New York 152 Niiightless Game Over!

[Blonde Doctor]

Pine is probably scum by the way.

Why?

sup.
VOTE: noraaa
seems like she has the urge to post for the sake of posting.

What makes this scummy?

[Blonde Doctor]

Sorry for the triple post; I just realized this was to me...

elliot-

1. hypocritical to vote someone that is policy lynching for their policy lynch I mean it's kind of...spells itself out.

2. I'm not trying to look anything, nor am I trying to save anyone from any lynch. I was examining red's position. And yes, I figure it would be known before he died, and I wondered if he'd still want him dead regardless of his role.

1. I did NOT get that.

2. This makes sense, and I actually like that line of inquiry.

[Major Minor]

Whoa, this game is way more hostile than the ones I've played on here so far. I hate playing catch-up but I didn't realize the game had started already, so I'm doing a brief runthrough.

redFF & noraa's back and forth on pages one and two and three seem rather town-on-town. I think red's joking intent seems genuine, and I think noraaa trying to latch onto it is an earnest attempt to try and decipher something, albeit misplaced.

crypto's postings make me think he's taking the game as a joke instead of actually trying to play, like when he claims he's a cop with an innocent on Vifam.

My head! It hurts! I can't keep track of who is replying to who in this redFF/Vifam/noraaa/crypto mess, but I don't feel like any of it is particularly scummy or worthy of a vote.

mb53's "Are you fucking kidding me?" post kind of fits my sentiments regarding Pine's posts so far in the game.

@Matias: What about redFF's posting style makes him scummy? He just seems to be dicking around, having a laugh, but not really taking it seriously yet. I get the same vibe from crypto's posts, and neither seem incredibly scummy.

@noraaa: Who is Elliot?

I agree with BBmolla: Pine is probably scum. The way he just stirred shit up then left under the slightest pressure doesn't sit well with me at all.

Pine only has three posts in the game so far: one that asks for a policy vote on crypto, one that mistakenly (and exaggeratedly) calls crypto's post an "ad hom attack" when it wasn't, and one that simply asks if Blonde Doctor is an alt. He's just skirting by in the shadows, not saying much of anything, hoping nobody will notice.

I noticed!

Vote: Pine

[noraaa]

My head! It hurts! I can't keep track of who is replying to who in this redFF/Vifam/noraaa/crypto mess,

lol yeah I think we were all hyper and we had been back and forthing in several threads at that point and it carried over here.

Elliot is Blonde Doctor, I was making a joke, I'll stick with the real name from now on. xD (scrubs if you're not a tv watcher)..I was going to use a different name every time ALA Dr. Cox but I'll refrain.



Question for all the people who said "and this is scummy because?" Do you agree or disagree with that assessment of my posting?


leaving for the beach in like, 10-40 minutes soooo gimme while we got it.

[noraaa]

Nice to see people coming out of the woodwork. See, crypto.. we will have a real game. (I'm a real boy!... god I'm tired).


If anyone thinks they're going to want to leave the game, can you do it sooner rather than later?

[redFF]

<3 vifam

[noraaa]

an earnest attempt to try and decipher something, albeit misplaced.

I would argue that something of the sort is never misplaced if it leads you closer to the truth.


I like Blonde Doctor's recent posting, but it's just been accepting answers and trying to flesh out what others (Matias) means by something so it's not super deep. I do think (s)he is overreacting to Matias.

[Ythan]

Vote Count

3 redFF (BBmolla, Vifam, Hiraki) L-6
1 Vifam (redFF)
1 crypto (Pine)
1 Matias (Blonde Doctor)
1 Blonde Doctor (Matias)
1 noraaa (BK201)
1 Pine (Major Minor)
0 Hiraki
0 inte
0 BBmolla
0 BK201
0 Major Minor
0 mb53
0 Mogri
0 Nobody Special
0 VitorMachado

7 Not Voting (mb53, Mogri, Nobody Special, noraaa, VitorMachado, crypto, inte)

9 to lynch
Deadline May 10th

[BBmolla]

I'm gonna go ahead and say this game is mountainous.

This seems like an impossible thing to know by someone who is town and serves no useful purpose at this point in the game. Confirm vote.

If Red is scum, Major is probably scum with him.

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

[mb53]

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

I don't follow. meta reasons?

Vote: Major Minor

I don't like the timing of the vote (right after BB said pine was scum) and I don't like the reasons for the vote ("He's just skirting by in the shadows, not saying much of anything, hoping nobody will notice." When the he has proposed a policy lynch/the game hasn't even been up for 24 hours).

[BBmolla]

I don't follow. meta reasons?

Last nightless he was harping Scumhunter at this point in time I believe. It's gone so I can't link it unfortunately.

Yeah Major's agreement was pretty bad, especially with everyone being so inactive.

[redFF]

I'm gonna go ahead and say this game is mountainous.

This seems like an impossible thing to know by someone who is town and serves no useful purpose at this point in the game. Confirm vote.

If Red is scum, Major is probably scum with him.

