Pick Your Power: Double Deck (GAME OVER)

[Maxous]

go ahead

i'm listening

[Fishythefish]

Looking at this post on gerry's innocence. Actually, it's quite convincing. gerry's interactions with Maria don't feel like scum-on-scum action. Uzi, less so.

[Fishythefish]

@fishy: i don't see your cards argument...who is left in the game that has pro-scum cards?

By "card information", I meant cards and their resulting actions. Many people in the game have taken some pretty protown actions (Dunn, Vecna) and/or attempted to take cards that make more sense for town (Dunn, you, drealmer, Grey). This figures quite heavily in my reads.

I'm strongly considering that if gerry is town, it might be fishy as scum

Why?

Just a feeling... and what you're pushing right now

and a bit of poe

OK. If you work out where that feeling comes from, I'd like to know. I think I've played a pretty damn town game in just about every way.

What am I pushing right now, and why is it scummy?

[Fishythefish]

yeah but that's 7 out of 8 players
at least one of them has to be scum so the cards thing will only go so far.

:shrug:

Oh, sure. Some of these are much stronger than others, though. Particularly, Dunn's actions and taking the king of diamonds are very much better for town than scum.

[Dunnstral]

@fishy: i don't see your cards argument...who is left in the game that has pro-scum cards?

By "card information", I meant cards and their resulting actions. Many people in the game have taken some pretty protown actions (Dunn, Vecna) and/or attempted to take cards that make more sense for town (Dunn, you, drealmer, Grey). This figures quite heavily in my reads.

I'm strongly considering that if gerry is town, it might be fishy as scum

Why?

Just a feeling... and what you're pushing right now

and a bit of poe

OK. If you work out where that feeling comes from, I'd like to know. I think I've played a pretty damn town game in just about every way.

What am I pushing right now, and why is it scummy?

Didn't you say we need to solve the gerry me thing now, but you thought we were both town?

WHo do you think is scum, if we are both town?
I had town feelings on drealmerz too

[Fishythefish]

Yeah. You were death-tunnelled on each other, and we can't have deathtunnelling in LYLO - do you disagree? If you've stopped that, that's great.

My reads kind of go from super-town to mildly-town at the moment. If there was a slot I knew nothing about, I'd gladly PoE lynch it. My rough ordering is:

Super-town

drealmer, Vecna

Town

Dunn, Grey, TWIE

Mildly town, which I guess means scum

gerry, Max

I'm not feeling very inspired by any of that, though. The problem is, a PoEish lynch doesn't tell you much if you get it wrong.

[gerryoat]

lol fishy. im done here.

VOTE: Dunn

[gerryoat]

i already proved why ic ant be maf with either of those, but im done here now

[Dunnstral]

Gerry's still tunneled so we lose

From poe it might just be TWIE bussing.

[-Grey-]

yeah, i think i'll be voting Grey after Dunnstral tbh.

Sure, vote the guy that's been screaming for Dunnstral's head... after lynching Dunnstral.

That makes all kinds of sense.

[-Grey-]

I'm still 90% sure you're maf!!!!

Duh.

[-Grey-]

I'm thinking the Scum is Dunnstral and Maxous.

[drealmerz7]

yeah ^

the 2 I'm most comfortable lynching currently are dunnstral and maxous, comfort not necessarily in that order

and I really think fishy has to be town - if we win this he is one of THE top responsible people for the win, imo - no way he is scum

fishy, help me weigh some things re: dunnstral (the rest of you toss these thoughts around in your head too)

he does the pro-town cardpicking, reviving, all previously mentioned stuff that makes you think he has to be town and does exactly as he did to get to where he is now (and he's scum) - do you think he thinks he is "sitting pretty" right now enough that he doesn't need to try and look like he's solving the game (because he doesn't so much, yes, moreso recently, but, it's been notably lacking imo for where we are in the gamestate) - what

is

his frame of mind? is his scumbuddy is so deep he doesn't really care that he's under fire?

do you think (again if he's scum having done those things) the value in having done those things as scum is MORE /has more payoff (having led to us all to this actual gamestate), or do you think there would be higher value for scum (netting in a better position for scum than they are in currently, which granted is hard to determine not knowing who they are, but theorizing that he is one of them) if he hadn't done those things as he did them? am I making sense? (lots of thoughts running around and sometimes for my brain it is hard to pull out the singles and articulate them well - I can tend to go in circles/repeat or be overwordy

otherwise dunnstral is just towny at a loss and not trying so hard, which is also quite believable, but, I'm still leaning more likely scum, with what is "out there"

grey and TWIE are still options as scum but right now they are both part of the "having nailed down scum and gotten us to 2 left" duo - I don't think they'd BOTH be scum having gone that route - if I had to pick one as scum I don't know who I'd pick, I guess grey based on most recent play (but he wants to lynch maxous+dunnstral like I do...sooo...?)

vecna - I just don't see it, again, one of the top players responsible for a town win if town wins

scum is in: maxous/dunnstral/grey/TWIE pretty sure with gerry as an out-lyer possibility that I'm still "sitting with"

[-Grey-]

I think I'd prefer to lynchbait Maxous before Dunnstral because of 6446, tbh.

No way does town support the lynch of their scumread like that. If I was so scummy to him, Dunnstral should be the last person he'd want lynched.

[-Grey-]

I think I'd prefer to lynch Maxous before Dunnstral because of 6446, tbh.

No way does town support the lynch of their scumread like that. If I was so scummy to him, Dunnstral should be the last person he'd want lynched.

FU autocorrect.

[gerryoat]

would lynch Dunn and Grey. Maybe max

[drealmerz7]

my mind is pretty resolved to dunnstral as my first choice but want to hear from fishy again

[Maxous]

yeah, i think i'll be voting Grey after Dunnstral tbh.

Sure, vote the guy that's been screaming for Dunnstral's head... after lynching Dunnstral.

That makes all kinds of sense.

I'm thinking the Scum is Dunnstral and Maxous.

a) you haven't
b) i've been vocally anti-Dunnstral since the Davesaz kill so if you think i'm scum with Dunn that defence doesn't roll anyway

[drealmerz7]

I'm really trying to squint and see if I can see this as scum-gerry and it is hard but I can maybe see it ?

phewww...I dunno...

[Maxous]

Meh.
I think Gerry is a cop-out option personally.
The easy lynch

[-Grey-]

No way should Gerry be lynched over Dunnstral.

[Dunnstral]

Meh.
I think Gerry is a cop-out option personally.
The easy lynch

Nothing easy about it

Also funny, since you're pushing me

No way should Gerry be lynched over Dunnstral.

are you scum

[-Grey-]

are you scum

Dammit, you got me.

I succumb to your advanced sleuthing skills.

[Maxous]

Meh.
I think Gerry is a cop-out option personally.
The easy lynch

Nothing easy about it

Also funny, since you're pushing me

Why is it funny

[Dunnstral]

I'm


the easy lynch