Wait, I can still do something.
The following part will be relevant only if Cheery flips town.
In that case – though I think we've, or, let's be honest,
you've
found the right one – my reads are the following right now:
Sthar is most probably town. Or at least, I can remember that I thought Broodking was town. That's my main argument.
I'm almost sure that Guyett is town. He was on the Chevre wagon. Misaka wagon – oops, he was there, that's a caveat (?). During the Riddleton wagon he voted for Konowa. In general, his posts have been town, I think.
So, in this case EPM is the scum. Missing the Chevre wagon. He was on the Misaka wagon. Though, missing the Riddleton wagon and voted for Konowa. (Caveat?) Plus, his hammer and the fact that he is willing to want Guyett.
Remember these, because it's very likely that I won't survive the Night. (And, to tell the truth, I deserve that Nightkill.) If Cheery flips town and I'm still here next Day (which is not too probable in my opinion) I'll have more time for re-reading and analysing everything once more.
And I hope I haven't f-cked up everything with this post now.