My reasoning for thinking that is somewhat flimsy, and I'm notTML wrote:I do agree with Mastin about there probably two scumteams barring shenanigans.
Please elaborate on why you think I'm actually correct in my theory. (...How often do you hear someone say that? )
In post 1040, Maxous wrote:In post 1028, mastin2 wrote:-Were meant to look kinda town in nature,
What?
Nero's post was'nt a 'scumslip', though I really don't get the 3 people pulling a distraction to the game thing...(to what end exactly? Why?)
Unfortunately I can't re-check rolling in the deep - as it is lost in the crash - but if I remember correctly, Pine is quite likely scum for this post
There was a player in that game, sky who lurked like hell and then claimed VT when wagoned to L-1.
Pine made the arguement(again, iirc) that it was unlikely that a player would be so lurky and useless and then claim vt so he is likely town (or something to that affect). Turned out he was correct.
Yeah, he was a sk in that game but he was still genuinely hunting scum.
The same arguement is pointed out to him this game and he dismisses it with 'oh wifom, let's lynch scooby next'
Whyscooby is scum for that post was'nt pointed out either
Plus that fakeclaim accusation was silly, a fakeclaim of what exactly?
Why would scum claim vt and then say 'oh I want to check with the mod about my role'
Why would someone think a scum player would do that?
He did'nt think that through at all ...which is also scummy, particulary since he was basically calling for a hammer on rack.
vote:Pine
In post 1047, HezLucky wrote:
My reads were given yesterday. It should be obvious that I push on my scumreads and largely leave others alone, at least this early in the game.
In post 1048, The Mini-Librarian wrote:Nero Cain. I don't think that creating a vote post overnight is a scumslip, but goddamn that post is terrible for other reasons. What exactly is your case on LLD again?
In post 1049, DeasVail wrote:Nero:Why did you comment on GI's replace out now? Why did you feel the need to mention me as possible scum?
In post 1020, Nero Cain wrote:OH HAI MINI!!!
You're always there to defend LLD, huh? She your scumbuddy? Wouldn't suprise me.
I wrote that at the end of the day phase but when I got home the thread was locked. You are correct that I would have voted LLD regardless of night kills (unless there was a scum) and I really don't understand why it matters who got flipped. How would two town flips change my scum reads?
nice chainsaw.
Nero wrote:yet according to you (atleast the vibe I get) its unacceptable for me push on my scum reads and ignore those that I'm not ready to lynch yet. Please explain this double standard.
In post 1057, Junpei wrote:In post 1020, Nero Cain wrote:OH HAI MINI!!!
You're always there to defend LLD, huh? She your scumbuddy? Wouldn't suprise me.
I wrote that at the end of the day phase but when I got home the thread was locked. You are correct that I would have voted LLD regardless of night kills (unless there was a scum) and I really don't understand why it matters who got flipped. How would two town flips change my scum reads?
nice chainsaw.
Okay... people won't lynch the scumslip, how about the reaction to the scumslip being pointed out?
He aggressively attacks Mini-Librarian for one. Then he says he
1) Wrote the post at the end of Day 1
2)Would have voted LLD regardless of night kills
Issue being of course that he first references the posts' logic in regards to pre-night and then post-night. Why was Nero voting LLD at the end of day 1? This reaction looks fake and looks to try to scare off his attacker.
In post 1061, Nero Cain wrote:I don't understand why you or Hez or Mini feel like I should have dropped my LLD scum read overnight.
In post 1062, DeasVail wrote:In post 1061, Nero Cain wrote:I don't understand why you or Hez or Mini feel like I should have dropped my LLD scum read overnight.
I don't think that's what they're saying at all.
In post 1055, DeasVail wrote:Scooby:I'm pretty sure that part was lost in the crash. It was NY 142, but I don't think it'll help.
Nero:I'm pretty sure he's being replaced (from the replacement thread anyway).
Why would it matter that I was possible scum if agreeing with me on an unrelated-to-the-game issue?
Prae had everything to do with GI. Prae's lack of posting and then replacing out shouldn't have had an impact your read on the slot whatsoever.
What makes you think I'm concerned about him? My question demonstrates concern about you.
In post 1056, DeasVail wrote:Also, about the Pine thing, I do remember Sky claiming VT and then someone saying he was town for the way he acted. I do think it quite likely that it was Pine, and am quite willing to trust Maxous that it was the case. This is not the only thing that makes Pine scummy in my mind though.
In post 1069, Pine wrote:No, that was definitely me. Maxous is taking my comment completely out of context, however. I'm not calling Scooby scum for the wagoned-to-VT thing, that was entirely irrelevant. I'm calling Scooby scum because he said he was clarifying something about his role with the Mod. WHAT DOES A VT NEED TO CLARIFY?
Also, I'm pretty sure Gunny is scum too. Universal Backup DOES NOT WORK THAT WAY. Mason is not a Power Role, you don't inherit it. Fakeclaim is fake.
Vote: Scooby
The more egregious of the pair.
is one of the stupidest things I've ever read. Your scumhunting has been pretty random all game, but this takes the cake. This is craplogic that makes drmyshotgun look brilliant in comparison.Still I think the LLD, GI, Benmage taking offense to reds post is a dileberate attempt to distract from the game and each slot should get major scum points.
go town.