Mini Normal 1460 - Normalville Mafia (GAME OVER)

[StupendousMan]

Lucky2u (chernobylcitybus) VCA:

Darthe (7) - Miss Stranger, grimgroove, Baezu, Nachopappa, SunnyDays,

chernobylcitybus

, PeregrineV (town lynch)

6th person to vote, put Darthe at L-1.

PeregrineV (6) - Baezu, Miss Stranger, Elyse, Slandaar,

Lucky2u

, Grimgroove (town lynch)

5th person to vote, put PV at L-1.

Ztife (5) - Miss Stranger, ChannelDelibird, SunnyDays, Baezu,

Lucky2u

(mafia lynch)

Last person to vote for mafia.

__________

This confirms my suspicion of Lucky. Take it as you will.

Pedit: First page, page you linked me to, and a few pages before I came in. Also, as you can see from this post, I've looked at the end of day lynches. Why do you ask?

[ChannelDelibird]

I'm back from Scumdon so I'll get caught up today if possible (couple of other things vying for my attention after a week more or less without internet). Pretty sure we should be lynching Shamrock today; I'll go into why when next possible.

[Shamrock]

SM what is your role?

[Slandaar]

Hello dears, I've been reading the topic since I applied for replacement but it's going to take me a few hours more, probably. Once I'm done I'll give my initial thoughts!

Okay, I'm mostly done reading this, it took me a lot more than I initially thought.. -_-

Well, I better get some sleep now, I'll try to post my reads as soon as possible, and perhaps a collective table with everyone's reads so we can compare and analyse easier. Good night ^^;

She then goes and posts ISO reads on people, this reads very fake and manufactured. Note it took THIRTY minutes between her first read and second after reading an entire thread.

She admitted in the hood qt which Grim's slot can confirm, she had no reads and went to ISO people to get reads but this contradicts;

I'll try to post my reads as soon as possible

Which implies she has reads already.

When Grims slot gets here to confirm this I expect Stu dead.

[Slandaar]

To expand on this earlier point;

Also, how was Red Dragon not lynched afterwards?

Red Dragon is obvscum how wasn't he lynched??!!!

Can you answer the question from my previous post?

Sland answer my question how on earth isn't RD dead???

People need to post. I'm not waiting any longer for my vote.

VOTE: Lucky

Vote Lucky!

If RD was as obvious as Stu was implying why isn't he voting that slot? (I think its CDB)

And then we have him accusing me of promising but not delivering content, I reply saying yep thats my plan got a problem? and he just lets it go which is amusing but also very weak.

[StupendousMan]

@Slandaar- You missed two things: the post where I said that RD probably defended himself but I'm too lazy to look and the post where I made a good case against Lucky. In regards to your promising but not delivering content post, I don't answer when it looks like sarcasm.

@Shamrock- Town neighbor.

[Slandaar]

What? where is your good case against lucky?

[StupendousMan]

Top post of the page. Look at the voting patterns.

[ac1983fan]

Votecount

Lucky2u (1) - StupendousMan
StupendousMan (1) - Slandaar

Not Voting (5) - Grimgroove, Shamrock, ChannelDelibird, SunnyDays, Lucky2u
With 7 alive, it'll take four to lynch. Deadline is on Monday, August 19th, at 10:30 PM EST, or in (expired on 2013-08-19 22:30:00)

Since grimgroove is supposed to be off V/LA I really hope he comes back and posts, but if not then I am still looking for a replacement for Grimgroove.

[Lucky2u]

Stupid man - I agree with Slandaar here. As scum in the past I've done the very thing stupendous did here and raised a case against someone then voted for another. It was because I was raising the case against my partner for WIFOM in case one of us flipped. Probably scum.

Slandaar - since I've got here he tunneled me first day on scene and then votes PV, tunneled me the next day and votes ztife. One led to mislynch and the other was right on target. I think he is town because what I see happening is he is pushing me and then seeing the scum come out when they feel safe.

Shamrock - I like his interactions during the ztife wagon. Reads town.

Grim - who is this guy?

CDB - I always get town reads from this guy when he is in a game, I think I remember seeing him scum once during the last marathon. I'm putting him at null until I look closer at him.

Sunny - need to look closer here as well. Null.

[Slandaar]

OK lets start a new trend.
We will each grade people based on content from TODAY only (note your grade post counts as content) and the person(s) who are in the bottom 3 most often are the only lynch candidates for the day.

So my list is thus;

1. Slandaar - Continually provides amazing content.
2. Stu - this was close between 2 and 3 but I just feel Stu's effort edges it
3. Lucky - produced some fine posts however the competition for top 3 is fierce and only lost out narrowly to #2
4. Shamrock - Sparse content posting but there is some stuff there.
5. CDB - he named a suspect
6. Sunny - Well...he proddodged.
7. Grim - Not posted once.

