The Third Fortnight (Game Over [Bonus Round])

[JohnnyFarrar]

Missed that amazing p1. Drat

[JohnnyFarrar]

Looks like an organizational thing to prevent miscounting but what do I know

People in this game are too comfy and too good. Can't parse jokes from intent.

VOTE: Bulge dats my least favorite post so far

[JohnnyFarrar]

It is?

[JohnnyFarrar]

my picks would be:
i) quilford
ii) johnnyfarrar
iii) marquis

[JohnnyFarrar]

who is that korean boy

Spoiler: hes my fav pls don make fun

[JohnnyFarrar]

is he in some other korean boy band

He's the leader of BTS

[JohnnyFarrar]

Nah you know how my scrum game works, kills don't get fancy shit like 'reasons'

Reck lives forever because he knows BTS tho

[JohnnyFarrar]

Least likely to vig? Ummm are we just making a short list of people to kill for scum or should I read the setup?

The "intrigued" post looked the most empty/dumb of anything so far. Maybe that was the straw that broke the back of Geoffrey, my beautiful pet camel.

[JohnnyFarrar]

/kisses johnny

well now i blew my load

thanks

VOTE: the bulge

[JohnnyFarrar]

The thing to be gleaned from this is voting Bulge gets you sexual pleasure so lego

Also for least likely vig rn ummm idk Reck and hip are the only ones that jump to mind

[JohnnyFarrar]

Tbone is my third now because he agrees with my political leanings

VOTE: the bulge

i have this photo of jimin's thighs let me find it one sec

[JohnnyFarrar]

No choice now but to be on the right side of history you pokemon moocow

[JohnnyFarrar]

Go on

[JohnnyFarrar]

Go on

[JohnnyFarrar]

Now I'm all self conscious

[JohnnyFarrar]

Then bandwagon on my wagon ass

[JohnnyFarrar]

Y'all did a sad while I was gone. Cheetsie I did tell you youd get mad before me

@Marq talk to me like I'm slow, why you voting the bone zone?

For Dav I actually really don't like what bulge is doing, but couldn't really tell you why atm

[JohnnyFarrar]

Yeah there's a lot of just like not stating the reasons for things in this game, and I'm like a stupid person so I can't necessarily into it why people they're doing the things that they're doing. Maybe it's a problem with me, but if y'all could just clue me in that'd be dope

[JohnnyFarrar]

Come at me quil

[JohnnyFarrar]

VOTE: CES

actually, good candidate for scum

Eh. I'm willing to follow Hiplop. Out of all the votes on the Bulge wagon, CES bothered me most.

VOTE: CES

Now I want a tier list of favorite to least favorite

[JohnnyFarrar]

I was talking about the wagon and boo.

Ergo's not the only one throwing shade at you hip, why is that a point against him?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Go on

[JohnnyFarrar]

I don't have a problem with it because I trust this player list to not be full of idiots. It's that some sort of mistake?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Got all excited about a post

[JohnnyFarrar]

Bad muffy bad let whoever answer for themselves

[JohnnyFarrar]

Dang muffy so you buy whatever non reasons whatshisname gave earlier for tbone? Or do you wanna say reasons with your mouth hole?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Ergo I'm trying to defend you but jumping on some shit is annoying. Is lynching lurkers worth it right now?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fuck thats such an easy thing to say. Cogie?

Tbone is one of like 14 people who fit that, what about him stands out?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Um. meh? That's what my response is but I wish it wasn't? Is that weird?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I've never played with muffy and I'm not in league with Satan so should I see this?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I'm not put off by you baby

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hip votes. Neat. Why tho? Also I'm just not caught up

[JohnnyFarrar]

Tempted to sheep for the rest of the game until Moo Cow gets off his high horse

[JohnnyFarrar]

Tempted to sheep for the rest of the game until Moo Cow gets off his high horse

hi johnny.
i missed you.

have you found my hiplop case yet.

Not caught up just snarking from work. You want to link me stuff.

[JohnnyFarrar]

That was supposed to be a questionmark.

