In post 10293, MathBlade wrote:I don't know what to say here. Gio clears can be trusted. You are acting as if there is a godfather when nothing has been proven to indicate it and lynching the one person scum can't kill.
We are literally fucked if you take Ank at face value. Like all it is rolling dice. His gut is so horribly wrong. Lynch Ank.
And from my PoV; you're trying to lynch the one person who can shoot at scum, thus providing them with a major advantage. Moreover, I said repeatedly that -even if you're BP- you're NOT the only one they can't kill. I can't be NK'd either, unless they want to lose their killing ability altogether.
besides, you haven't even touched my point on you trying to conf!Town yourself based on the Maxous push but refusing to do the sane to those who got Cakez lynched.
My stance is clear. You and Ank are NOT of the same alignment. You and Nahdia most probably are. If Ank is scum he's the only one left, because everyone on the Cakez wagon is Town. If yo are Scum then Nahdia is too, and that makes more sense to me than Ank being a lone scumster.
Now let's consider the Maxous Faction creation both ways: If it was done night by night, and if he picked 3-4 upon his lynch.
Let's first agree that either way he would have picked those most likely to survive for long.. to end game that is. Then he'd be picking he more influential roles (like the Inventor, for instance).
Now if he was picking on a nightly basis then his defence of the Creature slot in particlar is some ndicator he was eying that slot to recruit or has done so already. If he picked 3-4 upon his lynch then he most likely would have included the claimed BP so that the SK won't be killing them. And either way Cakez handing you his toys is a strong indication all in itself, and you defending him that hard is another, so you really can't tell me that was "just a bad read". I mean, why was SCUM CAKEZ giving you toys? Why would he hand YOU the Tracker shot, for instance? A Tracker would have been useful for HIS OWN SCUM BUDDIES to try and catch the SK (or anyone else who does have a night role).
Then you using it on Nahdia is also questionable, because Nahdia's role could have been proven by simply JKing someone with a night action, let alone YOU are the one who practically reinvented the wheel.. oops! I mean, the phrase "Roles are NOT -necessarily- alignment indicative", yet you're not only trying to convince us Nahdia IS a JK, but also that being a JK necessarily makes them Town.
So, I'm lynching YOU for starters, and I'm 90% confident you'd flip red. When that happens, Nahdia is next. And then I would expect the game to end. If it doesn't then Ankamius becomes the last lynch and the Town wins.
Lynching Ank first is dubious at best, if not outright dumb. He could be shooting Nahdia tonight to end the game already, or -if he is the SK- is a guaranteed shot for Scum over the next 2 nights, so REGARDLESS OF HIS ALIGNMENT (and I do reassert I'm Town reading him) he is NOT the optimal lynch of the day. It's either you or Nahdia, and I prefer you over them.
Now if you're Town as you claim you would be happy eating rope today to eliminate the doubt. Then, and ONLY THEN you can tell me to eat shit and shut up. I mean, you tried to shut me up about Cakez earlier, but -fortunately- we had other CLEARLY TOWN players who saw to it that we lynched SCUM for a change.
In short, you need to admit you're either Scum or bad Town, and we need to know which is it NOW.
Now, please vote yourself and get it done with.
P-edit:
No, and you're -once again- pulling that obtuse card which is not becoming at all. Ank clearly said "You make sense as scum", and not "You make sense, THUS you're scum". He is saying that you being scum makes sense to him.. makes the setup fit.
