In post 699, Chevre wrote:Nominee:
Thestatusquo
Title:
Shea
Fairy Opinion:
I've thought this one through and I think I was wrong. Clearly there was a lot of support for the title and a lot of reasoning behind it. I think I've made a mistake by not accepting it the first time around, so I'm
it now. But I maintain that we shall not go willy-nilly with first-name titles and the like in the future.
- - -
Nominee:
GreyICE
Title:
50 Shades of NICE / Fifty Shades
Fairy Opinion:
Eh? All these really do is attempt to enhance or improve the current title. I agree with Psyche in that 50 Shades of NICE could really be taken out of context a few more months away from ChicagoMeet. It may seem to some that 50 -> Fifty is a small change, but I like it. "Fifty Shades" is just better-looking to me than "50 Shades". So InflatablePie's slight amendment of Fifty Shades is
.
- - -
Nominee:
Ranger
Title:
{Top, Tier} and variations
Fairy Opinion:
I'm not really familiar with Ranger, but I like this title! It's pretty signature and representative of her reads, and if they are truly good reads, then it's a very worthy and fitting title. I like it with the brackets because that makes it more unique. I'm
{Top, Tier}.
- - -
Nominee:
Flameaxe
Title:
This 7
Fairy Opinion:
We had a nice discussion about this title and Flameaxe's current title in the SUPP Discord chat. Ether was there to discuss the old one, "Comma Police"; it's from a post restriction in a marathon game. On the other hand, BPC and Shadoweh (and Reck in thread) have explained "This 7" and how it pertained to SurvivorMeet.
I mean, I had no idea how "Comma Police" was relevant to Flameaxe. And I know we're in the moment of SurvivorMeet, so who knows how quickly this will fade, but I think it is most certainly more fitting than the current title. I also like that "This 7" seems sort of clunky when an outsider looks at it, but it's really easily explained. I'm
This 7.
- - -
So yeah. Everyone has 48 hours to approve and further discuss these titles!