Mini 1667: Dr. McNinja McMafia [GAME OVER]

[SloppyJoe]

I'm not hammering. Boo can hammer and then X/X mafia team will win.

[Salamence20]

Youre playing against auto

[lalaladucks]

Sala won't lynch Boo right now

[lalaladucks]

If scum won't bus we need all townies on the lynch wagon. Sloppy did you read the PB fiasco? Any conclusions? I'll do a Boo wagon cause she is scum but Sala wants ~RIP on a platter~ and he hasn't claimed a role despite multiple requests which is suss af

[SloppyJoe]

Yeah I don't see how Boo is being scummy so reference specific posts if there are any. You all see pretty chillax considering that a Kit/Boo team is possible. Way to go town.

[Salamence20]

Its not Boo/Kats. I think Boo would be smarter than that to jump on with Kats as buddies

[Katsuki]

Yeah I don't see how Boo is being scummy so reference specific posts if there are any. You all see pretty chillax considering that a Kit/Boo team is possible. Way to go town.

your stupidity is unfathomable

[lalaladucks]

Sloppy did you read the PB fiasco? Any conclusions?

[Salamence20]

Let me explain in detail since Joe just doesnt get it.

Ducks is town based on his role and I believe the Tracker confirmed that hes a motivator.
Joe is town becuase he had the opportunity to hammer Kats and RIP.
Im town because if I was scum, Kats would have been lynched.

Leaving Katsuki, Boo, and RIP.

RIP and Katsuki voted each other, so I doubt its RIP/Kats
Boo hopped on Kats vote on RIP, and looking at it it seems scummy, I dont think Boo would do that if Kats was her buddy, so its not Boo/Kats

So the last combo is Boo/RIP.

Boo was willing to bus, and then a seemingly odd unvote instead of persuading us to vote RIP.

RIP is confirmed scum because Boo and Kats arent buddying up in mylo.

That leaves the last scum in Boo/Kats.

Boo will either JK Kats (town; Kats is scum), or No-Kill (Scum; but we have a mislynch so we can lynch both Kats/Boo).

So again, unless you believe there is scum in lalala, me, or Joe, Or Boo was stupid to wagon with her scumbuddy, RIP is confirmed scum.

[lalaladucks]

uh so hey guys

grapes is a decent scumhunter

pretty good really

I ISO'd grapes and found some interesting things

aero is town, house could be town

VOTE: lucianroy

that chainsaw, though

oh look grapes thinks that Lucian (RIP) is scummy and we think RIP is scummy - Sloppy Joe let's lynch this scummy gummy bear hey?

House, I've never played a game with aero before. But he picked up on lucians white knighting of soren about the same time I did. I.E. same wavelength.

grapes commenting on scummy stuff Lucian did

It was particularly bad for me because it was way over done for a meta read. Borderline buddy - which came before they've even interacted.

Then he used it to justify a vote on house ie the chainsaw.

oh more observations of Lucian's scummishness this is nice

p-edit for Grapes, Soren and I are buddy-buddies, not scum buddies. I voted the person who was voting my one town-read. That just seemed logical.

How?

You think somebodies town so everyone voting for them has to be scum?

I'm not seeing the town motivation for that.

That's called WKing and buddying. Scum motivated. Top on the fact everything soren has posted so far looks pretty null.

Like he literally used spamming the thread with fluff questions as a reason to town read him. Pretty strange because that's easy as fuck meta to replicate anyway.

oh ma gosh look how scummy Lucian issss did many scummy things and they look really bad now that we have a decent number of flips

house your reads are garbage

grapes was absolutely correct with this - none of House's scumreads were actually scum

It seemed like a decent way to insert myself into the game since everyone's vote during that stage was kind of jokish/silly. If I could present reasons why I find someone town, and look at the votes on people voting them, deeming them to be on a town player, I voted the person voting that town player. It's mostly to see what they do/ how they react to it. Scum would make a big deal about it, deny it, but not really take action against it, as they want to "lay low." House just OMGUS'd me right away, but later I figured out it was mostly a reactional jab from him going at players who jabbed him. It was a semi-RVS vote that served its purpose, and I'm reading house as town right now.

As for Soren, he's still pretty town in my opinion from what he's presented in-game so far.
Except for his read on house. I just think house screwed up by placing that one game there. Soren is still going after it.

The back pedaling commences.

grapes said Lucian did scummy stuff, and oh look he did how wonderful pls lynch RIP

I think Soren's read is bullshit. I wouldn't count him as having a good read, if that's what you are doing. If other players were concerned enough with House's scum play to pile on him in RVS, I doubt that scum House would make a mistake like that. It doesn't fit the image that's forming of him. The constant push seems too easy to make, his defense of Suzune is worrying but I can't make out if it's just over protective or buddying and WKing. I like House for town. I like Farside's line of questioning and I dont like the people who've used Soren's "friendliness meta". I'll pull the quotes when I'm home. Doesn't mean I'm going to stop questioning though, I disagree about questions becoming circular.

i don't really think his read is that substantial as well, for it's not really a read at all. I think House just made that one mistake when he tried to bring up Aero's meta. I'm not too worried about his slight defense of Suzu. They've played a lot of games with each other as well. Your town read on house is mutual, but I'd have to look at farside more.

