Open 333 : Carbon-14 - Game ended

[Cobblerfone]

Actually it was serious. To explain, "trying out a new style" can be an excuse to avoid comparisons to previous town-meta. It's not much, but it's early. With my townread posts I felt we were out of RVS but still in RQS, so... yeah.

Why are you trying to avoid comparisons to prior town meta?

?
I was talking about DonJosh.

@Kondi: It was Newbie 1112. You are also so obvtown it's not even funny.

[Mist7676]

School -.-

Xalxe stop trying to get a lynch on me...

Whiskers stop vote hopping.

Kondi thanks for posting more.

DonJosh... POST MOAR!!1!!!11!!

Xalxe this is taking it seriously but ya I do play suckish. I'm still learning how to play even though I've played for 3 years now...

OH YEAH I'M GRANDMA!!!

[Whiskers]

saulres- does the research, cares about the game, is active, etc.
DonJosh- similar reasons, but I like saulres better.

Let's start here:
Um, what? DonJosh is a townread for similar reasons to saulres: he "does the research, cares about the game, is active, etc."
Is there an example of him having done any research?
What makes you think he "cares about the game" any more than any other player (except for Mist or maybe Kondi)?
DonJosh is active? O RLY? He's tied with Mist for second-to-least amount of posts.

Actually it was serious. To explain, "trying out a new style" can be an excuse to avoid comparisons to previous town-meta. It's not much, but it's early. With my townread posts I felt we were out of RVS but still in RQS, so... yeah.

Why are you trying to avoid comparisons to prior town meta?

He isn't, your conf-town read DonJosh is. I expect you to promptly ignore this bit now that you realize it's against him.

Why do you call those players weaker than the rest of us?

:goodposting:

I'd like to hear the answer to this as well[/quote]
Interesting is that my "taking the game seriously" is a scumtell, and my activity apparently counts for nothing. Double standard?

However, your scumread on Whiskers earns +town credl

Buddying. "You agree with me, you must be town."

Someone asked for reads. Here.
Xalxe - Overall friendliness, seems to be taking charge of scumhunting. Is pro-discussion
saulres - Pretty much same as above, but less scumhunting.
Cobblerfone - Pre-game research was good, but I always see scum doing RQS, so that docks some points. This puts him in null-zone.
kondi2424 - Overly-defensive. Null-scum, but mostly Null. Moar posting pl0x
Whiskers - Vote-hopping and clinging to unnecessary RVS arguments.

Mist isn't here cuz she's so null it's not even funny.

I'm pretty sure

I

asked for reads.
Xalxe-- I missed the overall friendlyness, maybe it's there? I don't really care, because it isn't a town-tell. I'm not sure he "takes charge of scumhunting," as Cobblerfone has been more productive in scumhunting.
Is there any single one of us that is NOT pro-discussion?
Where is kondi2424 overly-defensive? I'd like some evidence, please. His posting is fine for how far we are into the Day (not very). The only gripe I had was his posting frequency and that he has a history of "flaking" (which ultimately leads to being replaced). I won't go so far as Cobblerfone and say he's obvtown (I just plain don't see it), but he certainly doesn't look like scum and is playing well.

[Xalxe]

School -.-

Xalxe stop trying to get a lynch on me...

Whiskers stop vote hopping.

Kondi thanks for posting more.

DonJosh... POST MOAR!!1!!!11!!

Xalxe this is taking it seriously but ya I do play suckish. I'm still learning how to play even though I've played for 3 years now...

OH YEAH I'M GRANDMA!!!

Sure, contribute more. Also, what?

saulres- does the research, cares about the game, is active, etc.
DonJosh- similar reasons, but I like saulres better.

Let's start here:
Um, what? DonJosh is a townread for similar reasons to saulres: he "does the research, cares about the game, is active, etc."
Is there an example of him having done any research?
What makes you think he "cares about the game" any more than any other player (except for Mist or maybe Kondi)?
DonJosh is active? O RLY? He's tied with Mist for second-to-least amount of posts.

Ooops, my bad. I just prefer posts with content to things like Cobbler's posts.

Actually it was serious. To explain, "trying out a new style" can be an excuse to avoid comparisons to previous town-meta. It's not much, but it's early. With my townread posts I felt we were out of RVS but still in RQS, so... yeah.

Why are you trying to avoid comparisons to prior town meta?

He isn't, your conf-town read DonJosh is. I expect you to promptly ignore this bit now that you realize it's against him.

Oh, shit, really? Sorry for the misquote.

@DonJosh

: Why are you trying to avoid comparisons to prior town meta?

Why do you call those players weaker than the rest of us?

:goodposting:

I'd like to hear the answer to this as well

Interesting is that my "taking the game seriously" is a scumtell, and my activity apparently counts for nothing. Double standard?

Your version of taking the game seriously includes scummy posts. Active scum are possibly scarier than inactive town.

However, your scumread on Whiskers earns +town credl

Buddying. "You agree with me, you must be town."

Nope. Agreeing with me does not mean auto-town. After all, she could be bussing.

[kondi2424]

Nope. Agreeing with me does not mean auto-town. After all,

he

could be bussing.

