Questioning: What should be the best approach regarding this

[Accountant]

Ask questions that:

1) Are Armor Piercing Questions
2) Would make a mafia member panic if asked
3) Allow players to incriminate themselves
4) You already know the answer to
5) Places a player in the spotlight

[Accountant]

The game that we call mafia would be vastly improved if nobody reaction tested, ever.

[Accountant]

hey frozen angel you should try playing some games without raection testing and see how well you do compared to when you do test

[Accountant]

So you can't read people without rxn tests?

[Accountant]

when you say something that doesn't reflect your true thoughts about the game specifically to make someone else react to that thing that you said, in the hopes of discerning his alignment from his reaction

[Accountant]

that's not reaction testing though that's just normal post analysis

@smithereens: questioning can be useful if it's a legitimate contradiction that mafia wouldn't be able to answer

[Accountant]

Smithereens and Frozen Angel have absolutely no disagreement but they use different words so it looks like they are.

If a reaction test falls in the forest without anyone to hear it, does it make a sound?