Open 595: Elemental Mafia (Town Wins!)

[Ricastle]

Oh right, Flubber. Can you point me to where Con is looking fake?

[Alchemist21]

VC 1.3

(3)Flubbernugget:

ConManMick, Senator, FA_Q2

(2)ConManMick:

Flubbernugget, Wrong Song

(1)Plotinus:

Bellaphant

(1)Choof:

Plotinus

(1)Ricastle:

Lane

(1)Vettrock:

Papi Bear

(1)Bellaphant:

farside

(1)lane0168:

Ricastle

(1)Jeanne:

Vettrock

Not Voting: Jeane11, Spartan117, mnemonicdevice, Choof

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-05-03 12:00:00)

[FA_Q2]

“as I reason?”

I do not understand what you are exactly asking. I assume it is about my vote.

I did not vote in my first one because I thought more people had voted flubber and wanted to know where he was before placing my vote. I realized after I posted that the VC was right there and there was only one vote added after. I was mistaken when I thought he had a fast developing wagon – there just seems to be some interest there.

Your post seemed like the wagon on him was fast, but you never explained what you found scummy or why a concern for a fast wagon.

I clearly explained my reasoning. I gave 2 reasons – the opportunistic move to get a wagon and stating he would move his vote if he got another scum read without giving any motivation to go with it.

As far as fast wagons, they tend to be town because no one is actively resisting them and they can get a lynch before we are ready for one. There is always one "anti-town" townie that is willing to hammer an L-1 for the scum team without reason. That screws town over pretty hard.

I don't see how the second part is scummy.


Bored people can vote bela with me to see if she does something or continue crap posting.

I don’t see a town motivation there and when I asked for one it was ignored. Possibly because he does not have one….

[Alchemist21]

Choof is V/LA until Sunday.

[FA_Q2]

What do you think of con’s excuse? Does it change your suspicions at all?

Also, the OP clearly states that the scum team had communication pre game start. This could be a newbie mistake.

Also, @Spartan, can we get a confirmation on this previous relationship that you two have.

[FA_Q2]

Forgot the damn quote.

Don't know if I make the cut, plot, but I'm new too. Heard about the site in July, forgot about it until a ToS marathon, signed up, shyed away and then came back!
Set up for this game sounded mad so I figured I'd give it a shot.

Speaking of inactives, Spartan is V/LA until tomorrow I think, and hasn't been able to check in. He's got coursework deadlines.

VOTE: ConManMick

Are you RL friends with him? If not this could be a slip because there's no where that he's stated he's V/LA. So this is information that no one has.

What do you think of con’s excuse? Does it change your suspicions at all?

Also, the OP clearly states that the scum team had communication pre game start. This could be a newbie mistake.

Also, @Spartan, can we get a confirmation on this previous relationship that you two have.

[lane0168]

lane, do you agree with FA's suspicions then?

Yeah I think they have merit for sure. I tried saying that in my 142 but I don't think it was clear what I was referring to

[Flubbernugget]

Oh right, Flubber. Can you point me to where Con is looking fake?

Yeah I'm just going to swap brains with farside and magically understand what the fuck she's saying for you

[Ricastle]

ffs...YOU incited her to look into that.

flubber is now a scum read. I don't recall him trying hard to find a purpose to keep is vote on a player (yes meta)
Still think bela is scum. non reaction and newb = scum in my book

can you explain how bella's iso is fake but con's isn't?

So answer the question.

[Flubbernugget]

Because she always complains that shit's fake and I have no idea what that means so I'm trying to put it in terms that people actually use so I can work on making sense of her posts which isn't the easiest thing to do

But being a douche makes you right so idk

[Ricastle]

So you're correlating 'non reaction and newb' with fake?

[Flubbernugget]

No I'm correlating fluff posting with fake

[Bellaphant]

Because I agree with you?

Stating you are willing to sheep a vote that does not even exist and also not vote really seems opportunistic. Then, couple that with:

OK, you want a read? I think, flubber, you're being a tad over pedantic about me not correcting a formatting error. That's a feeble line of investigation, feels like your whole line is an OMGUS vote. My vote will stay put for now.

Gimme one more scum read and ill move my vote over to plot

Why? Why would you move your vote over to plot if you get another vote but stay where you are at if you do not? Give me a town motivation for this that makes sense. O far the only player that looks to be scum is you…

Where is flubber at in the VC? His wagon is moving awfully fast...

UNVOTE:

FA, I do wanna ask you about this. Do you have any other reads? I get your later point about town wagons with no resistance, but I don't necessarily see this as a reason to town-read anyone else on that wagon.

I had to meta flub for my last game. He's ALWAYS weird about rv(q)s. Is there any other reason to think he's scum?


@ric, farside had made the fake comment after my...second(?!) post. Maybe it was the smilies. I didn't really react to it because...wut? Then my non-reaction was an issue. If you wanted something contrived...

[ConManMick]

Do you guys want me to message Spartan again? He was on our Minecraft server for a little bit earlier

[Wisdom]

Do you guys want me to message Spartan again? He was on our Minecraft server for a little bit earlier

Please do not discuss this game out of this thread.

[lane0168]

Yeah Bella is weirding me out... she's asked people for reads or who they think is scum exactly 8 times among other questions posed. Made some vague references about how something could be bad but maybe not. Voted plot cause he might be scum.

Do you have any of your own reads Bella? And what was silly about fa's vote?

[lane0168]

Do you guys want me to message Spartan again? He was on our Minecraft server for a little bit earlier

It's already been stated that someone hoped you wouldn't be modkilled for talking out of thread. Do you really think it would be advisable to do it again? Are you just trying to cover up your slip and prove how much you talk to him in real life?

Seemed pretty clear that talking outside the game is a big no no. We get it. You're know him from other games. Don't talk to him about this game unless it's in this game.

[lane0168]

UNVOTE:

[lane0168]

I can't help but think I believed conman much more before his last post

[lane0168]

Wait. Who the hell is wisdom?

[Wisdom]

I'm your friendly Backup Mod, as per

Also, please welcome Wisdom as our new Backup Mod!

[ConManMick]

Sorry ... Thought I could help with prods, get the wheels turning. Won't mention it again.

[Ricastle]

Didn't you

just

say Spartan was V/LA?

This is actually starting to sound bad.

[Ricastle]

Nvm I can't read.

[Ricastle]

Yeah Bella is weirding me out... she's asked people for reads or who they think is scum exactly 8 times among other questions posed.

That's bullshit. I counted around half as many instances. Six the second time, and that was being generous.

You have a point anyway, but this is blatant exaggeration to make Bella look worse.