Mini 1783: GTA 2 Mafia (GaME OVAH)

[shos]

Aaaand pagetop for VC

Deadline is in

(expired on 2016-04-24 00:01:11).

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes for a lynch.

VC 1.4

Votecount #1.4

BlueBloodedToffee

(1) - FA_Q2.

The Banterlords

(2) - A Real Scourge, TheDominator37.

FA_Q2

(1) - Masquerade.

Dragon Knight

(1) - BlueBloodedToffee.

BlackStar

(0) -

Code of Honor

(0) -

Jeanne11

(2) - Dragon Knight, Polar Vortex.

Masquerade

(0) -

PhantomCobalt

(0) -

TheDominator37

(2) - PhantomCobalt, MagnaOfIllusion.

MagnaofIllusion

(0) -

Polar Vortex

(0) -

A Real Scourge

(0) -

NOT VOTING (4) - BlackStar, Jeanne11, Code Of Honor, The Banterlords.

NOTICE:

Jeanne11 has earned a second prod this day. Her house has been blown to pieces by a flak grenade, thrown by an unknown identity.

Did you know?

The GTA2 gang, the Zaibatsu, that appears on all three levels, is not in fact really a gang. In Japanese, "

Zai

" means wealth and "

batsu

means group. There were originally four Zaibatsu's in Japan. The most well known of these is....Mitsubishi

[Polar Vortex]

I have no problem lynching a watcher in a role madness game. That role could easily be scum. And the reveal absolutely sucked, even more than DK's did.
Bearbert

[Dragon Knight]

Also, watcher is not even close to cop. You definitely tried to throw shade at me there!

...
Yes it is. They are both investigative roles. :/

Not in a game-making sense. Cops have much more certain results, while trackers have much bigger "nets" to catch people with.

[Dragon Knight]

The niches in which they operate are completely different. You can't replace a cop with a watcher in a game and call it balanced. Tracker or Rolecop, maybe, but definitely not watcher.

Anyways, enough setup speculation. Hmm, let's comment on... Nothing. There's nothing Jeanne has given that's worth commenting on. Well, that's scummy.

[BlackStar]

The niches in which they operate are completely different. You can't replace a cop with a watcher in a game and call it balanced. Tracker or Rolecop, maybe, but definitely not watcher.

Anyways, enough setup speculation. Hmm, let's comment on...

Nothing. There's nothing Jeanne has given that's worth commenting on. Well, that's scummy.

You're trying way too hard, man...

[Dragon Knight]

Nah, 2 things.

1. I get super big tunnel vision
2. I really, really hate lurkers.

[MagnaofIllusion]

MOD – I’ll be V/LA from approximately 5pm today until Monday morning for my usual weekend family duties.

I don't like it when people lurk either, but some people could make the argument that this post is a cop out because you don't have any reads

Way to straddle both sides of the fence. Do you personally feel it is a ‘cop out’ or not?

I think you're reading too much into his posts when they're pretty simple. For example, you point out how he did nothing with the theory that there were two scum in DK's wagon (though I think voting us counts as something, since it shows he pursued the theory's direction),

when the real worrisome thing would be if he had done something scummy with it, like pushing for a lynch on someone just because they voted DK.

I don't think his lack of pro-action on a faulty assumption is something that should be held against him

See I disagree with the bolded in a very strong way. Saying with conviction (which is how I read it) that he believes there are 2 scum on that wagon and then providing from my perspective absolutely no followthrough is far more scummy than dissecting the wagon voters and trying to puzzle out which is most likely scum.

It is not about whether you or I think it is a faulty assumption – Mafia is a theory game that is going to be riddled with them. The issue I have is if he believes what he was saying then his subsequent actions don’t mesh very well with his supposed stance. At least to the degree I don’t see him taking the feedback and rethinking his stance in thread.

Thinking right now Black Star is def strongest town read, and Jeanne is my strongest scumread.
Haven't talked to Diamond Sentinel so far, but I will break him to sheep my scumread.

-Fire

Elaborate on why Jean is your biggest scum-read and your read on Dom.

[Code of Honor]

Prod dodge.

Will read later. Sick and Taxes.

I see me struggling. I hating.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Prodge.

Will read this game when I can.

[BlackStar]

BBT, can you stop saying that you'll read it later? This is like the second time

[MagnaofIllusion]

VOTE: Blackstar

[Dragon Knight]

@mod can you also implement a clause that says they can't just prod-dodge either, regardless of whether or not they have a prod? You already have one that says they can't prodge after having a prod, why not make it both?

[The Banterlords]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

[The Banterlords]

lol at the school part


Lynch train headed to jeanne station!
~Dwlee

[Masquerade]

Not much happened here..
Now, the reason I'm scumreading faq is because he's not making a stance on DK's claim, while appearing to be at least having some sort of scumlean there judging by what he says about them. And I feel 207 was more of an OMGUS than anything else.

I'm not sure yet if I want to lynch jeanne. I don't know her that well, and I'm not sure enough of anyone's alignment to trust their statements on jeanne.
Jeanne, if you're town I want to work with you. What do you think of my faq-vote? What's your read on other players, as far as you have them now?

[The Banterlords]

Very well, since all you do is throw shade on me yourself, I'll stop you by claiming fully. I am a town watcher.

Thats no where near cop fml

VOTE: Jeanne11

idk if we already have the vote on or not but she is sucm

~KT

[TheDominator37]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

[TheDominator37]

Jeanne might be a scum watcher
VOTE: Jeanne

[The Banterlords]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

you don't have swim practice 5 days a week and every day it leaves you so sore you need to rest eat dinner and go to sleep

[The Banterlords]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

you don't have swim practice 5 days a week and every day it leaves you so sore you need to rest eat dinner and go to sleep

~KT

[BlackStar]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

you don't have swim practice 5 days a week and every day it leaves you so sore you need to rest eat dinner and go to sleep

I used to have swim practice. I only felt sore for the first 2 weeks and then I felt completely fine after each practice.

[The Banterlords]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

you don't have swim practice 5 days a week and every day it leaves you so sore you need to rest eat dinner and go to sleep

I used to have swim practice. I only felt sore for the first 2 weeks and then I felt completely fine after each practice.

This is a 50 meter long course though and I practice with high schoolers when I'm only 12 ;/

[The Banterlords]

Dwlee where's my boy KT?

Dieing of school and swim team


mostly swim team

oh yea, I'm catching up right now
~KT

I have school robotics 2 different bands and homework and yet I still have time for this. Pls KT

you don't have swim practice 5 days a week and every day it leaves you so sore you need to rest eat dinner and go to sleep

I used to have swim practice. I only felt sore for the first 2 weeks and then I felt completely fine after each practice.

This is a 50 meter long course though and I practice with high schoolers when I'm only 12 ;/

~KTthecreeper

now lets stop bantering and play the game

[Polar Vortex]

Unvote.

-Snow

[Polar Vortex]

Jeanne might be a scum watcher
VOTE: Jeanne

Why?

VOTE: Jeanne11

idk if we already have the vote on or not but she is sucm

~KT

Why?

-Snow