[JohnnyFarrar]

weak town:
bins
hiplop

this guy is voting me without me making a new post in between lmao

VOTE: quil

quilford!
i would like you to argue at me your hiplop townlean!
!

oh i mean it's in the weakest town category for a reason but i just liked...

...

actually i misread his post #294.

i could probably go for a vote there

Read all the posts homeboy

[JohnnyFarrar]

Ugh

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hi. I'm not caught up but I'm drunk. Who wants to question me?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Its gross. A player I don't like joined my only other game so this one's now my fav

[JohnnyFarrar]

I wanna join this hip wagon but I don't know a hip town game looks like so I dunno if he be scummier than norm

[JohnnyFarrar]

Why not?

[JohnnyFarrar]

We only have 2 weeks total homie, what should I wait for?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean we still get to talk after this (right???) so I don't necessarily think ending the day now is bad unless you're gonna be an asshole after we're no longer on the same team , because there's legit no reason to keep your dope ass sleuthing to yourself afterwards, right?

[JohnnyFarrar]

But we have less bait to hunt and a flee to guess the partner of. Is it not worth it?

[JohnnyFarrar]

You guys should make out.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fuck me. So I just checked when the last time I felt I was "caught up" was and it was goddamn 30 pages ago. I shouldn't have agreed to play a large but hey fuck me right?

Rather than do the shitty thing and replace out I've decided to waste what little free time I have sorting through you bitches getting all testy with each other. I'll be doing this 10 pages at a time and I'll be starting right now. Every 5 pages I'm rewarding myself with a beer and every 10 I'm rewarding myself with anime, so it'll take a minute.

here is where I'm starting, for reference.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fine, Anti, I was going to go for the bandwagon on scum, but let it not be said I'm unwilling to compromise.

Unvote, vote: bulge

Any lynch at all huh? Don't like this one bit.

Marquis I've read 185 like 5 Times and I have no idea what it's saying.

Anti, cheely, do either of you see anything alignment wise in that huge fight thing you had because I really don't wanna read it and I already really like both of you as town.

@Marquis how much do you trust the opinions stated in 211?

Answering the question sort of posed in 216 while his mislynch record is apparently technically alright he does get votes pretty frequently regardless of alignment.

First thing I think snowman did in this thread was implore that dude I've seen the face of to not leave. Seems weird?

My own ego is upset that I'm "unread" in snowman's 251, but the existence of a "null" category in the same list replaces my indignance with confusion.

The weird Hiplop Kuroi 1-2 punch Cogie vote without explanation has my head spinning. It's vaguely clear to me that Kuroi seems alright with a stupid=scummy mindset, but Hiplop didn't state a reason either, other than an implied hipocrisy=scummy mindset, neither of which I agree with.

Boy I was druunk when I posted on page 13, I don't remember that at all.

14 is a quil explosion. I like it, though I'm a little hurt he didn't mention me pridepridepride

I don't have a problem with it because I trust this player list to not be full of idiots. It's that some sort of mistake?

That's your first mistake.

I wanted to assume this was a joke but you're acting on it so let me just put here that I fervently disagree with this line of thinking. Its not really related to

this

game, but I'm bored. The reason I continue to get a kick out of this game and (most of the time) manage to keep my cool is because I treat it like a game, meant for fun, and treat my fellow players with respect in hopes that they'll do the same. Don't assume people are idiots and maybe you'll have a better time and also improve as a player.

The reaction to Kuroi, from both cheets and quil, make me smile. Still pretty sure grogington is town, quil remains to be seen.

Bonesies 399 makes me super uncomfortable. It's like a weird "I know how this game's gonna end but I'm not telling you HAHAHA which is freaky as shit. The only motive i see for this is he's confident he's not going to get lynched? Which seems bananas to me so someone else feel free to interject.

Ehhh he keeps it going on 403 (getting too lazy to link) which is still freaky. If Kuroi or someone Kuroi adjacent flees tonight I'll follow him into he'll but right now I really just want to poke at him about everyone right now.

Snap Chester cheetah taking moo cow to task. I'm practically beatboxing over here.