Alright, this is some actual stuff. This is good, I like this. More of this. Please.
UNVOTE: Blankface

Ps. Soren and Suzu are friends as well.

This back down off of blankface was too easy.

Some wifom bullshit about house to justify a town read - likes farsides questions - doesn't like people using soren's 'friendlyness meta' (aka you lucian) and sorens not alignment indicitve defense of suzune having her reads being called shit is 'worrying'

Your push and everything in 241 is looking kinda fake because there's nothing compelling at all in blankface's 244 to really justify it.

hey, fake is scummy and yeah let's lynch RIP because grapes is a good scum catcher in fact the demonfruit is almost a dream catcher tbh

also bookitty's hedge and subsequent hop on to me is totally skeeeeeetchhhhhhh

I don't support a grapes lynch. I don't see scum openly admitting that they are going to phone it in and I don't see scum behaving in such a hostile way when they were under suspicion. I could be wrong there, but I don't think so.

super shallow and all around bad reason to town read somebody plus the 'i could be wrong' which is fucking wishy washy hedge ughhhhhhh this is probs scum guys

I looked at Farside's comments on grapes and his/her non-response about it, and I agree with her about the cognitive dissonance. I don't know if it's fake, but it's for sure confused and nonsensical.

ima dude btw

also my non response might be because i haven't posted since then? like this is pretty weak sauce here this could be scum

makes me wanna keep my vote on soren though because this person is like turning a blind eye to that wagon while readily riding on just about everyone else

and the vote on soren looks like distancing out the ass - like coupled with the 'oh i was just voting you to see if people followed me' just screams easy turnaround read + distancing could be buddies for sureeeeee

oh my gosh

Becky, look at her butt

NO WAY - grapes thought Boo was scum and wowzies! Boo is scum which I can see now how good is the demonfruit, really, scum team wrapped up nicely so early

Spoiler: can you even believe this

lala ducks vote is pretty bad but not really convinced that slot is scum

farside seems town

b

o

o

k

i

t

t

y

i

m

l

i

k

e

8

5

%

o

n

f

o

r

b

e

i

n

g

s

c

u

m

l

u

c

i

a

n

l

u

r

k

i

n

g

o

u

t

d

e

a

d

l

i

n

e

a

n

d

c

o

m

p

l

e

t

e

l

y

a

v

o

i

d

i

n

g

v

c

a

i

s

s

k

e

t

c

h

y

a

f

house i still think is town sadly

grapes is a v cool demonfruit with v good reads eh

Everybody's snark is different so it's kinda like comparing apples and oranges for you and house.

But less than a day left it's pretty much me or vysepresident. So, I'd just like people to ball up and pick a wagon. Like I don't want to have to self hammer just for us to get a lynch today but this activity right now is sorta making think that might actually happen.

Right now there's scum on my wagon guaranteed.

(hint it's bookitty

or maybe this peacebringer fella who hasn't impressed me, like I didn't even catch the post where he voted me) I could flashwagon either of them no questions asked.

Also of note that bookitty hops on me without batting an eye when peacebringer/aero whom she's presumable scumreading hops on as well scum for sure but that might have to wait until tomorrow)

At least the vyse wagon looks relatively town driven to me.

Like suzune is probs town, im town, dex is nullish town and house is pretty town like it's a pretty cool wagon in my totally unbiased opinion.

CAN WE PLEASE JUST ALREADY LYNCH RIP HE IS DEFINITELY SCUM ALSO BOOKITTY FOR TOMORROW

[SloppyJoe]

We don't have tomorrow in any scenario. This is mis-lynch and lose, and you guys are policy-voting.

[SloppyJoe]

Also I figured out who the mafia are.

[Salamence20]

Whatever man.

[SloppyJoe]

Okay I plan on voting for RIP tonight. Going to do a few re-reads first; also going to be a little busy until tonight.

[SloppyJoe]

VOTE: RIP

No guts no glory.

...

...

[SloppyJoe]

BooKitty please be scum.

[Salamence20]

I expect a motivate tonight.

Joe should get something from me

[SloppyJoe]

I really really hope this isn't Kats/Sala but it might be...

[SloppyJoe]

But yeah, BooKitty should have said something (anything). Staying silent is super scummy.

[SloppyJoe]

Well...

So if Kats/Sala is scum, then I've lost... but if Rip is scum then I was VI... shoot.

[Salamence20]

Well...

So if Kats/Sala is scum, then I've lost... but if Rip is scum then I was VI... shoot.

Im town as fuck.

Youre just slow to catch up

[Bookitty]

But yeah, BooKitty should have said something (anything). Staying silent is super scummy.

Seriously? This is why I periodically consider dropping Mafia. Did it escape you that last night was the Game of Thrones finale and that some people have to work during the week? Chill out!

I hope RIP flips scum, but given the absolute train wreck that happened yesterday and this morning, I'm not tremendously optimistic.

[Salamence20]

AtE some more Boo.

Its over.

[Bookitty]

AtE some more Boo.

Its over.

Was it you and Kats or was Lalala scum after all?

[Salamence20]

You And I both know if scum was me and Kats you would have been lynched