?

[Yarrrrgami]

I'm a detective. visited Aronis, and he went nowhere tonight.

that in no way shape or form makes him a jester.

[Yarrrrgami]

hhhmm...

[Yarrrrgami]

Beaker-pirate doesn't look especially scurvy to me, but aronis be almost guaranteed scurvy.

There is certain to be a king-o-scurvyness, and there be only two scurvy dogs left. Spinny-ring pirate's result implies to me that Aronis is the king-o-scurvyness.

Beaker-pirate's dismissal of aronis as a partner in scurviness is silly, but not to the extent that I think beaker-pirate be scurvy himself.

VOTE: Aronis

[Yarrrrgami]

Aristophanes be me bet for Cap'n Crunch-like third party scurvy scalawag.

[Yarrrrgami]

Forgot that beaker-pirate be sneaky-sneak pirate. I guess that be possible, but Aronis is a sure thing.

[Yarrrrgami]

I object to snowpirate, he be a jester and the only one.

[Yarrrrgami]

okay we only have 4 hours left and I am willing to switch to ranger to see a lynch go through.

846 is pretty funny, but makes me think she is town cos LOL no1 is following her vote except random who I am starting to think is scum. usually it is town who is that self-delusional.

[Yarrrrgami]

stating intent to hammer

and I won't be waiting long cos I gots ta go

[Yarrrrgami]

VOTE: ranger