Mini 1805: neighbourhood

[Dragon of the West]

Yo robb, sorry about not being active on here. I've had this screen sitting open but just kept forgetting to post

[Dragon of the West]

Are we the only 2 in the neighborhood?

[Dragon of the West]

okay I was just wondering. I feel like it'd be strange to only have 2 people in a neighborhood but I guess it's possible. Also possible that one of the inactive people are supposed to be here

[Dragon of the West]

I don't think you're off base entirely with Creature. But from playing with him last game, his town game always felt scummy to me, so it makes me hesitant to be confident he's scum. Although, he feels even more scummy this game especially because of the lies he's told and his faulty reasoning.
I don't think you've had a problem with tunnel vision this game and you've been really good about throwing pressure around to a lot of people.
I think some of the suspicion might be due to the noobiness of this game. this is only my second game, crab's second, and i think atm's second. beyond that, it's day one so i feel like until a flip or two happens, it'll be tough to narrow down the scum a lot.
So your reads so far have felt pretty agreeable. I want to watch out for atm because 1) I think he's clueless, 2) he doesn't contribute many original thoughts, and 3) Last game when he flipped scum he specifically said he tried to use his cluelessness(is that a word?) to his advantage. Last game we were all reading him as the village idiot day 1, which makes me that much more careful when it comes to him.
Smithereens is off and on for me. Them seem genuine in their scum hunting and trying to push reads on people. I think that the early disagreement between you two made him argumentative with you in particular and your interactions are strained because of that.
I think Dwlee is town. I don't think he'd be so bold as to say "let's just lynch crab" if he was really scum. Plus he's put a lot of decent points out there.
Crazy's play and his defense yesterday didn't feel good to me. You're seeing it the same as me where you said Crazy looks lost right now. I'll have to go through the ISO's and see specifically how they've interacted with each other to make sure their team is plausible but right now I think the most likely scum team is Creature, Crazy, and one or two of the lurkers

[Dragon of the West]

But obviously this could be pretty off-base. My other possible scum(meaning I haven't decided they're townleans through PoE) are eggman, atm, and the other inactives

[Dragon of the West]

And I think you're town right now, but I'm very cautious about that because from my understanding there's generally at least one scum in neighborhoods to avoid giving them the power of masons. Now there may be a lurker or an inactive that's supposed to be in the neighborhood as well but we can't be sure so I'll just have to watch you closely

[Dragon of the West]

Nevermind, I don't think crazy and creature can be scum together. I think if one of them is scum, the other is town. Unless crazy is throwing creature softballs right now for creature to try and defend himself. I don't agree that Creature is acting like atm acted in the other game, but i will agree that creature is playing more standoffish and less arrogantly bold and sure about everything he says

[Dragon of the West]

Yeah mario has been weird because he's been inactive but post enough to not get replaced. I kind of hate that honestly. It's impossible to be sure when someone never posts

[Dragon of the West]

not liking smithereens right now. but that may just be what i pointed out about you two clashing all game

[Dragon of the West]

lol it's not even that he's that scummy it's just some of the things he says make me so mad