Open 667: Day 3

[JasonWazza]

Vote Count 1.18

[2] Vijarada: Gamma Emerald, chilledtea,
[2] Keyenpeydee: Celtic, Börk Börk,
[1] chilledtea: Vijarada,
[1] Creature: Pepchoninga,

Not voting: keyenpeydee, SnarkySnowman, Creature,

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline:(expired on 2017-01-20 16:41:09)

Looking For a replacement for Keyenpeydee
Celtic has 12 hours to post in thread.

[Creature]

meh idk what right now

[Creature]

chilledtea, did you check Vijarada's first game?

[Vijarada]

I was scum that game. Terrible meta.

The reason you having the most votes matters chilledtea is that you were about to be lynched and then straight after you made a bald assertion and everyone jumped on it. I find it strange.

[JasonWazza]

I'm replacing celtic.
Tenshii replaces Keyenpeydee effective immediately.
I am also poking Gamma.

[chilledtea]

chilledtea, did you check Vijarada's first game?

No. Is there something special about it?

[chilledtea]

I was scum that game. Terrible meta.

The reason you having the most votes matters chilledtea is that you were about to be lynched and then straight after you made a bald assertion and everyone jumped on it. I find it strange.

I wasn't about to be lynched. Indigo was and partly because she wasn't here to defend herself. Probably also because she didn't seem that good at structuring her thoughts while defending herself.

I mean if people don't have an option then lynching a lurker who might be scum is always inviting. If someone doesn't defend themself then others have even less reason to probe further into the lynch.

Where is gamma and why does he play like this every game?

[Creature]

chilledtea, did you check Vijarada's first game?

No. Is there something special about it?

Nah, just want some comparison there, I've tried to compare myself, though I'd like someone else's opinions.

[Börk Börk]

Vijarada, I feel like I ought to clarify this, I took my vote off Indigo/chilledtea because I wanted to listen to chilledtea and make most of my judgement of Indigo's slot based on the current slot holder. I did this because it's day one and on principle alone I prefer to avoid deciding that someone is 100% scum because, especially when it's only halfway through the day, as it was when I unvoted, it's just not that clear. I think a slot holder can make a big difference, and while I'm not totally townreading the slot due to Indigo's actions, I feel that chilledtea's demeanour and general helpfulness merited an unvote on my part. Especially since he replaced in when the slot was L-1.

[Tenshii]

@Mod I'll be V/LA Thursday-Monday

@Bork SS's last post looks fine

Who or what is SS?

[Tenshii]

@chilledtea What was your reasoning for scumreading Vij?

[Tenshii]

@Pip Restate your case on Creature.

[Tenshii]

I'll post catchup thoughts/reads after my questions are answered. Also since I'm V/LA Thursday, I plan on locking my vote on someone by then.

[Tenshii]

Oh SnarkySnowman. Nvm Gamma.

[chilledtea]

@chilledtea What was your reasoning for scumreading Vij?

He hasn't given me a reason to town read him other than his full on tunnelling on indigo, which I think is fake in this case.
He doesn't seem genuine to me.

[Tenshii]

Are you townreading every other slot? If not, what are your reads on every other slot? Your Vij read is a PoE and not an actual scumread right?

[Pepchoninga]

@Pip Restate your case on Creature.

His couple first posts were a claim that he had a game theory that he wouldn't reveal until the end of the day. Now as town you shouldn't hold information that could possibly help town win. But it's not really town to say you basically game solved in RVS.

Anyways, I see no progression from the slot and yes, this is fact even for the pace that this game is going on.

Due to the pace we actually got his theory early. I hope you will find it easily at it was discussed quite a lot. For me, it is completely anti-town and potentially a dommed strategy for town. But it's also smart. Scum wants to manipulate the situation while looking town. What he proposed tho is basically lynch without actually scumhunt. He is actively proposing we should misslynch. No town motivation in this at all. He doesn't really seem interested in lynching scum and from what I got from his way of thinkins is that he is perfectly fine with us blindvoting until day 2/3.

Do you guys actually need more?

[Creature]

I don't want to waste my precious recourses making scum aware of them.

[Creature]

"No town motivation in this at all"

lol you keep pretending you don't understand.

[Pepchoninga]

I don't want to waste my precious recourses making scum aware of them.

Then don't claim you have shit tactics lol.

[Pepchoninga]

"No town motivation in this at all"

lol you keep pretending you don't understand.

I don't. Enlighten me.

[Creature]

Lynch players you're having a hard time to sort. Like someone that's very good at scum and you can't determine if he's town or scum.

[Creature]

The town motivation is that you're still keeping townread players from being lynched and you're also giving a chance for scummy-looking players (specially if they're easier to read later the game).

[SnarkySnowman]

Hot take: pep is scum

[chilledtea]

Are you townreading every other slot? If not, what are your reads on every other slot? Your Vij read is a PoE and not an actual scumread right?

No I am townreading celtic, and your slot I think (keyen?) bork, creature, pep.

There is a good chance snarky is town as well though. I always tend to scumread her regardless of her alignment. Although not much has been done by her.