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

last 2 games were

[redFF]

I'm gonna go ahead and say this game is mountainous.

This seems like an impossible thing to know by someone who is town and serves no useful purpose at this point in the game. Confirm vote.

If Red is scum, Major is probably scum with him.

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

last 2 games were

[redFF]

I'm gonna go ahead and say this game is mountainous.

This seems like an impossible thing to know by someone who is town and serves no useful purpose at this point in the game. Confirm vote.

If Red is scum, Major is probably scum with him.

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

last 2 games were

[Nobody Special]

Inte is going to be hard to read this game

I was going to say, initially, "Just like you?" but then I saw your post 133 and you're better now. Just be either really townie or really scummy so I know. Okay? Okay.

My head! It hurts! I can't keep track of who is replying to who in this redFF/Vifam/noraaa/crypto mess, but I don't feel like any of it is particularly scummy or worthy of a vote.

Perhaps you should go back and read it again.



red, stop that. It's annoying.

[redFF]

I didnt mean to

[BK201]

I"m probably failing for always being on my ipod in class.

I'm going to minimize you guys and try to work on my paper for a while.

Me? I'm not on anyone's side but the truth.


(cue law and order theme song)

That first post seemed unprompted, like she felt the pressure to keep her presence up. Whether or not she is mafia might depend on how she usually plays, but have never played with her so idk how that is.

[mb53]

Oh no, anything but talking like a normal person in a mafia game

She's actually contributing stuff.

[crypto]

Tell me, what did YOU find scummy about redFF...or are you also choosing to throw vague accusations out there and hope that someone latches on?

Where did I FOS redFF? Where did I throw out vague accusations?

crypto's postings make me think he's taking the game as a joke instead of actually trying to play, like when he claims he's a cop with an innocent on Vifam.

VOTE: Major Minor

[BK201]

I'm gonna go ahead and say this game is mountainous.

This seems like an impossible thing to know by someone who is town and serves no useful purpose at this point in the game. Confirm vote.

If Red is scum, Major is probably scum with him.

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

Well Red and Pine seem kind of scummy, especially Pine's posts. I don't see how if Red is scum, how that makes Pine probably scum though.

Oh no, anything but talking like a normal person in a mafia game

She's actually contributing stuff.

wat, man you missed the point.

[Matias]

policy lynch that isn't really pushed, yeah okay. That's not stubbornness, that's panning to everyone

I'm not sure on red's scum game including taking D1 statements too seriously but calling noraaa's post is as serious as they come.

I knew I posted this somewhere and that I wasn't crazy and I told you it was the post after

well I was wrong, it was the

same fucking post

Unvote, Vote: Blonde Doctor

because you're reaching.

Your first comment was effectively "if you missed it, too bad so sad, you will never know!" I still do not understand what posts you are actually talking about, and would have graciously accepted being pointed in the right direction when I asked politely the first time. Furthermore, you claim it is OBVIOUS, but continue to not explain it. You throw out some whimsical comment about how he is "too serious" but have still failed to offer up an explanation of HOW after two requests now. The only response is pointing to a quote which does not adequately answer the questions I have asked, only to be followed up by a vote for...not understanding what was so obvious?

What did he call Noraaa's post?

What was scummy about it?

Why are you still insisting that we see the scummy part of it ourselves instead of offering your own interpretation?

I am sorry, but you seem more and more desperate as you post...

I'm not going to hold anyone's hand. My reasons were not too vague if one could just ISO red or even, you know, read the first few pages of the fucking game

Let me ask you something: Had I not posted that "the reasons write themselves", would you have even thought to vote me?

[Matias]

@Matias: What about redFF's posting style makes him scummy? He just seems to be dicking around, having a laugh, but not really taking it seriously yet. I get the same vibe from crypto's posts, and neither seem incredibly scummy.

I find it completely different. red took the first few posts of the game wayyyy more seriously than he should have.

[Pine]

Blonde Doctor: Are you an alt?

Blonde Doctor, please answer this question. It's actually important.

[BBmolla]

Blonde Doctor: Are you an alt?

Blonde Doctor, please answer this question. It's actually important.

Pushing a minor question as he apparently can't read the whole game until it's answered.

Pine are you even trying

[Pine]

Yes, I am, actually. The game has been active for just over 27 hours and is chock full of fluff. Forgive me if I don't really feel like getting it on me. That question is important, and I want an answer.

However, I'm quite caught up, I just don't see much worth commenting on. Crypto is being a spammy ass, noraa is working way too hard to defend him while being spammy herself, and you're pushing something you (falsely, though probably genuinely) think is a good meta point on me. Vifam and Red are dicking around a bit scummily, though Red tends to come off a bit scummy regardless of his actual alignment. Matias LOOKS like he's being productive and focused, but he's really good at faking it.

In other words, it's still early RVS. The only solid tell I've spotted so far has to do with the question I asked Blonde Doctor, which I will explain in full when I get an answer.

@Blonde Doctor

: Fail to answer my question in your next post, and I will assume you are being intentionally evasive.