FTFY

[Xalxe]

Sorry kondi. Don't know why I thought you were a female.

[Cobblerfone]

Scumspects: Mist for #101 (mainly the copycat cry of "Whiskers stop vote hopping" rubs me wrong) DonJosh is relatively only leaning scum for previous reasons. Xalxe is getting scummier by the post. Examples of my posts without content please? The only reason I'm not voting you right now is because I'd expect scum acting like you are to be more competent than this. And I don't see a Mist/Xalxe scumteam as likely.

VOTE: Mist

[Xalxe]

What I mean by "posts w/o content" is that you were very good at asking questions, but there's been no followup. Same goes for Mist. Why bother asking questions if they're not helpful? (useful question btw)

[Cobblerfone]

What I mean by "posts w/o content" is that you were very good at asking questions, but there's been no followup. Same goes for Mist. Why bother asking questions if they're not helpful? (useful question btw)

I ask questions to get a frame of reference.

[Whiskers]

His questions at the beginning were useful, and looked good. they pertained to the players if not this specific game (unlike Mist's questions, which were the standard, "What timexzone are you in lol?"). Now, he is making reasonable accusations and using his posts fairly effectively.

Cobblerfone SHALL NOT be lynched, assuming he keeps up this good play.

[Mist7676]

I was just asking questions to know when you guys are on.

And sometimes questions can be important no matter what the content...

[Whiskers]

Yeah. I'm not even fighting against your questions. My point here is that Xalxe or DonJosh are all cuddly together, saying that the other is so awesome, both reading Cobblerfone as Neutral/Null, for instance, when in fact Cobblerfone has been more useful to the town than either one of them.

[Xalxe]

Xalxe or DonJosh are all cuddly together

Bullshit. He's being productive.

[saulres]

His one post with content is productive?

I'm not seeing it. It's helpful, sure, but productive?

And it's more than Mist. So it's got that going for it. Although that's not really saying much. Mist, do you have any opinions at all on what anybody's said?

Someone give me someone to ISO looking for tells. Oh wait, too early for that. But know that I like doing that, so if you need someone to ISO, I'm your man!

[Whiskers]

I'm not sure I'd say it's too early, either, I've been ISOing everypony (Xalxe in particular) all game. I was ISOing you, about to make a case, when you posted your wonderful link that explained why you were playing the way you were playing.
Something fits with Cobblerfone. After a two-hour nap, I'm looking back over his ISO, and no, he hasn't been a big player. But I can hardly call him useless.
Mostly, his questions have been pointed and-- I don't know. He's playing the way I expect good town players to play. He hasn't provided much content, but I liked his bit on DonJosh.

His reads are more solid than yours, Saulres.

Xalxe or DonJosh are all cuddly together

Bullshit. He's being productive.

Bullshit. Xalxe, the only place DonJosh could be said to be "being productive" is in his sixth and most recent post, where he gives his reads. HE GIVES HIS READS AWAY FOR SILLY REASONS. For example, you are Soooooo town, because you're Pretty friendly! Way to go, Xalxe, you won him over with your charm, and turned into a townie!

Ah, and looking back I see that you (saulres) were referring to DonJosh's one post with content.
A saulres, why don't You go and Iso somepony, looking for tells?

[Cobblerfone]

And sometimes questions can be important no matter what the content...

What do you mean, exactly?

[Otolia]

2nd Votecount of Day 1

:
Mist7676 (2) - Xalxe, Cobblerfone
DonJosh (1) - Whiskers
Xalxe (2) - Kondi2424, Mist7676

Not voting : saulres, DonJosh

[Cobblerfone]

@mod: you have Mist as having two votes but her name still appears as voting for herself along with Xalxe's and mine.

[Cobblerfone]

Also, Whiskers is voting DonJosh

It should be correct now. ~ Otolia

[Whiskers]

And sometimes questions can be important no matter what the content...

What do you mean, exactly?

Maaaan, Mist, I hope that come the weekend, you'll be able to check in a little more frequently?

[Mist7676]

And sometimes questions can be important no matter what the content...

What do you mean, exactly?

Maaaan, Mist, I hope that come the weekend, you'll be able to check in a little more frequently?

I'll probably explain later. I don't know what I was thinking then

And Whiskers I'll have some access but not much.

[saulres]

So could you maybe answer your own questions? Particularly #4?

1. What is your timezone?
2. Why do you play mafia?
3. What's your favorite role?
4.

When do you get to post?

[Mist7676]

So could you maybe answer your own questions? Particularly #4?

1. What is your timezone? Central
2. Why do you play mafia? Because I like the concept
3. What's your favorite role? Any Mafia Role
4.

When do you get to post?

Hardly Ever. After school and Saturdays if I'm not doing stuff with friends.

[saulres]

@Xalxe:

Was this:

Vote: Mist7676

Policy lynch go!

due to this?:

Hardly Ever.

If so, how did you know she hardly posts? If not, what was the policy?

[Xalxe]

@Xalxe:

Was this:

Vote: Mist7676

Policy lynch go!

due to this?:

Hardly Ever.

If so, how did you know she hardly posts? If not, what was the policy?

I've played with her in MishMash. And it was due to that.