Every game needs a prideful idiot, and since I wasn't here to do it miltank took the reigns

Teebee still being super cryptic in 424-425, still not liking it.

Gork, remove Kuroi from my "wouldn't shoot" list, and add

myself

...Johnny? Idk, I'm struggling to find anyone town enough to justify putting on the list above anyone else.

Motherfucker I hadn't posted anything serious in arguably 10 pages, how am I one of your 3?

Speaking of 10 pages I've earned some anime brb

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hey you're lucky, I used your real name like 97 Times in that post and replaced it with a cool name each time because who KNOWS what would happen to someone if their real name was on ms?

Nos's beef looks different from my early beef with this idea ftr but I also don't think I follow

[JohnnyFarrar]

You are managing to be wrong, idiotic, and stubborn all at once.

What an achievement.

Vague, ad hominem and ad hominem. Congratulations.

Alright before you were objectionable but now you're just being gross.

People dogpiling on someone for being dumb isnthenwrong kind of interesting.

I kinda wanna be on Cogie's side in 447 because the bone zone is freaking me out but I can't get behind his language nitpicks. It's probably because I've made shitty votes followed by "no for real though" really early in my town games and also because it assumes a base level of shittiness in scum's play that I can't subscribe to.

I agree with 464 a lot and as I write this I'm getting paranoid about how my friendship with Gorky may be ruining my ability to read him. This is why I don't do large games. I latch onto certain people.

Oh snap there's a Kuroi wagon analysis.

@Kuroi I'm curious to know what about the ISO of myself, Dav and Kats sets us apart from those of Gork and bins?

Kats you're too cute in my head for this language

In a stunning turn of lurkervote, quil votes reck. It's clear that it's not a proper lurkervote, but gosh he'd been gone longer than me at that point, what's the point? I had more shit to say about the Reck vote and subsequent talking but Anti had that covered in 485 so snip~

506 is the best case in the game so far. I don't particularly care if googleton is pulling one over on me at this point, if he's scum he deserves the win.

@Kats why Cogie?

I kind of want to say even think like Kats is in 541 Seems townie to me but this setup is weird? And maybe only scum would think of this sort of auto lose situation for them? Fuck it nvm this thought is useless. Made you read it though

548 from Muffy is really bumming me out, why even play if you're not gonna try to win? I get it's a fun place and we're all hilarious but this game has a waiting list of people who presumably want to get in here and

play

.

Ugh gross now we're

discussing

it forget I said anything. *commence posts and posts of arguing about how to properly play mafia*

Bulge seems honest in 626 and his last game was a while ago, backing up said claim.

Wondering why Kuroi's reaction to any wagon is incredulity, but it might be a personality thing?

Then Kuroi takes over the thread again with opinions I disagree with. Notable here is Bulge defending bins

I actually like Dav here. Could be because I do the same thing a whole lot (questioning the motives of people agreeing with me vote-wise)

heyyy just finished 28 animeeeeee

[JohnnyFarrar]

Woop fell asleep

theres nothing in johnny's catch-up that i really disagree with.

There's some typos in there do you agree with those!?!?!?!

Notable here is Bulge defending bins

just fyi though, bins and bulge are loafbirds in the real world.
wooOoOOooo.

Double noted

[JohnnyFarrar]

Last 10ish pages coming as I watch Daredevil. No beer or anime to bribe myself with, so expect slow (not that today is particularly exciting)

[JohnnyFarrar]

I initially wanna vote Hiplop for not making any sense and exhibiting signs of flailing, but then I realize I hate it when people do that shit. I blame the connection I have with cheerio. I might brainstorm out loud about him if he doesn't do something soon.

Hip says "self preservation" as though it's alignment indicative.

Don't like the attack on Dav much and he responds, showing us why he gets votes often. Hoping to get a read on him here, but its hard to tell the difference between him voting with his feelings and him posturing. Basically unless he makes a mistake I'll be assuming he's as scummy as he is good at acting.

@Cogie what?

