i literally just commented on the fact that your excuse for avoiding any sort of discussion about your read on greyice/lld/hebi makes no sense, and you reply telling me that you're not paying attention to my greyice stuff
In post 2299, kuribo wrote:yeah, that's my problem when trying to read either side of the argument
do you want me to give you a cliffsnotes version of what's happened and you can do whatever you want with any links i provide?
i can condense all of my issues with greyice in 1-2 paragraphs if it actually makes a difference, but if you want specific details about where x or y happened, then refer to walls where i've gone into copious amounts of detail about each and every one of my thoughts on everything
In post 2290, kuribo wrote:Yeah, I want Creature dead as fuck, but 10 hours before deadline is hardly the time to do it.
I'd hop over to Grey to avoid no-lynch too, but for the record all three wagons give me shitty feelings for various reasons
I go back and forth on Grey in my head, I feel like I'm in a similar position to hebi--- I like Grey as a person and I'd feel like shit if it was a mislynch, but I'd equally feel like shit watching him coast to endgame, then watching him post afterwards something like "Sorry, kuribo bro, that's just how the game goes. You played well, though!" while I say things like "GOD DAMMIT WHY THE FUCK DID I LET HIM OFF THE HOOK" And I can't put my faith in the idea that a vig shot would succeed against him if he's scum.
In post 2290, kuribo wrote:Yeah, I want Creature dead as fuck, but 10 hours before deadline is hardly the time to do it.
I'd hop over to Grey to avoid no-lynch too, but for the record all three wagons give me shitty feelings for various reasons
I go back and forth on Grey in my head, I feel like I'm in a similar position to hebi--- I like Grey as a person and I'd feel like shit if it was a mislynch, but I'd equally feel like shit watching him coast to endgame, then watching him post afterwards something like "Sorry, kuribo bro, that's just how the game goes. You played well, though!" while I say things like "GOD DAMMIT WHY THE FUCK DID I LET HIM OFF THE HOOK" And I can't put my faith in the idea that a vig shot would succeed against him if he's scum.
Man despite butting heads with you yesterday you pretty much summed up my feelings on the matter. This day can't end soon enough. But we do need
A lynch here.
here is a short version of my issues with greyice:
greyice's d1 was unimpressive in every way a d1 can be unimpressive; his votes were meh, his reasoning was meh, the things he was doing in general were meh (lack of scum hunting, lack of comments on important things). d2 he votes zzzx out the gate and gives no other scum reads til i prompt him, at which point he comments on utl. he gives reasons for utl but never expands on them. he goes into detail about something he didn't mention as a reason, and when i comment on that, he uses it as an excuse to vote me (because i've argued on that in a previous game, as well), even though he was the one who focused on it. i point out he was the one at fault for not elaborating on any of his other reasons, he calls me a liar, i ask him to prove it, he still hasn't
he spends the rest of the day claiming i'm scum and that everything i'm doing is lies and slander, but when i ask him to prove this, he doesn't provide any links or quotes. rather than address major points, he nitpicks finer details (like my word choice). when he eventually does go into detail about his reads, he omits things and takes things out of context. he continually avoids giving the information i'm asking for and then acts like he's done it, while raging about how i'm obviously scum
and to top it all off, i still have no idea who his scum reads are outside of me and now pieguy... he hasn't made any effort to talk about anyone else being scum
want me to back up any of this? i can (and have) several times, but give me a specific point and i'll go into detail
there. succinct as it's going to get, now no one has any excuse for claiming they don't understand my issues (and im not even including relatively minor things like the stupidity with the gun "guilty")
i was just reading back over this game and realised how good greyice is at making it seem like he has a point when he really doesn't, and how bad my style of responses are when nobody can be assed to actually read and understand what's going on
i really should have spent more time this game spamming "GREYICE IS SCUM, IT'S OBVIOUS, LOOK AT ALL THIS BULLSHIT" rather than breaking down each of his points and explaining what's wrong with them
i don't even really feel like voting him as a compromise
the only thing that comes out of a random town flip is the fact that magua actually has to pretend to scum hunt tomorrow and spiffeh needs to go "oh tee hee i still have too many town reads" before latching onto a new target, and still neither of them will look at greyice
*shrug*
i suppose ill look stupid if im wrong but whatever
I'm having trouble believing we had two town players who were like...."look at all these awesome roles....but none as great as the double neighborizers!" Let me go all in (like hebi) or 89 points in (like rabbit/RM).
In the latter case, they apparently were interested in auction cop, but could only risk 11 there because they had to make sure they got at least 1 DN.
Best lynch out there? Prob not, but still better than a no lynch and if wrong we only lose a DN.
this is one of those lynches where logically nothing he's done has made a whole lot of sense for him to do as scum, even though he looks bad from it
e.g. the whole on-off-on-off shit with my wagon, while i don't think any of the justification he's given for anything makes a lot of sense, i think it makes less sense for scum to do it. especially unvoting me to what? vote you? a wagon that isn't happening this close to the deadline? why does he do that as scum, when he could easily just ride out my wagon and play it off like the other derps who have no good reason to be on it? worst-case scenario he still gets lynched, but he's at least putting me one vote closer to a lynch, and one vote closer to others compromising on me
i also don't really think he's lying about those bids. i do find it a little strange that a relatively unknown player would prioritise neighbouriser, i guess, but like, either scum left him in the cold for fake-claims (what does he do when he has to prove that claim?) or he's honestly claiming it (seems a bit more likely). the only scenario in which he fake-claims that as scum is if he's scum with hebi though, so i agree with that
i mean, i don't even really know why i'm arguing this since at this point, given almost no one is going to be active before the deadline, it's pretty much me or him
i suppose i'm just trying to make myself feel less bad about what happened today by at least maybe being right about this