In post 130, insanity018 wrote:
@Scripten, So if your role pm said nothing about type of dinosaur = alignment, why did you find Grib's discussion of role flavour 'reasonable'?
Because the way he described his role sounded like the rest of the flavor we've been provided and I could see how he could have made the mistake he did, as town or scum. That's why I said it was not alignment indicative.
In post 190, FinnLaw wrote:Struggling a bit to get involved, we're 8 pages in and half of it was unnecessarily shit about setup that I found confusing, it wasn't needed and has distracted the thread.
Who are you scum-reading and why?
Meta this. Meta that. Meta Everything. Meta is not a good scum-hunting tool. PEOPLE CAN MANIPULATE THEIR META. Stop it. Stop. It. Now.
Instead of asking empty questions that don't actually amount to work, how about you tell us about your thoughts
To avoid the hypocrisy that was almost this post, here are my generalized reads in alphabetic order (as I ISO):
Beck - Doing his usual bumbling. General rule: the more Beck is pissing me off, the likelier he is to be Town. Townish
BBT - I've already stated a case on him. Scummy
Finnlaw - few posts, mostly conciliatory. 96 and 190 are peacekeeping posts, which is usually Town, but can be scum trying to become Town leader. Thoroughly null
Grib - Townread previously explained, but it's a mild one. As much as I don't see a whole lot scummy from him, I don't see much distinctly Townish either. Could possibly be super bussing between him and BBT, but that seems too easy for this early
Insanity - 131 seems her only productive post so far. Everything else has been empty clarification questions and similar. Can't fault that TOO much, this is a fast-moving and annoying game to read
Mathdino - Has posted nothing of consequence since RVS vote
Scripten - Seems to be exercising logic, which is a point in his favor, but is provoking and engaging Beck. The only time I did that, I was non-Town and coasted on number of posts as evidence of doing something. Just barely on the Townish side of null ATM
Yungh0mo - Who? Has not posted of consequence
In post 202, Pine wrote:Instead of asking empty questions that don't actually amount to work, how about you tell us about your thoughts
To avoid the hypocrisy that was almost this post, here are my generalized reads in alphabetic order (as I ISO):
Beck - Doing his usual bumbling. General rule: the more Beck is pissing me off, the likelier he is to be Town. Townish
BBT - I've already stated a case on him. Scummy
Finnlaw - few posts, mostly conciliatory. 96 and 190 are peacekeeping posts, which is usually Town, but can be scum trying to become Town leader. Thoroughly null
Grib - Townread previously explained, but it's a mild one. As much as I don't see a whole lot scummy from him, I don't see much distinctly Townish either. Could possibly be super bussing between him and BBT, but that seems too easy for this early
Insanity - 131 seems her only productive post so far. Everything else has been empty clarification questions and similar. Can't fault that TOO much, this is a fast-moving and annoying game to read
Mathdino - Has posted nothing of consequence since RVS vote
Scripten - Seems to be exercising logic, which is a point in his favor, but is provoking and engaging Beck. The only time I did that, I was non-Town and coasted on number of posts as evidence of doing something. Just barely on the Townish side of null ATM
Yungh0mo - Who? Has not posted of consequence
Comments on eight players. All nine if you count the implicit "Pine-Town lololol" that's missing from the above
This discussion is going nowhere. I'm not arguing about 'who provided the better reads' especially given that you only provided yours because you was asking me to do so ,when in fact, I had already done it.
Meta this. Meta that. Meta Everything. Meta is not a good scum-hunting tool. PEOPLE CAN MANIPULATE THEIR META. Stop it. Stop. It. Now.
This entire exchange reminds me a lot of how BBT interacted with me when we were on a scum team together on day 1. I'm not sure how telling this really is, since he's allegedly aware of his meta, though.
In post 215, Beck wrote:damn, those are the 3 things I said I was going to work on fixing when I returned. I guess it's kind of hard to change your playstyle
Because we are very much the same exact person. This does make your constant assurances that I'm scum make sense, however.
In post 216, Scripten wrote:
This entire exchange reminds me a lot of how BBT interacted with me when we were on a scum team together on day 1. I'm not sure how telling this really is, since he's allegedly aware of his meta, though.
Nah. Pine is the one engaging me, not the other way around.
I'm trying to converse with other players and he is just tunnelling on me.
Meta this. Meta that. Meta Everything. Meta is not a good scum-hunting tool. PEOPLE CAN MANIPULATE THEIR META. Stop it. Stop. It. Now.
BBT, could you give me a per-player reads list real quick? It doesn't matter if most of your reads are null. That should not be surprising considering the levels of activity the game is getting.
I'd really appreciate our resident lurkers coming and actually playing, too. Scum hide behind lurky towns so easily.
Nice, that makes me happy. Not sure why you're townreading Beck, but eh. I'm actually losing a bit of the certainty I had about him being scum due to the way Pine is talking. Can you give me an idea as to why you're townreading Insanity, though?
Yeah, Grib is my top scum-read. I believe he scum-slipped pretty hard, I really do.
I take it you're planning to just votepark me until one of us dies, based on exactly one (1) piece of what you deem to be evidence.
You have still failed to explain why it's an outright scumslip and not a mistake irrelevant to alignment (which it likely is, I could be wrong but I don't know what a scum PM looks like, so).
This does make your constant assurances that I'm scum make sense, however. 