This argument with Hip, honkington, antihero and David after dentist just comes of as hip being a brat in all aspects. Like, you have two different meta conversations happening and dav asking in-game questions, and hip's being obstinate about all of them. On the one hand, that's super risky scrum play, on the other if he lives and flees he's left a minefield of bullshit for us to sift through. Ugh.

Dad blowing up looks fine. He did that and died in a game I replaced into recently.

I like the turn on quil by Reck and Hip, quil needs pressure.

I'm pretty blatantly town, cheet.

This shit is the goddamned worst. Every time cocky players don't get their way I see some shit like this and it just makes me wanna put a brick through somebody's head. You're not blatantly town and you're barely even trying to win based on how you're playing, so step off your high horse and play the part of the game where you discuss shit with your fellow human beings.

The meta scumreads on hip from pretty obvious townies Gurgle and antre are hard to ignore.

Heyo caught up. Got a little skimmy for the last few pages but hey my typing thumb has a goddamn cut on it, get off my back. I'm gonna make a list of things I want, hold up

[JohnnyFarrar]

Dav

blowing up

That's a dark typo I apologise

[JohnnyFarrar]

Dav, Groky and antihero are all town and I'm willing to stake the game on that. Less so on Bulge but not enough to put any more thought into him.

People who have presumably not read that I have no read on: Nos, bins, Marq. If any of y'all are reading this, get your ass in gear or replace out, this game's hard enough without good players falling behind. I wanna win this.

@mod - do something about tbone

Hip seems like a person I'd normally let slide, though his flip from "^fake" to "genuinely frustrated" on Dav is somewhat distressing and now going after teebee again seems uninspired. I will more than happily lynch him based on that and my townreads' meta-scumreads.

I don't like quil's flip on hip. Quil should talk more.

I don't like kuroi's flip on hip. Kuroi should talk more.

I don't like Snarky's flip on me. Snarky should talk more.

Grade A hero shots if anyone wants to make them: Muffy, Kats, Cogie. Those three are active and I can't think of a damn thing any of them have done.

I'm here for questions, reactions and to discuss the lynch. Who's here?

[JohnnyFarrar]

on another note.

i have a bit of a game that i want to play because ive been mulling over how useful pressure wagons are going to be early on in this setup.

basically, i would like for everyone to give an ordered list of the three people who you would be least inclined to shoot if we were to jump into n1 right now.

my picks would be:
i) quilford
ii) johnnyfarrar
iii) marquis

p-edit: booooooo.

Reference

[JohnnyFarrar]

Can I ask why I've managed to stay at the top when I have basically lurked the last 200-ish posts, beyond one post about Snarky's activity?

Can't tell who you're asking but I've addressed this.

Can I ask why I've managed to stay at the top when I have basically lurked the last 200-ish posts, beyond one post about Snarky's activity?

Lurking is often a scum tell?

And Johnny, I thought my posts grossed you out. Why would you want me to post more?

Because I want to win. Was Hip a townread before your more recent catchup post?

if snarky's not scum, i'd probably pick kat as my shot

Are we doing a Snarky vote then? I'm down.

[JohnnyFarrar]

But seriously can you explain because I'm confused by this... Also which game?

I've seen you get angry like this before as town. Don't wanna bother with self meta rn

[JohnnyFarrar]

Not a strong town read, or probably not any town read.

So you were getting all defensive for him on what? Principle? What was with you and him voting Vogue so quick?

Are we doing a Snarky vote then? I'm down.

i am

VOTE: Snarky why you change your read on me bro?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Not a strong town read, or probably not any town read.

So you were getting all defensive for him on what? Principle? What was with you and him voting Vogue so quick?

Are we doing a Snarky vote then? I'm down.

i am

VOTE: Snarky why you change your read on me bro?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Double post?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Just checked, seems I was conflating your aversion to seemingly all wagons with a defense of hip. My apologies.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Still what's with the jump on the Cogie vote?

[JohnnyFarrar]

VOTE: CES

actually, good candidate for scum

Eh. I'm willing to follow Hiplop. Out of all the votes on the Bulge wagon, CES bothered me most.