So, this means todays lynch is currently between CDB/Sunny and Grim. Not going to end up well for CDB with that competition.

(the real point to this post is to demonstrate how 3 people have literally not posted once which is ridiculous and Shamrock has done little more)

[Slandaar]

Grim - who is this guy?

How much of the game have you read Lucky?

[Lucky2u]

Grim - who is this guy?

How much of the game have you read Lucky?

It was a joke because he hasn't been here for almost two weeks.

[Slandaar]

Fair enough. Answer the question anyway.

[StupendousMan]

I don't see how only looking at today will help, but if you believe it will then here is my list:

1. Slandaar - I would be lying if I put myself above Slandaar. His posts spark good discussion and his activity is great.
2. Me - Awesome VCA of Lucky and awesome activity.
3. Shamrock - Hasn't posted much, but he made a few useful posts.
4. Lucky - Posts often, hasn't provided much good content.
5. Sunny - "Hey I'm still here guys!"
6. CDB - Offers a lynch suggestion with nothing to back it up.
7. Grim - POST, DAMN YOU.

@Lucky- Please, show us where this case is that I made against someone else. I only see my case for you. Trying to discredit me by calling me stupid isn't going to work if you can't back it up.

[Lucky2u]

@Stupendous. First allow me to apologize for "Stupid Man". I have been playing mostly from mobile and that was an autocorrect. I had no idea what you were talking about until I went back and saw it. Second, I was referring to your obvscum read of the Red Dragon slot inhabited now by CDB. I shouldn't have said you were making a case, but it is certainly the opinion you expressed as Slandaar has pointed out. Following on that line... Slandaar's list has the three people he wants to lynch last and you made a list copying him but I am not in your bottom three, Sunny, CDB, and Grim are. Why is your vote still on me then and not them? Further more, the RD slot you think is obvscum is apparently not redeemed by CDB who occupies it because you have him at #6. So you still think that slot is scummy, even MORE than me, but you vote me?

[StupendousMan]

Slandaar asked for a list based on today's content. It doesn't provide much room for flexibility because of the inactivity, so the 3 most inactive are obviously going to be on the bottom. Like I said, I don't see the point of making such a list. In terms of overall scumminess you are still my top read.

[Slandaar]

My list isn't who I want to lynch its an activity based list, not scum based list, I made it to jab at the inactives more than anything, I didn't expect you to post your own (Stu) but thats fine!

Anyways back on topic, Lucky could you answer my question please.

[StupendousMan]

OK

lets start a new trend.
We will

each

grade people based on content from TODAY only

(note your grade post counts as content) and the person(s) who are in the bottom 3 most often are the only lynch candidates for the day.

So, this means

todays lynch

is currently between CDB/Sunny and Grim. Not going to end up well for CDB with that competition.

My list

isn't who I want to lynch

its an activity based list, not scum based list, I made it to jab at the inactives more than anything,

I didn't expect you to post your own

(Stu) but thats fine!

Anyways back on topic, Lucky could you answer my question please.

Please explain this. Either I misread your post or you contradicted yourself.

[Slandaar]

1185 wasn't a serious post.

[SunnyDays]

I agree with CDB, I think it's very important to consider the possibility that Shamrock already knew that Ztife was scum given the progression of his push yesterday.

I have a good handful of townreads right now from reading yesterday specifically. Yesterday's replace-ins definitely made me feel more excited about this game to see what he's contributed so far ^^

[SunnyDays]

On further consideration, I'm actually going to put off an in-depth look at Red Dragon until he gets replaced, partly because his ISO is long and gives me a headache and partly because I'm wondering if my scumread on him is because he annoys me and I want to see if the replacement changes my impressions of the slot.

If anyone transitioned into the Ztife wagon randomly when the pressure was on and went full swing from there is was Shamrock. He even implied it was a temp push until he could look at CDB and then CDB replaced in and it never happened

I would want this or Slandaar lynched today. Slandaar's been leading the team around by the leash and hasn't ended up doing ANYTHING helpful for us. All he's done is make us massclaim and waste time arguing when people like Shamrock are MIA

[Grimgroove]

If I can still play, I'm back. Reading up now. Just got back from traveling and had no internet access.

[Grimgroove]

It seems as if I haven't missed a thing. And I'm still top poster after my complete inactivty Congrats on the latest lynch though.
Too bad I wasn't part of the Ztife lynch. I was certain I had placed a vote on him before leaving but I had forgotten to do it.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 4#p5165344

I haven't seen any reasons to change my views from above. Lucky2u made himself even scummier with that hammer which could not be more obvious when it coems to a vote being a bus.

The Stupendous vs Slandaar thing is not good for town, since I really feel they are both town.

CDB replacing Red Dragon hasn't changed my views on that slot in the least.

VOTE: Lucky2u

[Lucky2u]

Hey grim welcome back! Not a fan of that vote, but good to see you.