ROLE MADNESS: Dead Thread

[Drixx]

Well shit. I'm either too low key and get scumspected or I'm too engaged and immediately draw night fire.

It was your doc claim, actually. (Although the idea of you being scum was mentioned too)

Why did I get left alive so long then?

[Egg]

Fear of watchers and protection

[Titus]

You me And boem was unbreakable circle given no ninja or strongman, which we presumed.

@Transcend, sorry for copping you. You were the biggest slot Shiro and I disagreed on at the time and I figured you looked like a CCC partner I would never get lynched.

[mhsmith0]

Shooting drixx was a job for either the sk or a goon under suspicion IMO. It was somewhat surprising that drixx lasted this long.

[mhsmith0]

Also thors result is 100% correct. Egg really was an sk shot.

[Parama]

yeah tbh i think thor's town. just unlucky. gs report, weird no-visit report bcuz ninja sk

[Transcend]

Thor has towntold quite a bit I do admit.

[Parama]

BORING IS SCUM I WIN SUCK IT

[Parama]

GOD BLESS BOEM I KNEW THERE WAS A REASON I SAVED HIM

[McMenno]

where last red scum at

[Transcend]

boem's a G and actually really good at the game.

also we're good too parama. we cranked boring d1 but CERTAIN PARTIES WHO WILL GO UNNAMED said they were obvtown

Spoiler:

with that said, elyse is conf sk????

[Transcend]

Spoiler:

also thor is town??? boring leading the kill over thor seems... unlikely???

[Dunnstral]

Way too many guilties this game: basically just follow all the cops around

Also way too many lurker scum

[Transcend]

Spoiler:

a50 for last red, laps for one of the blue the other 2 are vedith and someone???

[Dunnstral]

Heard it here first: Narna is town

[Dunnstral]

Gollum has 4 posts and hasn't posted in 11.5 days

I don't even remember who they replaced

PeregrineV has 12 posts and last posted 13.5 days ago

Good chance one of these two is the vig?

Also that's... a pretty crazy rate of participation they're getting away with

It's kind of annoying that we barely have a choice on who to lynch here: town should have had a double lynch mechanic or something and less power roles

[Transcend]

gollum replaced... alpacaalpca???? i don't know lol

[gigabyteTroubadour]

no thor is alpaca

gollum's bella i think

[McMenno]

poor thor

[Transcend]

Gollum is a Nero Cain hydra according to my sources.

[Parama]

4912 is probably the worst post in the thread.

[Drixx]

Yeah ... had boring nailed super early. Nobody was listening to me then but still feels good.

As a discussion point: was the need to get rid of me simply because I would always be on one of CB/Boem? Did any scum buy my expressed doubts about either of those slots?

If there weren't obvious roles that had to be killed, would a doctor claim otherwise merit an instant death sentence? It seems to me that doctor is maybe overvalued (outside of situations where combinations of roles make a doctor a lynchpin), so I'm wondering why others view it as more valuable than I do.

[mhsmith0]

In role madness w a bunch of investigatives a doc is super valuable because it makes shooting the main powers really dangerous. One reason I thought original setup was super town sided was because town roles for together w a lot of synergy, for pretty easy guilties and clears. Iirc the three switched roles were all vt/neighbor roles, easy gunsmith innos.

[CCC]

Surely a doctor claim should be considered equal in power to the most powerful claimed role, when considering who to kill?

[Drixx]

In this game, I felt more like I was just an inconvenience. I was not super likely to get the 3 or 4 saves necessary for doctor role utility to provide an extra mislynch given that I was basically locked into trying to keep Watcher and Gunsmith alive and use my posts to try and play head games with the scum, and hope there was protection for me.

This is exactly what I'm interested in, btw. Doctor is always viewed as a really strong role, but I always struggle with how to manufacture utility from it, apart from the obvious drawing a kill.