VOTE: CES

Reference

[JohnnyFarrar]

Nod I did a dope catchup thing if you wanna read that ;D

[JohnnyFarrar]

I thought you meant snark I'm general, was getting gifs

[JohnnyFarrar]

Nos I did a dope catchup thing if you wanna read that ;D

Ay nos shu'up and catchup. I get it's hard, it took me three days. Either commit to it or replace out, though. We don't have time to argue.

[JohnnyFarrar]

@Bulge Do your best bud, I'm pretty sure you're town so come in with observations, not defenses. If you don't think you can catch up soon replace out.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hip wassup. You still care?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Cogie, you still here?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Fuck I actually missed him by like 10 minutes fuck me

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean I'd rather what you think about Snarky but a vote'd be dope

[JohnnyFarrar]

What does one who's setting up to flee read like?

[JohnnyFarrar]

About halfway through my readup, I'm not gonna do a big catchup post but so far only gork and quil are on my "do not touch" list. Katsuki and kuroi are at the bottom of the barrel, everyone else is varying degrees of inbetweenness.

Why quil?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean we can but that'd be boring if we're wrong?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Snnnnore. Lurker lynches are barely a way to win a game even if you're right

[JohnnyFarrar]

everyone is being so pointlessly rude.

Right?

And granted on the Snark vote. I was hoping the overwhelming towniness of myself and anti would either pressure snowman or get some people to stop hurling insults at each other, or both.

UNVOTE:

@Muff why not Hiplop

[JohnnyFarrar]

Because Hiplop is the fleeingest looking dude in the whole thread

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hip's the only one that's actually done anything tho

[JohnnyFarrar]

People are sad or something.

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean that's possible, but eh?

I'll apologise to you if you're right but that line of thinking would just make me feel like a dirtbag if I acted on it whether it was wrong or not.

[JohnnyFarrar]

vote: hiplop

choochoo.

Spoiler: Pictured, me and you during this game

VOTE: hiplop

Be on the right side of history people. If I lose because I was wrong about lynching Hiplop at least I can feel good about it.

[JohnnyFarrar]

What do you think then Now?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Nos* Jesus fuck new phones and autocorrect

[JohnnyFarrar]

What I mean Nos is that you're still kind of on the sidelines. You got a vote? Hip, Perry? Maybe something new and exciting?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I'm voting you because you're fleeing. I have no idea why anyone would play like you are otherwise. From the "I'm obviously town" bit to the multiple page spanning personal arguments with Gorky and Dav. That's not finding scum, its a distraction that saturates the thread with bullshit that makes the game easier for scum and harder for town. If you were a newer or worse player I might be able to write it off as inexperience or arrogance, but you should know better.

Plus I trust Gorky more than you here.

[JohnnyFarrar]

I'm voting you because you're fleeing. I have no idea why anyone would play like you are otherwise. From the "I'm obviously town" bit to the multiple page spanning personal arguments with Gorky and Dav. That's not finding scum, its a distraction that saturates the thread with bullshit that makes the game easier for scum and harder for town. If you were a newer or worse player I might be able to write it off as inexperience or arrogance, but you should know better.

I'll give you a hint, they were the ones continuing to push that. I kept saying we should stop.

Even when you were "trying" to stop your tone egged them on tho

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean it did tho, unless you think they're both irrational/scum, which just isn't true

[JohnnyFarrar]

Thought that was your new signature for a hot second

[JohnnyFarrar]

why are people reading cupcake as town?

Izzat Kats? Because good question

[JohnnyFarrar]

You're just saying that cuz you don't think hippie's scum

[JohnnyFarrar]

Oh shit

[JohnnyFarrar]

More votes on PV, please.

why tho? have you made a case? It's hard for me to remember your actions.

While we're at it:

Nos, hip reminds you of half a different town v town in a different game, so he's more likely town than a lurker? Can't necessarily argue that but holy shit if hip flees off this

Kats, what about PV's push was scummy?

