Mini 1483: Finagling of Flitter Hills

[Feel It]

Can't believe I missed the Bowser lynch

[Smudger]

Attention. Smudger

has

a gun.

From now on, I'll post a list of the people I've checked so that you guys can organise your thoughts more easily.

Spoiler: Results

N1

Feel It

does not have a gun

N2

Smudger

has a gun

ummm I don't?

[notreallygood]

Attention. Smudger

has

a gun.

From now on, I'll post a list of the people I've checked so that you guys can organise your thoughts more easily.

Spoiler: Results

N1

Feel It

does not have a gun

N2

Smudger

has a gun

ummm I don't?

You do. You do have a gun.

[Smudger]

well I know of no reason why I would have a gun?

[notreallygood]

Claim your role then.

[Smudger]

one shot bullet proof townie

[notreallygood]

I don't quite believe you.
1. Your result shows that you've really got a gun.
2. Bulletproof townie is a very scummy role to claim.

Or, maybe bulletproof counts as having a gun? Does anyone have any ideas?

[Titus]

Smudger please post your flavor if that is legal.

I threw a Grey Goose fueled party last night. Seriously, I am a joat. I don't care to reveal what I did. Make the scums kill me before they hit our PRs.

VOTE: Smudger

[notreallygood]

Sorry, Smudger. Facts speak louder than words. You have a gun. That's the fact.
VOTE: Smudger

[Smudger]

There are many reasons someone would have a gun other than Mafia. I don't have any of those reasons. I know I am not scum so why You would see that I have a gun is beyond me. The only thing I can think of is a commute or redirect? The other thing that does not add up is Titus. Seriously are you all accepting this claim?

Admitted to the Don kill, so what does that tell us? Titus has or had a kill action, so?

Then a JOAT claim? convenient really to claim that. State you will "heal someone" then say you did not do it, then there is no Mafia kill and I have a gun after Titus FoS me end of D1. Beast who did you track?

[Smudger]

Titus what more than what I have given can I give?

*off topic, Grey Goose, seriously good vodka and not cheap... Classy, hope your head explodes though *

[Paperscraps]

Lazy scum I guess.

So NRG, what did you get on Smudger?

It is obvious who Beast tracked.

So either Beast and NRG are lying or Smudger is lying.

VOTE: Smudger

[beastcharizard]

I made sure I had the first post today so you all couldn't question my role anymore. And yes I did track NRG, like I said I would. There is no way it was a redirect because I was told who NRG visited.

This is a lot of votes fast. While they all make sense are we sure we want to end the day so quickly? We might be able to find the other scum if we talk more.

[Huntress]

It is obvious who Beast tracked.

So either Beast and NRG are lying or Smudger is lying.

I think it's out of the question that Beast and NRG are scum ganging up on town Smudger. That would be suicidal at this stage of the game. It's just possible that Beast is a scum tracker who is bussing his partner knowing that town nrg has checked him, but it wouldn't make sense for scum nrg to out his partner like that so he seems fairly solidly town now.

Intent to vote Smudger

(Not actually voting to avoid a premature hammer.)

If Smudger flips town I'm going to be very suspicious of Titus as a one-shot redirector or framer could well be part of a scum joat's role.

There is no way it was a redirect because I was told who NRG visited.

It depends how the redirect works. If ngr checked Smudger but was given a result that related to another player and was not told about the redirect he would have a false result.

[sthar8]

I absolutely want to vote Smudger, but will wait for a votecount. I'm not thrilled with the end of day chatter yesterday, and in my mind it leaves beast not completely confirmed. I'm totally willing to play follow the cop for now, though.

[Elyse]

What happened to having beast claim his track first?

Anyway yay scum #2 probably found. I thought we were going to lose this.

[sthar8]

Elyse, he did.

My lingering paranoia aside, Beast is probably town.

Our lynch today is Smudger.

That means our investigation pool is {me, Elyse, huntress, paper}

Please do not announce who you are going to investigate in thread.

I believe that a town win from this point is inevitable. We may require a massclaim tomorrow, but this one's pretty much solved.

@Titus- Your play this game has been

incredibly

risky, but it appears to be paying off. Kudos.

It doesn't matter, but my current scumlist is:

Huntress- Based on associatives from bowser and smudger. If you're the scum, you basically replaced into an unwinnable situation, which sucks.

Paper- Based on how well Titus's claim gambits are working.

Elyse- Has an element of association with smudger, but if she bussed Bowser it was very aggressively.

[Elyse]

Oh I missed that nvm

[Elyse]

And yes I agree Huntress is most likely the last scum, followed by Paperscraps.

[Elyse]

And I'll still be paranoid about someone lying until massclaim but meh.

[beastcharizard]

If I am not mistaken Smudger is at L-2.

[sthar8]

Has anyone not checked in? And does anyone have anything else that we need to talk about before the day ends?

[beastcharizard]

Everyone has checked in. Feel It's post was weird to me.

[Toomai]

Spoiler: Flavour

"Sheldon has a gun." Malinda's report immediately summoned a flurry of votes to boot him off the mortal coil.

Votecount D3-1

Smudger	L-2	3	Titus, notreallygood, Paperscraps
beastcharizard	L-5	0	—
Bowser	L-5	0	—
Titus	L-5	0	—
Elyse	L-5	0	—
Huntress	L-5	0	—
Paperscraps	L-5	0	—
sthar8	L-5	0	—
Feel It	L-5	0	—
notreallygood	L-5	0	—

Not voting:

Smudger, beastcharizard, Elyse, Huntress, sthar8, Feel It

Current deadline

08/10/2013 23:06 (EDT)
(expired on 2013-10-08 23:06:00)
8.89 days available for Day extension requests

[Smudger]

Seems strange to me that you are all so gullible.... Anyway the word 'Vengeful' means what?

VOTE: Titus