In post 619, Lemons wrote:At the time it was all the evidence you'd given.
My suspicion of your read on BTD was primarily due to your heal turn directly after karnos' baseless PR claim, which turned out to be false. I still find this pretty sketchy, and in hindsight it looks like you were looking for a way to stop bussing your partner.
Why was karnos' claim baseless?
We had nothing to go on but his word that he was a PR.
Dark. Culted should be town, you are a confirmed PR; And the reason why we asked Karnos for a full claim was because Lemons started the talk about why we trusted Karnos's claim in 484
If he isn't scum for some reason i have no idea what to do.
Both could be scum but I am leaning Lemons.
Lemons is a lot less active than he was in my prior game with him and the way he jumped when I gave the opportunity could be read as trying for a mislynch into lynching me tomorrow.
Culted is more active than typical scum but there is something off there.
I jumped on Culted because I think you are a mislynch. I'm pretty convinced you're the miller at this point, which makes Culted my top pick for scum, and Charloux my second by POI.
As for activity, in your prior game I had a single day to stay active in, plus life stuff has gotten in the way.
In post 630, rb wrote:RK was your top scumread, but you then jumped onto the Charloux wagon with them - y u do that?
You seemed confident so I took the opportunity to explore charloux myself. It was early and I wasn't really worried about preflips; could've been wrong on RK, scum buss sometimes.
In post 642, Lemons wrote:I jumped on Culted because I think you are a mislynch. I'm pretty convinced you're the miller at this point, which makes Culted my top pick for scum, and Charloux my second by POI.
As for activity, in your prior game I had a single day to stay active in, plus life stuff has gotten in the way.
Why do you think Dark is town?
What's your read on charloux's play?
There's no way Dark's play today is scum. He's completely accepted his lynch and is actively trying to help us find the last scum. Even when I gave him an out by supporting another lynch, he dropped the idea instantly when rb told him to, and he's gone back to accepting his lynch.
If this were an act, he'd have to be relying completely on us changing our minds on a sure lynch without any pushing on his part. That's suicide, especially with how rb is leading things. If he were scum he'd be trying to defend himself at least somewhat.
Charloux is hard to read right now. He's been a bit quiet and he's changing his reads a lot. His play in general this game has been mostly town from what I can see. Still, he's less town then Dark is so he'd be my second pick.