Muffy, I dunno, you just don't acknowledge any of the points against hip? or you're just apathetic to everything?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Which one's most likely? Gimme a reason and we'll start a dope ass wagon and get this day going all last minute style

[JohnnyFarrar]

Cheetsie if we're arriving at "hip just kind of sucks" is this really the line of questioning you wanna follow?

[JohnnyFarrar]

If it gets down to voting in that pool I think I'll think less of myself and evreyone here as a Mafia player.

But I like other votes better and no one (I think?) is insinuating that both scum are lurkers which means we can find them. For our dignity.

[JohnnyFarrar]

who's scum then johnny?

You know my reads. I don't like hip here. If we're rights or we take this:

i dont think a lurker lynch is so bad in a setup like this where there's clearly going to be one scum making the least amount of associations they can. the question is which of the least-amount-of-association people is the bad guy and which of them is the bad people in general

fucking stab in the dark and we're wrong and he flees, I can send my shot toward quil or Nos, who seem his most likely partners in my head.

If I'm wrong I have a few more suspects in Kuroi, Kats, and Muffy but none of them are as strong.

Also as I'm typing this I realize Quil was absent a hot minute before now, maybe Quil's scum regardless?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hip has been either an asshole or accusatory to everyone, so his partner would be one of those. Plus Nos's reason for townreading Hip seems ridiculous to me

[JohnnyFarrar]

@Quil Self Meta upsets me because these are

things you know

and

would be avoiding

if you're posting them at me as scum

okay, so lets talk about nosferatu for a minute.

in isolation, ignoring potential partner connections, does his catch-up look like scum or no?

I'd bitch that I'm tired but this is probably short, hold up

P-Edit: is Mina even in this game?

[JohnnyFarrar]

Nos starts

Ch. 1: Gork flavored what?

Pushes sweetory for reasons I don't understand to this day. Drops it because I don't remember? States a dislike for gorks that reason escapes

Ch. 2: Catching up but eh?

Asks a bunch of "I'm not actually catching up so tell me stuff" questions, does a 20 page catchup in which questions are asked and never answered and never brought up again (I didn't even notice this)

Ch. 3-4: pointless Bulge poking-reacting to being told to catch up

Titles' self explanatory

Ch. Now

Caught up Nos posting reads lists and joining conversations without standing firmly anywhere, much like most players in this game.

The only thing that really strikes me reading this ISO is Nos's pivot from "show me the important things" and "Here are people who are possibly scum" to "I'm caught up and have no scumreads." You could convince me that's the move of a smart scum who, upon catching up, read the game accordingly and blended in. In a vacuum.

[JohnnyFarrar]

@Quil Self Meta upsets me because these are things you know and would be avoiding if you're posting them at me as scum

No, that's bullshit. How can I avoid hating scum as scum?

Not gonna argue with this because we both see how it can go in circles

[JohnnyFarrar]

@Now pitch me your Cogie & Muffy thoughts. Preferably with graphs

[JohnnyFarrar]

I have to sleep now. I'll be around to change my vote before deadline if need be but I'd rather not. Also heads up I'll probably be grumpy so be on your toes.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Man I think lurker lynches bum me out even more when they're right

[JohnnyFarrar]

I like to think so. This was way more stressful when my partner got picked out of the crowd of their lurkers

[JohnnyFarrar]

Cogie and Bulge, what clued you in?

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean

[JohnnyFarrar]

I mean you didn't fail me. As a friend.

[JohnnyFarrar]

S'cool bbz. I did a job I can be proud of.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Naw I'm just bad at jokes

[JohnnyFarrar]

go right ahead. It's like 7 posts of not a lot

[JohnnyFarrar]

Ugh. I hated doing it the whole time, too. What do you do in that situation? Any other setup I would have bussed pages ago

[JohnnyFarrar]

I'm a persuasive guy, but town basically decided on that slot like 3 irl days ago. At some point Hip looks better just for being here and talking. I could have maybe pivoted onto Nos from what I had said previously but I would have needed a miracle.

[JohnnyFarrar]

@Mods it'd be neat to see who everyone guessed ^.^

[JohnnyFarrar]

In the fight that really matters, I side with muffins.