(1765) Star Wars: The Force Awakens [D5]

[Venmar]

like what the fuck is this then

unfortunately I kinda believe Eagle so I guess we lynch Key or Venmar

like, as far as i am concerned, you just pulled something out of your ass

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Hey guys been a busy couple days. I believe the lone wolf vote on key confirms one of them as scum, seeing as all the possible scum buddies have posted since then. So I plan to spend the rest of the day determining between the two.

[TheTrollie]

like what the fuck is this then

unfortunately I kinda believe Eagle so I guess we lynch Key or Venmar

like, as far as i am concerned, you just pulled something out of your ass

like what the fuck is this then

Only person I think is town is Trollie. Everybody else is fair game in my eyes, including wolf.

[TheTrollie]

I did not think of the fact that "no result" was different than "not guilty" at first

[TheLoneWolf]

Unvote

I thought we determined it would be absurd for it to be a 2man scumteam left so one vote by town isn't enough to quicklynch but w.e

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Unvote

I thought we determined it would be absurd for it to be a 2man scumteam left so one vote by town isn't enough to quicklynch but w.e

Crap I forgot it could be an SK. I was thinking of my game that just ended from that. My bad.

[TheLoneWolf]

What's your bad is a complete lack of content today. Who is scum?

What if is between me and Key? What are your thoughts?

[TheTrollie]

What's the likelihood there is a scum roleblocker AND town RB?

[Keyser Söze]

I blocked wolf.

oh btw reason is i was roleblocked last night

What's the likelihood there is a scum roleblocker AND town RB?

Yes,

this doesn't make sense

- why would Extrapolated Eagle block TheTrollie but then claim he roleblocked TheLoneWolf? That either means there is 1) a scum roleblocker ontop of the town roleblocker 2) Extrapolated Eagle is the scum-roleblocker and messed up his claim 3) TheTrollie is lying about being roleblocked.

[TheTrollie]

Eagle could not have claimed to have roleblocked me if he did. There is no town motivation for roleblocking the the claimed/confirmed cop.

[TheLoneWolf]

Oh what's this? Is Keyser forming an actual stance today?

Key+Eagle still fine with either

[Venmar]

@Reckoner

- If you can answer this question, is there any functional difference for a role getting "No Result" and "Not Guilty"?

[TheTrollie]

As far as I see it, there are 3 possible explanations

(a) Eagle is lying, he is a scum roleblocker, and he targeted me (wish I realized this earlier, would have made Eagle claim first)

(b) Eagle is lying, he has a role modifier which would mess with my investigation (because I targeted eagle-so like reflexive roleblocker)

(c) Someone else is lying, they are a scum roleblock/jailkeeper (

what other roles could prevent a cop investigation from going through?

)

If C is true, then A is probably true too though since I think a scum and town roleblocking role is strange.

If C or A, there is likely with 1 more member of the mafia team. I dont see a 3rd party blocking me.

So I think the conclusion is that we lynch Eagle today. The probability that eagle is town with these results is slim to none

[xRECKONERx]

@Reckoner

- If you can answer this question, is there any functional difference for a role getting "No Result" and "Not Guilty"?

Depends on the role and the formatting.

[Venmar]

@Reckoner

- If you can answer this question, is there any functional difference for a role getting "No Result" and "Not Guilty"?

@Reckoner

- To rephrase the question, if a role that receives results back, such as a variation of a cop, would they be able to distinguish based on their result if they were roleblocked or not?. Basically, does being blocked produce a result different from just getting a negative result? (In the case of a Cop, "No Result" over "Not Guilty")

[TheTrollie]

venmar

i know for certain based on role pm that a no result is not a not guilty.

[xRECKONERx]

@Reckoner

- If you can answer this question, is there any functional difference for a role getting "No Result" and "Not Guilty"?

@Reckoner

- To rephrase the question, if a role that receives results back, such as a variation of a cop, would they be able to distinguish based on their result if they were roleblocked or not?. Basically, does being blocked produce a result different from just getting a negative result? (In the case of a Cop, "No Result" over "Not Guilty")

Again, it would depend on how the role PM was formatted. Some roles may be formatted in such a way that they specifically receive "guilty" or "not guilty", with "no result" as another option if blocked. Other roles may simply only receive an affirmative or general positive feedback if their role succeeds, but may receive "no result" in both the case where they do not get a positive with their action AND where they are blocked.

I have used both in the past.

[Venmar]

Okay whatever, I'm prepared to just take a leap of faith and vote Eagle here

[TheLoneWolf]

Keyser is by far the better lynch though

[TheLoneWolf]

Its not COMPLETELY impossible that there is a town and a scum RB, and I'm just more sure on Keyser's play as reading scum.

There's a small chance Eagle is just as shit at town as Snarky was (and Snarky flipped scum-reference SpyreX signature)

[TheTrollie]

Let's wait for eagle to check in

[TheTrollie]

please prod

[TheLoneWolf]

Can I vote Keyser yet or are we still going with the RB oh noes lynch.

I mean it would be kinda stupid for Eaglescum to RB a useless cop and confirm himself as scum

[TheTrollie]

Not if he's first order or reflexive
The kill was made figuring the 1shot claim was bs
The block was made figuring my limitations claim was bs

Sense a pattern?

We have a paranoid scum

[xRECKONERx]

Prodded Keyser & Eagle.