In post 3167, Titus wrote:This is the first halfway acceptable vote you've had in awhile. Tempted to follow, but you've been wrong so much. It's no where near my ideal list though.In post 3161, Vecna wrote:Because for someone that is so aware of all the ins and outs of the setup he is way too quiet
Given what you posted had no meaning, no.In post 3174, Vecna wrote:Im sure you can logic your way to the answer
How is MoI/Milkshake town? Also while I agreed it is more likely that Transcend was cleared, it wouldn't surprise me if it was actually Gerry based on what I pointed out in 2851.In post 2881, Titus wrote:MoI and Transcend are town, but he never pushes anything. Shade and 90-95% of his posts are directly shading me or being contrarian to meIn post 2869, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:Except it isn'tIn post 2866, Titus wrote:That's his whole ISO.In post 2865, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:Titus, are you scum reading Max for any other reasons besides his comments about you?
He pushed Vedith and Transcend pretty hard and was like one of the first people to SR the MoI slot.
I could've sworn it was you but after another look I realized it was more so Maria.In post 2886, Vedith wrote:You mean Max saying he will vote me if not Jackal then doesn't end up voting either?In post 2869, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:He pushed Vedith and Transcend pretty hard and was like one of the first people to SR the MoI slot.
Yeah he pushed me hard...
I've yet to vote because the Jackal wagon feels weird and doesn't feel like the best choice out of rb's lynch pool and my other scum reads don't seem like they will get enough traction. Why are you voting for Kraska? You didn't address my point about it being nitpicking.In post 2892, Kison wrote:I can't understand town motivation for it. She cast her vote expecting him to flip town with no deadline urgency. Excuse given is she was "lonely voting scum" and didn't want more day 1 spam.In post 2699, Vifam wrote:Kison what about Kraska's vote on Drone get you off
If anyone thinks this is fitting of her town meta then I'd like an example of her doing this as town in another game.
Drealmerz's says a bunch of nothing with a whole lot of words.
Did I miss something? Is the only reason you're limiting to these four because RB flipped town and had scum reads on them? Just because he flipped town does not mean he is infallible. Obviously we should take the reads into consideration, but I don't see why we should lock ourselves down to them.In post 2708, Fishythefish wrote:We are lynching in rb's lynch pool - {mariaR/vedith/titus/jackel}. rb was obviously town, but if those reads were wrong scum would have had little motivation to kill him. So, townies should get their asses in gear, read up on these players, and vote one of them.
That said, of those four I'd lynch in this order:
1) Maria - Playing inanely, highly distracting, not helping whatsoever. Only silver lining for her is she started to get her act together after getting shit today. Was on Drone wagon, reasoning fairly weak.
2) Jackel - I think he's an okay lynch at best, but I'd be more willing to go with it today than I was yesterday. Disengaged, not contributing, not scumhunting. I could say the same of several others in the game.
3) Vedith - Hasn't pinged my scumdar so far. Reviewing again, consistently active with decent quality. Reasoning for voting Drone also pretty weak though.
4) Titus - Her reads are shit but I've consistently read her as dumb narrow-minded town. Useful if town & game breaking opportunity arises. Was on Drone but not as opportunistic as others - was on his ass consistently D1.
Why have you yet to vote today?Quipla wrote:Not Voting (1) - Lil Uzi Vert
In post 3151, MariaR wrote:Dreal is a good oneeee um
I don't get the tr's on max much (not saying I sr him just wanna know why he's tr #shade)
OH THIS ONE
VOTE: Gerry
hahahaha wimp B)In post 3154, MariaR wrote:Eh sure
VOTE: Dunn
He voted me and called me scum so I shall omgus back until I have a good enough excuse to call hin scum
^^^^^
yeah, just to say - i'm more than happy to stay sitting on Maria.
I cannot endorse this plan. If we wind up lynching Jackal today, we should do your plan. It only has upside if we're wrong though. If Jackal is scum, he will not venge the target. If he's town, he will.In post 3190, kraska77 wrote:Guys get back on jackal and let's direct that shot.
I say we make him shoot Maria. Thoughts?
It slightly annoys me how correct this isIn post 3187, gerryoat wrote:Yeah! You tell her, Max!
Only GERRYOAT can pull blatantly scummy moves and just get away with it because of GERRYOAT'S personality.
Often imitated never duplicated.
In post 3152, Vecna wrote:I cannot find anything about him claiming vengeful earlier in his iso - am I not looking hard enough?In post 3145, Fishythefish wrote:Jackal claimed vengeful a while ago - it's not like it was just when he was being lynched. And scum might well not have realised the problem with claiming - it's pretty hard to shift mindset to one where your role keeps changing. I'm pretty unconvinced by his sudden SR on Titus, looks like halfhearted scum near the noose to me.
Whether to lynch him today or not is tricky. Depends exactly how likely he is to be scum. Even quite likely scumbags are worth giving a vengeful shot - if they're better than 50% town, their shot is better than the average kill. I tend to think that, despite all our grand talk, lynches are little better than random. So I'd say we *should* be happy to lynch a scummy vengeful player. I want to sleep on that, though.
In post 2683, Jackel98 wrote:First off, I'm town.
Secondly, why was I town-reading Kraska? I know there had to have been a reason, but I'm not seeing it any more.
Thirdly
VOTE: Davesaz
I'm willing to believe Transcend was copped by rb. #2658 pinged me as scum being worried about their lynch? I can't very well join the town-bloc, sorry guys.
Maxous is feeling more towny to me. He's still a dick. And Transcend.
Also, lynching the top people is for what? The Jack of Clubs? I have it. Do it.
Why then not just _LYNCH_ maria? This idea is rather pointless.In post 3190, kraska77 wrote:Guys get back on jackal and let's direct that shot.
I say we make him shoot Maria. Thoughts?
I don't see why we should direct the shot by vote. The shot, if Jackel is town, is as pure as the driven snow. Why sully it with a vote involving scum as well as town?In post 3194, Titus wrote:I cannot endorse this plan. If we wind up lynching Jackal today, we should do your plan. It only has upside if we're wrong though. If Jackal is scum, he will not venge the target. If he's town, he will.In post 3190, kraska77 wrote:Guys get back on jackal and let's direct that shot.
I say we make him shoot Maria. Thoughts?
If I get overruled, he should shoot Kison or Dunn.
