Scummies Nominations 2023!

[Flavor Leaf]

i've had 4 completed scum games this year i think, only lost one of them when i was accidentally killed by a teammate n1 in "fire and more fire"

i wouldn't call myself a great scum player though, was yeeted in two of those

You’ll at least be getting a goodfellas nom

[Alisae]

I feel like this is a year where people didn’t get a high scum roll anywhere?

I got a total of 5 I am 2/5

5?!?

Damn.

The games I won were
Election - practically carried by LLD and Bingle, I didn't need to do much but then ig you can argue knowing how to not do much can be good wolf gameplay sure.
Demon Slayer - I mean for 3 phases of the game I forced things through and then I got mechanically outed as a wolf by a single night action which should have broken the entire game open but somehow I still won because I somehow mind controlled the thread into thinking my role was a real thing??? This was just a game of all time ya.

The games I lost were
A micro - my first experience playing with andante ever. I did not bus her on page 5. I should have bussed her on page 5. I didn't. I lost this game.
TM - Andante replaced in and in general I just made terrible decisions. Day 1 was beautiful tho I should have just forced Staeg dead considering all the trouble afterwards was just so not worth it.
Swingers - Ya so Klick kind of just won the game on page 1 and I did want to bus my teammates so I kind of just lost?

tl;dr yep shoulda bussed ig

[Black]

Thanks. It’s truly a crippling obsession.

Felt

I felt so bad having to power tunnel you, but it was the wincon.

It was a great play. Was I bitter? A little. Did I overreact? Definitely. You were so good at it that you made me want to retire

[Alisae]

ok actually that Demon Slayers game is just hilarious that is a goodfellas nom I think

[Flavor Leaf]

Demon Slayer I’ll write up a Goodfellas nom for too. That was well done. I felt like a pack of hyenas just swirled around me that entire game.

PEdit: Ninjad

[Flavor Leaf]

Town wise, this year for me, I feel like I had some good catches, and overall reads, but I have to die to prove my alignment to show my worldview

[Alisae]

I mean guns and roses my play was +winrate and I killed it in that game
in an open that just finished i started playing d2 and won the game on d3
datisi uni I was basically an immovable object and closed out the game.

[DragonEater70]

ok actually that Demon Slayers game is just hilarious that is a goodfellas nom I think

I will preemptively NTH it.

[Alisae]

it's also the one of the few games on ms where wolves actively utilized a discord to talk in and that just made the experience better being on the team

[Flavor Leaf]

What is like the overall feel for Rising Star noms?

I feel like Hu Tao and Black are like the premiere Rookie Year Rising Star candidates

But in the scenario someone’s been here for a couple years, but they showed out truly this year, would we think that qualifies?

[DragonEater70]

Honestly you were filling the main thread with so many messages the main thread was like your Discord

Like the volume and speed of posts felt more apt for the discord game than for a forum game

[DragonEater70]

What is like the overall feel for Rising Star noms?

I feel like Hu Tao and Black are like the premiere Rookie Year Rising Star candidates

But in the scenario someone’s been here for a couple years, but they showed out truly this year, would we think that qualifies?

According to the description of the award, yes.

[Alisae]

I liked oopsiedaisy but idunno if she wins

[Flavor Leaf]

Honestly you were filling the main thread with so many messages the main thread was like your Discord

Like the volume and speed of posts felt more apt for the discord game than for a forum game

Day play is my strength, I’ll give it that.

Really the only mark I would give against my scum year was on Night 5 in Pokemon, we hit an unclaimed BP, and used strongman before. Was going for a perfect game, but I said from the beginning, if any of us were to go down, I would go down for the team, and setup the Plan B in fading Not Mafia who I created connections with.

The Plan B got a little scary at times, but it did go off as planned after.

Risked it for the biscuit with Plan A perfect game in a large, and day play wise, we got it

[Flavor Leaf]

What is like the overall feel for Rising Star noms?

I feel like Hu Tao and Black are like the premiere Rookie Year Rising Star candidates

But in the scenario someone’s been here for a couple years, but they showed out truly this year, would we think that qualifies?

According to the description of the award, yes.

Okay, I got 2 Rising Star noms then.

[DragonEater70]

Honestly you were filling the main thread with so many messages the main thread was like your Discord

Like the volume and speed of posts felt more apt for the discord game than for a forum game

Day play is my strength, I’ll give it that.

Really the only mark I would give against my scum year was on Night 5 in Pokemon, we hit an unclaimed BP, and used strongman before. Was going for a perfect game, but I said from the beginning, if any of us were to go down, I would go down for the team, and setup the Plan B in fading Not Mafia who I created connections with.

The Plan B got a little scary at times, but it did go off as planned after.

Risked it for the biscuit with Plan A perfect game in a large, and day play wise, we got it

Hmm? That was @Alisae

[Flavor Leaf]

Oh, that makes more sense.

Discord style isn’t my style, but i see how it could help tremendously. Not that i wouldn’t do it, i just don’t think my posting style is good for it.

[Alisae]

I think if you fundamentally broke down what happened in demon slayer it's pretty funny

[Flavor Leaf]

Firebringer rolled scum multiple times this year, i think i played against them 3 times.

They always warlock me

[Cook]

The only noms I think I honestly should get this year are the moderation stuff but when it comes to play do what u want.
Klick I think def deserves a paragon nom because that guy is actually insane

i feel weird about requesting noms for myself it seems like bad form

[Alisae]

i feel weird about requesting noms for myself it seems like bad form

I think we're all adults here so I think we should be able to vouch for ourselves if we really feel like we deserve it.

[Alisae]

I think the cases that are bad form are a lot more obvious

[DragonEater70]

I agree it's usually bad form but I think Alisae deserves pretty much any nomination she thinks she deserves sooo...

[DragonEater70]

~

[Klick]

paragon
2023/20/11	Alisae	Klick	I mean this is basically the teacher vouching for the student. consistently very strong town player. Has a very solid understanding of the game (which is more than most players). Here is 1 notable example other people can write more and add more than I'm willing to. game - wins game page 1 by forcing a tvt. this tvt eventually leads into very quick game win.

I really appreciate it, but I also think I've had some kind of horrible town games this year mixed with the good lmao

I'll take the nom but I feel like I could do better.