pd mafia new thread (game over)

[Nachomamma8]

every one listened to me and no one listened to you because your reasoning was so bad
i'm the greatest

[Regfan]

i'm way greater than you because i got sesq lynched

I did too! And I didn't town read any mafia. Learn to play please.

[Desperado]

yup

[Nachomamma8]

so sesq got betrayed?

yeah i assume so

[xyzzy]

basically, the premise behind this game was that if the mafia could completely win the whole thing without either of them ever almost dying, they would win, and they collectively were able to survive multiple deaths, but once either of them avoided death even once, they'd be forced into a prisoners' dilemma scenario. hence pd mafia.

[Nachomamma8]

i'm way greater than you because i got sesq lynched

I did too! And I didn't town read any mafia. Learn to play please.

i didn't either i just lied to get mafia lynched

[Nachomamma8]

that's what super high level players do you wouldn't understand

[Ms Columbo]

Wow, this speed thing is not for me. But glad I tried. Scum or town, I can't process that fast. Kudos to all you who can.

[xyzzy]

and just to be clear, yes, ms columbo betrayed sesq, which was why she won

ideally the goal was for the betrayed scum to have an uphill battle but still be able to win; it didn't work out that way, but that was the theory for how it could go down!

[Regfan]

that's what super high level players do you wouldn't understand

I still have some to learn then.

[ConnorJC]

I think a pd multiball game could be interesting

[ConnorJC]

and just to be clear, yes, ms columbo betrayed sesq, which was why she won

ideally the goal was for the betrayed scum to have an uphill battle but still be able to win; it didn't work out that way, but that was the theory for how it could go down!

I don't think it really works that well, as lynchproof town doesn't make much sense.

[Regfan]

Did mafia get a night kill while being in PD? If so was I shot?

[xyzzy]

I think a pd multiball game could be interesting

agreed! I basically ran this as a proof of concept for the role, because I think used sparingly it could be the sort of thing that would work well in a larger game.

[Nachomamma8]

Wow, this speed thing is not for me. But glad I tried. Scum or town, I can't process that fast. Kudos to all you who can.

cristi the key to winning in fast games is to tunnel Regfan in every game you play with him

[FakeGod]

We won because of amazingly badass hunter of scum,

Nachomamma8

, a proud member of

FakeGod's Fantastic Federation

.

[WhemeStar]

your federation didn't do anything. rip

[xyzzy]

whemestar was targeted by the nightkill, but because sesq no longer had a factional kill, the kill didn't go through. basically, the timing I used was that the scum kill was the very last thing that would happen, and it checks to make sure the scum still have a kill before it happens.

[ConnorJC]

your federation didn't do anything. rip

^

[Nachomamma8]

federation voted scum and basically owned the whole time
so please kindly get out

[WhemeStar]

well this marathon game was fun, i wanna play more of them now

[Sesq]

i am mafia

LITERALLY

every

single

marathon

game.

[xyzzy]

and just to be clear, yes, ms columbo betrayed sesq, which was why she won

ideally the goal was for the betrayed scum to have an uphill battle but still be able to win; it didn't work out that way, but that was the theory for how it could go down!

I don't think it really works that well, as lynchproof town doesn't make much sense.

that's a fair point, yeah; I left a few minutes between the lynch being achieved and revealing the non-death to leave open the possibility of a governor, but you're right that unless players assume that sort of possibility, it'll look weird.

[Nachomamma8]

but yeah this marathon left me wanting more
i think the pd situation could possibly be interested in multiball but probably not in one team; one team is predictable and here it seems like if your scumteam is doing badly you betray and if you're not you cooperate

[Nachomamma8]

and just to be clear, yes, ms columbo betrayed sesq, which was why she won

ideally the goal was for the betrayed scum to have an uphill battle but still be able to win; it didn't work out that way, but that was the theory for how it could go down!

I don't think it really works that well, as lynchproof town doesn't make much sense.

that's a fair point, yeah; I left a few minutes between the lynch being achieved and revealing the non-death to leave open the possibility of a governor, but you're right that unless players assume that sort of possibility, it'll look weird.

i thought about a governor but it didn't make sense for town governor to throw things to a no lynch without saying or implying anything